News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by pydry on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @05:54AM (#29904723)
You know, I hear this argument a lot for e.g. why Slack is a dog slow electron beast.

The thing is, slack has not been short of time OR money for at least the last 5 years. They could have easily built leaner, faster native apps and customers would have appreciated it.

This "ivory tower" stuff smacks of just world/just market fallacy.

I suspect there are deeper issues here. For example, vendor lock-in inhibiting competition paired with the "electron app team" being a powerful fiefdom within the company.

IME the concealed undercurrent of politics tends to provide a better explanation for many hard to understand decisions at large companies than unexpected technical prudence. Why does Uber's app require 150 developers? Why is Facebook's app such a beast? Why did they create a whole new "lite" app rather than slimming it? Why does Google have 13 messengers?

Reaching for a calm, rational engineering decision to explain each case is tempting, but wrong.

Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by jack_pp on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @06:40AM (#29905039)
So once you have an app up and running, with millions of satisfied users you would hire another team of more expensive developers to build a native app.. for each platform? so make that 2 more teams or rather 4 more teams? (iOS, Mac, Android, Windows)
Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by pydry on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @06:58AM (#29905161)
They're a $24 billion company. Hiring 4 small teams probably shouldnt be too much for them.
Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by tanseydavid on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @11:56AM (#29909376)
...and one PM to manage all 4 teams and ensure that there is no feature-drift between the various OS-target versions. </sarc>

I am really just trying to emphasize that there are tradeoffs lurking everywhere and they are often hidden by assumptions.

Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by Siira on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:45AM (#29917903)
Telegram already does this with a rather small team. Hell, there are even third-party Telegram clients that, while a bit behind the features, eventually catch up with every single one.
Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by Nasrudith on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @08:41PM (#29915748)
You don't get to be a billion dollar company by spending money unnecessarily. The question is never the total size of the company the cost relative to other options.
Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by moonchrome on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @07:05AM (#29905238)
>They could have easily built leaner, faster native apps and customers would have appreciated it.

Example of such apps ? There should be plenty since it easily built.

Re:Is the madness ever going to end? by pydry on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @07:23AM (#29905378)
Telegram? They have decent native messenging apps, I believe.

Or did you mean good desktop apps in general in which case where do I start...? There are thousands.