News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by anonporridge on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:15AM (#29849093)
Why?
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by tagoregrtst on Saturday January 08, 2022 @08:38AM (#29851543)
Because its a deeply personal piece of information for many people.

Personally, Id rather have my medical history available to the public than my personal wealth or income (and Im loath to give that up!). No one except my wife knows how much I make. In the case of my parents, my mom has never known how much money my dad makes.

They may seem strange to you, it may seem barbaric or backwards. That’s irrelevant - I’m firmly entrenched in this position and wont help you release this data (through my vote, and legal lawsuits, clearly).

You can’t dismiss me as an eccentric American behind the more enlightened Europeans - Im not American, I am and grew up in Europe, I just live in the US.

Nor am I or did I grow up rich. Growing up, my dad whenever my dad was doing the bills he joked he was feeding a blackhole (debt). We never knew how big this hole was, but we knew where it came from - even a hard working engineer has a steep financial hill when you’re from a poor country.

You really must understand ours is a deep seated difference in points of view. My mom has never asked how much my dad made, my dad has yet to tell her. My mom had a vague idea how much she could spend (her guesstimate was very good) my dad never enquired what she spent money on. He himself never spent any money except on us. The result is they never fought over money, the most common marital problem (I guarantee you this. Both my parents would rather be paupers than put money between their relationship - they are both very stoic and devoted to each other). I doubt this would have been the case had my mom ever displayed any interest in money.

So what does making my tax returns or my salary (probably the lowest among my colleagues) publicly available mean to us? It means inviting strangers into our intimate space, more intimate than the fact that I have a rare auto immune disease Ill share with a random person on the internet (anonymized, of course :P ).

You see, there are people who view this information not merely as a means to a more just society (whatever that means anymore) but as a very intimate part of their family life. Just because some cannot see that doesn’t mean it isn't real.

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:14PM (#29853688)
Why consider it intimate data?

Fear it will cause spousal resentment, impact future offers, being targeted by gold diggers or grifters? Wealth tied to identity?

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by tagoregrtst on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:40PM (#29854692)
To summarize my comment, because something as mundane as money is more likely to enter (and therefore effect) into my relationships with others when we know how much we make.

Its hard to be friends with someone who you know makes twice (or half) what you make. But there are many people who I think are cool and would want to have a relationship with that make a lot more/less than I.

Thats also a reason why modesty in our behavior is important - the wealthier person in a relationship shouldn't keep proposing things that are financially difficult for the other

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by secabeen on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#29855033)
That has not been my experience. As a state employee in California, my salary is a matter of public record and has been for years. I have no idea who has looked up my salary, so I don't know what impact it's had on my friendships, etc.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by ramphastidae on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:16PM (#29854419)
Did you read the comment you are replying to? The answer to your question is literally the entire content of the comment.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#29855028)
Maybe I'm just dense but it wasn't clear the motivation for keeping the info secret. It seems implied that fear of spousal conflict was involved.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by ramphastidae on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:44PM (#29855385)
I see. Sorry for my snark. My understanding was that they feel money has a deeply corrupting influence on relationships, and credits the strength of their parents marriage with the fact that they both made a clear effort to avoid taking about money (while still being responsible with it). I don’t think that they are saying that making tax returns public will directly cause more spousal conflict, but it will cause more general corruption of relationships across the board.

I can certainly see that. In my experience, there are very few people who respond appropriately when they learn what someone makes. Rarely is it: “oh, good for them, anyway, moving on …” Most of the time, it’s unhelpful and toxic commentary about whether the person is overpaid/spoiled/poor with money/a sucker or whatever depending on their circumstances. I wish it wasn’t that way but that has been my experience.

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by sanatgersappa on Sunday January 09, 2022 @09:30AM (#29863523)
It can give extortionists / kidnappers a nice list of potential targets.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by WalterBright on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:28AM (#29849160)
Just the other day, there was a thread on HN about how terrible it was that employers could look at a candidate's salary history before making an offer.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by anonporridge on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:53AM (#29849297)
Doesn't this go both ways?

Employees would have perfect visibility into their peer's (and boss's) salaries and it would be impossible for employers to covertly take advantage of people with less leverage and poor negotiation skills?

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by jka on Saturday January 08, 2022 @10:14AM (#29852387)
In some cases equity and share grants could muddy the waters a bit there (salary isn't everything), but yep, I think that if salary transparency commenced, then total compensation transparency would likely follow shortly afterwards.

There's a meme I've heard that it's difficult for some people to discover that their salaries are lower than their peers. I can understand that, but equally I don't totally understand it as an argument for continuing to pay people less. (it might not be the strongest argument against, it's probably worth finding others too)

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by lelandfe on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:57AM (#29849321)
I'm confident that https://www.levels.fyi/ would be updated over night with that info if it became available stateside.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by Skinney on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:47AM (#29849263)
In Norway, this is normally asked during the interview. If the employeer would look up your tax returns, you’d be notified of it and, at least for me, it would be such a huge red flag that I would almost unconditionally decline an offer.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:16PM (#29853710)
Couldn't they just buy the data from companies that scrape it and sell access more discretely?
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by Skinney on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:00AM (#29871788)
You need to login with your BankID (national auth provider) which is bound to your personal id number, and which is illegal to use for machine access, so no.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by gostsamo on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:18AM (#29849427)
I posted this yesterday exactly because of the salaries post. It didn't get lots of attention back then but it seems that the post has gotten some sponsorship from the moderators.

My personal opinion is that it might not have a busting effect on any one activity except journalism, but it might be a stop measure for some politicians and public figures.

Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by hetspookjee on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:49AM (#29849273)
I'm torn on the subject, for one I think the transparancy is good, especially when viewed in the public sphere, but on the other hand, like HN mentioned: it's bad that the "ladder syndrom" might occur: e.g. one only hops a certain % in salary. On the other hand, one might also view what all the collegues are earning and the "past" wouldn't be a relevant anymore, but rather the merits one might bring to a company. In addition I find tax Returns different from salary history, though for most indeed would be the same. and finally I find it not the same that for the Experian flavor one has to pay to get some info, where the Norway variant is free for all to see.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by vegai_ on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:44AM (#29849255)
Yeah, that kinda sounds bad, but then again, if your salary is below what you should deserve, you just change jobs again with a higher salary request.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:18PM (#29853729)
In the US job changes aren't trivial. Health plans impact provider networks and coverage. In some areas employers demand in office with which reduces the pool of available employers.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by gonzo41 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:13AM (#29849394)
The candidate can also grab the business card of a few peers at the company and look at their salaries. The visibility goes both ways.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by vidarh on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:35AM (#29849521)
It's not that easy, because you get the taxable income, and e.g. mortgage interest and other debt interest is a deduction in Norway, so while the taxable income gives an indication it's a very unreliable proxy on the lower end.
Re:Norway Is the Only Country with Public Tax Returns (2018) by throwawayboise on Saturday January 08, 2022 @01:43AM (#29849249)
For a lot of state/government employees in the USA, salaries are public record. It's not really that uncommon.