Harry Potter is a fictional character. Sherlock Holmes is a fictional character. Bilbo Baggins is a fictional character. They never existed outside of their authors' (and then readers') imaginations, although in some aspects they may have been modelled on real people.
Jesus of Nazareth, in contrast, is a real person who lived in Galilee and Judea, a couple of thousand years ago. It's hard to find a serious historian who would dispute this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_Jesus
You may not believe every aspect of the "official narrative" (or other stories about him), or agree with their view of his significance. But to call him "fictional" is ridiculous.
We can say this because the major miracles attributed to him are verifiably borrowed from existing legends in other kingdoms.
Rather, historians look at parallels and similarities + timelines to draw lineages between legends of different cultures, and find common patterns that have a tendency to spring forth as emergent phenomena in oral traditions.
This helps tease out original content from borrowed or common themes. And even though originality doesn't imply truthfulness or accuracy, it does narrow the field significantly, separating the possibly-accurate from the definitely-not-accurate.
The Gospel of Mark was a kind of bios (biography) taken from many sources (oral and written), intended to promote the subject's reputation, morals, and preachings rather than as a historical narrative. Most of the narrative linkages are understood by scholars to be pure invention to give continuity (or glue, if you will) for the far more important morals and teachings. The Gospels of Matthew and Luke drew most of their narrative portions from Mark (no need to reinvent the wheel, especially for something so unimportant next to the moral teachings and prophecy).
The apocalyptic writing is understandable given the social and political circumstances it was written under (their utter defeat, the destruction of their temple, and the fact that their messiah still hadn't returned as promised to bring them the ultimate victory).
Unfortunately for the Gospel writers, they did have to square reality with theology, so that their theology is at times threatened by reality. This threat means nothing personal to the historian qua historian (giving them the benefit that they can dispose of their religious or anti-religious inclinations), but it does reveal some important possibilities worth pursuing for history's sake.
For example, Jesus is baptized by John in all four Gospels. But the baptism narrative contradicts a question that any first-time reader will naturally imagine: of what sins does Jesus need to be cleansed? Unsurprisingly, all four Gospels make an earnest attempt to undermine John the Baptist's authority. So why include the narrative? Maybe because it actually happened. We can say the same about Jesus being portrayed as violently confronting the money changers, or something like Matthew 19:17, or even the prevalence of women in Jesus's cohort, all which contradict various theological values of the Gospel writers that are discernible through textual criticism.
This is just yet another criteria in the method of historical Jesus research, albeit one of the more artistic ones.
> The Gospel of Mark was a kind of bios (biography) taken from many sources (oral and written) ...
Many sources indeed... All lying about the existence of a man who was allegedly widely known by both rural and urban Jews and crucified by edict of the state? The hoops you have to jump through to hold fast to the claim that Jesus was not a real person... It's a conspiracy theory whose inverse is "ancient aliens." Isn't it much more reasonable to say that the petroglyphs in Utah were made by humans, and that there is a distinct human basis for Jesus?
Sorry if this doesn't describe you, but: It's clear that most people have an interest in disproving Jesus's existence because of their atheism. I just don't get it. What's so threatening about the historical Jesus? Jesus wasn't the first prophet and he wasn't the last; we see crazy people amass religious followings frequently to this day. That's what I meant by short-circuiting the discussion at "miracles don't happen."
I'm not saying that a messianic revolutionary by the name of Jesus never existed. I'm saying that the writings about him were not written with historical accuracy in mind (that was not their purpose). There will be bits of historical accuracy contained within due to proximity to the actual events, but largely the real person Jesus has been lost to the fictional person Jesus (but oh how cool it would have been to interview him right before his execution!)
Since most of the original sources used to build the gospels are gone, it's difficult to say what is what, or what the motivations of the original sources were. But one cannot take the corroboration of texts written 30-40 years apart as an indication of accuracy. When similar liberties are taken about the JFK assassination, we certainly cry foul!
His words. They may be the words of someone else, misremembering or misquoting him but ultimately what he said had such an impact that people carried his ideas forward for two thousand years.
I've always wanted to do a movie where Jesus was just a man living in a barbaric time, who used a bit of ancient prophecy to get people to listen to him and make the world a little less barbaric. This sort of happens at the end of the film The Invention of Lying, but it's set in modern day.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christ_myth_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus
> Virtually all scholars of antiquity accept that Jesus was a historical figure,[note 1][note 2][4][5][6][7] although not all events mentioned in the gospels (most notably his miracles) are accepted universally.[8][9][10] Standard historical criteria have aided in evaluating the historicity of the gospel-narratives,[11][12] and two events subject to "almost universal assent" are that Jesus was baptized by John the Baptist and crucified by order of the Roman Prefect Pontius Pilate.[9][10][8][13]
The fact that you think the second argument is a strong one alone indicates that you aren't particularly informed about the practice of history. A lot of things are well-established historical fact (to the extent anything can be!) despite not having any contemporaneous records of them. Even entire historical figures.
Untangling those webs of knowledge, influence, bias, motivation, and uncertainty to determine which things are likely true within them pretty is the work historians do. Even with less contested individuals for whom we do have contemporary accounts, we don't just accept those accounts as facts.