News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by erulabs on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:13AM (#29903318)
This topic aside, I guess I just feel like if the Hacker community is saying “don’t build things! It’s dangerous! What if someone gets hurt! Go DMV! Put a stop to that!”, then maybe I don’t want to be a Hacker anymore.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by arcticbull on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:13AM (#29903324)
There's good and bad ways to develop new technologies. It is our responsibility to champion the good and call out the bad. If not us, the people who actually understand and build the technology - then who?

[edit] I'm pro EPA too btw, its nice that rivers don't catch fire.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by martindbp on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:40AM (#29904244)
If EPA regulations stood in the way of saving a million lives a year, yeah it would be a bad way to develop new technologies. We know humans are terrible drivers leading to countless tragedies. Tesla FSD is far from working at the moment, nobody is claiming otherwise. But it requires a human supervisor, and this is enforced by a driver facing camera. That combination likely makes it safer than the average driver already today.

What I'm seeing is that Tesla's appraoch, fleet learning, is likely to accelerate the advent of L4. If Tesla can solve this using the existing cheap camera sensors, they can scale this out incredibly fast. This year they are likely to produce upwards of 2 million vehicles, and by 2025 it's likely close to 6-7 million. Even if other self-driving solutions get there first, they have no way of reaching Tesla's scale as they need specialized sensors and partnerships with OEMs etc.

Consider the possibility that I'm right. By stoking fears and getting FSD banned or delayed, many lives would be lost in the name of safety, when there has been no fatality recorded on FSD.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by arcticbull on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @11:32AM (#29908914)
If saving lives were paramount would we not just be advocating for more trains?

I think this is simply a cost-saving measure. They have not developed a sufficiently reliable system, they are marketing it as though it is, and putting it on the road. I strongly suspect that they do not in fact require more data to perfect this system - I suspect they need more sensors. If they do need more data, they're free to obtain it otherwise.

Autopilot has tried to murder me a few times lol.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by jjav on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:16PM (#29912773)
> What I'm seeing is that Tesla's appraoch, fleet learning

I don't want to see that experimental learning happening on public roads which are shared by people who are not willing participants in the experiment.

Every time a Tesla crashes into a barrier killing the driver that is sad, but at least they chose that fate so ok.

When Teslas cause damage to other cars or humans who didn't want to be part of the alpha program, that's criminal.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by Thorentis on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:26AM (#29903404)
I didn't realise part of being a hacker was being okay with endangering lives.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by anonporridge on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:27AM (#29903407)
We all endanger lives every time we get behind the wheel of a manually driven car.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by BoorishBears on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:33AM (#29903450)
We individually endanger lives, presumably the people who made your car have not added it to an army of self-endangering cars.

It's not like there's nothing between 0 safety features and FSD. We could just have passive safety features like AEB and LKA and get a ton of benefit over nothing...

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by gamblor956 on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:42AM (#29903513)
If you endanger lives every time you get behind the wheel of a car, you shouldn't be driving.

Millions of people are able to drive safely, and do, every minute of every day.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by inglor_cz on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @03:03AM (#29903650)
Millions of people think they are able to drive safely. But 9 of 10 crashes are still caused by human error.

73 per cent of American drivers consider themselves above average [0].

[0] https://www.insurancejournal.com/magazines/mag-editorsnote/2...

I don't doubt that there are many safe drivers out there, but probably fewer than we think. With modern cars, you can risk a lot before having an accident.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by mellavora on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:11AM (#29904054)
There was some interesting comment a few months ago about the "human error" aspect of crashes.

Basically saying that the quoted statistic (90% or whatever) is a way to NOT look at how road design contributes to the error.

Earlier on this threat, someone commented that a road marked as 50 mph often has cars driving 150 mph on it, because it is a shortcut which is build like a racetrack. Obviously 150mph in a 50mph zone is human error, but a few simple changes to road design could take away the 150mph attractiveness of this road.

Or see some of the articles on stroads, or badly placed left turns, etc.

FSD might be a step to better road safety, but a focus on designing roads for safety might also be a good step.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by ribosometronome on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:18AM (#29904095)
Sure, and since we're part of the hacker community, we're doing some biohacking on ourselves before getting behind the wheel, right? You know, thc and microdosing LSD for creativity. A few shots of alcohol for easing social situations and anxiety. All while wearing a special VR headset that gives us a 360 degree view from the top of the car, of course. That's safe and not frowned upon when on public roads.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by dekhn on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @10:22AM (#29907567)
many people who build computer systems build systems that endanger lives. It's a tradeoff in modern society.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by mellavora on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:00AM (#29903985)
Yes, if.

If that is what the community is saying.

May I suggest an alternate "if", based not just on your statement, but on the general tone of this whole article?

I just feel like if the Hacker community is saying "react emotionally based on if we like Tesla or not and just yell at each other without trying to communicate", then maybe I don't want to be a Hacker anymore.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by hdhxjsksi on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:46AM (#29903529)
How does revisiting approach to regulate public self-driving test translate to dont build things in your opinion? To me if looks like no one has issues with building or testing, its just the public testing that there are concerns about.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by yumraj on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:57AM (#29903614)
Sure, why do we even need DMV and driver's license. Anyone and of any age should be allowed to drive, since who cares it's dangerous since hackers want it that way. Who is DMV to tell someone whether they can or cannot drive.

While we're at it, let's argue that FDA shouldn't worry about drug/vaccine trials? Perhaps as soon as a company makes something, it should be given to the people, since hackers. I'm sure pharma companies will love that, human lives be damned.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by XenophileJKO on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @05:20AM (#29904518)
It would actually be nice if the FDA just published an opinion and let me make the choice whether I wanted to use the drug or not.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by omegalulw on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @05:35AM (#29904618)
This is such a sad take - "move fast and break things" becomes a bad approach when you are breaking bones. It's always a risk reward tradeoff and in this case it's up to Tesla to demonstrate that the risk is manageable.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by willcipriano on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @05:47AM (#29904682)
Move fast and break your own things, not my things. I don't have equity.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by BoorishBears on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:18AM (#29903352)
Can you point me to a time where $BIGCORP leveraging mass public testing of 5,000 lb heavy machinery to get around actually having to pay for testers was considered part of the hacker ethos?
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by Rygian on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:36AM (#29903471)
What percentage of cars is enough for you to say "mass public testing"?
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by BoorishBears on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:47AM (#29903537)
Why on earth is it supposed to be a percentage of all cars on the road?

If I say I just ate a lot of rice, do I define how much rice I ate by the percentage of global rice consumption I accounted for?

-

Please, 2,000 cars is mass testing.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by martindbp on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @03:52AM (#29903940)
Wholeheartedly agree. I don't give much weight to the negativity on HN anymore. VR bad, crypto bad, Tesla bad, autonomous vehicles bad, billionaires in space bad.

To me it's pretty clear that Tesla's audatiousness in pushing FSD could move up the advent of L4 by years, possibly saving hundreds of thousands of lives, for very little downside. In fact, I believe human+FSD is already safer on average, just due to the fact that FSD requires the driver to watch the road.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by Pyramus on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:27AM (#29904167)
> In fact, I believe human+FSD is already safer on average, just due to the fact that FSD requires the driver to watch the road.

Are you saying that 'Full Self Driving' is safer because it is not full self driving?

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by martindbp on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @04:42AM (#29904256)
Yes, the combination of FSD and human may be safer. Deploying it at scale allows Tesla to accelerate the progress towards true FSD, at which point humans would not have to pay attention.
Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by erulabs on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @01:23PM (#29910823)
It’s genuinely some new form of conservatism. Imagine if the phone phreakers had stopped and given up “because someone might get hurt”. Imagine a hacker forum in the 80s cheering on the FCC. To be clear I don’t care about Tesla here - just the attitude of my peers.

I want my culture back.

Re:DMV ‘revisiting’ its approach to regulating Tesla’s publi... by sidibe on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @09:08AM (#29906460)
> To me it's pretty clear that Tesla's audatiousness in pushing FSD could move up the advent of L4 by years, possibly saving hundreds of thousands of lives, for very little downside. In fact, I believe human+FSD is already safer on average, just due to the fact that FSD requires the driver to watch the road.

I have no idea why that's clear to you. Seems to me from the FSD Beta videos that not only Tesla isn't in the same ballpark yet as the companies that are going for offering geofenced L4, but it doesn't seem to be improving much. Then there's the fact they've handcuffed themselves by widely promising/releasing the product with the hardware customers already have.