News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:05PM (#29847405)
I used Linux to play my music collection for a while, but it just had too many problems with crashing and randomly needing to regenerate its index. Windows Media Player just works.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by habeebtc on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:26PM (#29847545)
The current Windows Media Player is a bloated mess with unnecessary features. Not unlike iTunes.

The original WMP was pretty good! But you really can no longer get anything like it. ETA: at least under active development. WMP Classic was a suitable replacement I used to use: https://mpc-hc.org/

Full disclosure: for music I still run Winamp 2.95, and for video it is a mix of Kodi for set top boxes and VLC for PC/Mobile.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by eyegor on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:55PM (#29848149)
I'd recommend checking out foobar2000. It feels old in a good way and you can use a lot of the Winamp plugins if you want them for whatever reason. No fancy nonsense, just a music player. There are also plugins to integrate with streaming services, youtube, etc for when you want something outside of your library.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by glouwbug on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:42AM (#29848964)
Foobar2000 is good example of what a productive snappy user experience should be. It plays music, what else do you want it to do?
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by MikusR on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:32AM (#29850057)
In addition to playing I use Foobar2000 for tagging, ripping, managing and converting.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by TedDoesntTalk on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:38PM (#29847611)
I resort to VLC media player for music for the same reason.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by tonyedgecombe on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:39AM (#29849549)
>Not unlike iTunes

iTunes is dead although its replacements aren't much better.

https://www.apple.com/uk/itunes/

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by phendrenad2 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @10:12AM (#29852369)
Is it REALLY possible for a media player to be "bloated" to the point that it matters (for playing music), when even the cheapest new PC has 8GB of RAM, 4 cores, and an SSD?
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by habeebtc on Saturday January 08, 2022 @05:31PM (#29857169)
I can appreciate the performance aspect of your perspective here. But, if it takes up way too much screen real estate, it matters. If I spend extra time navigating a bad UI, it matters.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:37PM (#29848043)
Interestingly, the dev tools on Linux are rock solid. The other stuff, not so much. Hence Windows is my desktop, where I have putty text windows into my Ubuntu machine for dev work.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by mhh__ on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:04PM (#29848527)
Aren't you still using Ubuntu 14, or am I remembering a thread from too long ago.

"Modern" Ubuntu is absolutely rock solid as my work machine, the current iteration of the windows media player is total rubbish compared to VLC which does actually work with just about everything.

Interestingly, this Linux box is the first machine I've had with which the suspend actually works reliably, unlike every windows machine I've used.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:33PM (#29848651)
As I mentioned in another post, I am still using 14, as the newer Ubuntus would just crash on the machine. It's perfectly adequate for what I use it for.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by mixedCase on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:18PM (#29847489)
Weird. Sounds like you had an issue with a buggy music player. What lead you to think the entire operating system was to blame?
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:22PM (#29847934)
As a desktop replacement, I expect a music player, just like I expect a browser. The music player is a pretty good test of if the the operating system drivers work, although it was never clear if the music players were bad, or the sound drivers.

BTW, the music players on Roku, Grace Digital's streaming boxes, and Galaxy Audio's streaming boxes, are all unusable. The only ones that ever worked were the Turtle Beach Audiotron (now obsolete), and Windows Media Player.

I also have an Ubuntu desktop machine. It started pestering me to upgrade to a newer Ubuntu, and I finally relented and did. The new Ubuntu simply would not function with my graphics card. The old one worked fine with it. I spent a whole day trying to figure that one out, but there was no solution other than wiping the disk and reinstalling the older Ubuntu. A proper desktop replacement would:

1. warn me that I needed a new graphics card when pestering me to upgrade

2. refuse to install if I had a graphics card that was abandoned

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by cowpig on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:28PM (#29847986)
I immediately uninstall the media players that come on any linux distro and install vlc, which is a magnificent piece of software
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by heavyset_go on Friday January 07, 2022 @10:11PM (#29848246)
I've been burned by this. It was a result of nVidia deprecating support for my video card in new drivers, and Ubuntu only shipping up-to-date and compatible proprietary drivers in their latest releases. According to Canonical, this was because the nouveau driver has some support for the deprecated hardware and the old drivers were no longer compatible with up-to-date distros.

If that was your issue, there's scripts that patch support for newer distros into the old drivers.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:45PM (#29848698)
It sounds like my issue.

If there are scripts that fix it, those scripts should be run automatically by the installer. Otherwise, it's just not a desktop replacement. I'm sorry to have to say this, but to call it a desktop replacement means it has to:

1. just work

2. failing that, detect the problem and explain what to do. Crashing is just not acceptable anymore.

I do support all the time for the D compilers. In my experience, if the install does anything but "just work", you immediately lose 50-90% of your users.

Every error path in the installer needs to be gone over and engineered to "just work". Messages like:

"Unknown Error: TXerr 66x53 failed, aborted"

are so 1980's :-/

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by Brybry on Saturday January 08, 2022 @05:23AM (#29850285)
No desktop operating system meets this criteria though, at least not if you allow user-defined hardware combinations.

I remember I had to do some hackery on a driver to get my sister's printer to work with her macbook/OSX.

I've had all sorts of issues with printers/scanners/random software combinations/drivers/failed automatic update crash loops(!)/etc with Windows.

The only operating systems that might meet the criteria are on tablets and phones (which are obviously not desktops) -- and even then I've had to cross-compile a kernel module to support a wifi adapter w/ USB OTG.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday January 08, 2022 @09:28AM (#29851934)
Honestly I'll take that google-able error code over the modern trend of "The software has did a sad, please try again or contact our useless support".
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by rbanffy on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:51PM (#29847719)
A surprising lot of people consider a media player as part of the OS.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by grey_earthling on Sunday January 09, 2022 @04:34AM (#29861806)
One criticism of Linux that I've never heard before is too few music players ;)

Whichever music player didn't work for you here, there are dozens of others that might.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by heavyset_go on Friday January 07, 2022 @10:01PM (#29848192)
IMO, if you're going to use Linux to manage your music collection, the web app options are your best options, unless you really like mpd for some reason (which is valid because mpd is nice).

Funkwhale, Jellyfin, and the dozen Subsonic forks/clones are better than whatever desktop music managers exist, and they have cross-platform clients so you can access your collection on your FireTV or phone.

There's no real reason to run any of them on Linux, though, since they're just web apps. Jellyfin and some others are written in C# using .NET Core, so they'd probably be more stable on Windows, anyway.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @10:10PM (#29848243)
I don't want a web app to play my local music collection. What I want is:

1. here's the directory with my music files in it

2. shuffle play it.

That's it. This is not rocket science. I appear to be a unique snowflake, or somebody on the WMP team is just like me. Because that just causes every other music player to commit seppuku.

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by commoner on Friday January 07, 2022 @10:37PM (#29848390)
VLC (https://www.videolan.org/vlc/) has always handled shuffling music without issue for me on Linux (and any other operating system). Have you tried VLC yet?

Also, there are other Linux media players that focus more specifically on music:

- Lollypop (https://wiki.gnome.org/Apps/Lollypop): GTK-based

- Elisa (https://elisa.kde.org): Qt-based

- Vvave (https://vvave.kde.org): Qt-based, mobile-first

Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by WalterBright on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:36PM (#29848665)
As I recall, it was VLC that would randomly crash and corrupt its index file. Maybe they fixed it since then, but I got tired of dealing with it. I just want to listen to my tunes while I work. I just can't believe that in 2022, all the streamers I bought except WMP are unable to do this.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by grey_earthling on Sunday January 09, 2022 @04:38AM (#29861821)
You might like Quod Libet. It comes from the "spreadsheet" school of music library management.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by crb3 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:41AM (#29848957)
mpg123 -C -Z *mp3 works for me.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop... by herbst on Saturday January 08, 2022 @05:34AM (#29850352)
This is sarcastic isnt it?