News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by gruez on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:45PM (#29843014)
>I would be interested in seeing who this 'Public Health and Medical Professionals for Transparency' front group is. My guess is it's a group of charlatans looking to sell their own COVID cures similar to the doctor who produced the original study claiming vaccines cause autism (which was later retracted)

see page 3, paragraph 11: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/60390195/1/public-healt...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by geofft on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:16PM (#29843447)
Yup, looks like it:

- Aaron Kheriarty is no longer associated with UC Irvine after refusing their vaccine mandate (this changed between the filing and now) and tweets links to The American Conservative. https://twitter.com/akheriaty

- Harvey Risch published an opinion piece in favor of hydroxycholoroquine in the American Journal of Epidemiology which attracted opposition from many other scientists as inappropriate/unscientific (not simply wrong yet within the bounds of good-faith scientific inquiry) and a response from that journal. https://academic.oup.com/aje/article/190/4/491/5898696

- Peter McCullough appeared on an episode of Joe Rogan where even Joe Rogan correctly identified that his claims were implausible. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29655002

I got bored after the first page, I can look further....

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by vorpalhex on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:43PM (#29843749)
> and tweets links to The American Conservative.

Why do we care about this? Does he also have bad taste in summer outfits?

> which attracted opposition from many other scientists as inappropriate/unscientific (not simply wrong yet within the bounds of good-faith scientific inquiry)

That is incorrect. The counter arguments were narrow and about statistical methods, specifically risk ratio usage and confounders. Neither side appeared out of bounds in this debate.

> Peter McCullough appeared on an episode of Joe Rogan where even Joe Rogan correctly identified that his claims were implausible.

Your evidence here is an HN thread which restates the issue. Double infections are exceedingly rare (currently): https://nypost.com/2022/01/03/israel-reports-rare-double-inf...

Attack facts and claims, not people.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by samsa on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:56PM (#29843917)
The NY Post article you link to is about getting both Covid and influenza at the same time. That may be rare.

Getting covid a second time after having previously had it (which is what McCullough erroneously claimed was near impossible) is in fact increasingly common.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by AlphaOne1 on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:35PM (#29844443)
Yes, but in the subsequent podcast with Joe Rogan and Robert Malone, Dr. Malone specifically says that Dr. McCullough asked that he let everyone know that he was basing his information on pre omicron variant and that reinfections are actually much more common with this variant.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by pvarangot on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:01PM (#29844750)
Nah a lot of Delta cases where reinfections, I can't believe we are still arguing about wether COVID mutations can reinfect only because of McCullough.

Of course if you only look at the "variants of concern" that the media talks about you basically have to wait years until you have like 4 or 5 variants that went all around the world to see how common it is for it to mutate in a way that can reinfect, but considering Delta reinfections where common and now Omicron is also reinfecting everyone, I would just not loose any more time listening to McCullough. Note he says its _impossible_, not rare or weird or strange, _impossible_. He actually called bullshit on Rogan because Rogan said his friend got it twice because he got Delta and the first variant.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by vorpalhex on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:15PM (#29845589)
> Nah a lot of Delta cases where reinfections,

That is an amazing fact if true and you should alert the CDC immediately with your evidence.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by pvarangot on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:51PM (#29856080)
The first serious reinfection study I saw for Delta was the NHS study, with like 350+ reinfections over more than 35000 health workers. I think the chances for a case on that study to be a reinfection was something like 1.2% to 1.5%

I consider that "a lot" special when compared to McCulloughs prediction of 0.0% because reinfection was impossible.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by vorpalhex on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:35PM (#29844437)
Do you have a citation?

> Cases of reinfection with COVID-19 have been reported, but remain rare .

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/your-health/reinfe...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by samsa on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:23PM (#29846379)
This particular CDC page reports it was last updated in August.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by geofft on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:49PM (#29844614)
I agree that they are rare. Dr. McCullough's claim was that they were impossible, that Rogan's friend who got it twice actually had influenza or something one of the times - a diagnosis he made based on no information other than appearing to have gotten it twice.

If he merely claimed they were rare, that would not discredit him.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by dublin on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:23PM (#29845020)
And as mentioned above, he later clarified that he was talking about pre-Omicron variants, where that was true. It now seems possible to get Omicron more than once, but since it has virtually no impact (most people never even know they have it, especially here in Austin in Dec-Feb "Cedar Fever" season), it really makes no difference, other than that it's not yet known if it works the other way, so that an Omicron infection may provide protection against prior variants.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by vorpalhex on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:16PM (#29844939)
To recap, you are upset because a doctor on a podcast used the phrase "impossible" instead of "very rare"?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by akiselev on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:24PM (#29845038)
What's the point of professionals and experts if they don't communicate clearly and precisely? Why even have him on a podcast?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by coderaptor on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:49PM (#29845300)
Communicating technical concepts to lay audiences is difficult, and a universal problem these days.

Very rare and impossible are nearly equivalent wrt policies that broadly and significantly impact personal health and liberty.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by akiselev on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:19PM (#29845652)
I agree that communicating these concepts is hard, but that characterization of "very rare" and "impossible" only makes it harder.

Pandemics are very rare. Flying unicorns shooting Ebola out of their horns are impossible.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by bobthebuilders on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:47PM (#29846639)
Nope. Genetic engineering and bioweapons could very make the latter a reality. And that's why you don't try to be pendantic.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by geofft on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:02PM (#29846155)
I'm hardly "upset" - I just think the doctor is not a reliable source of medical information and not operating in good faith.

Are you upset because I hold that view based on observable evidence? Like, genuinely, I'm confused why you're so invested in arguing against me. What's the thing I said that you disagree with? Are you saying that the doctor is a reliable source of medical information despite his entirely unsubstantiated pronouncement that there was no possible way Joe Rogan's friend could have gotten covid twice, and one of those cases must have been influenza or something?

Attack facts and claims, not people.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by avs733 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:20PM (#29844986)
Not facts and claims...common sense.

Nothing suggests these folks are acting in good faith. They showed no willingness to bound an obviously over-scoped request. It is sad the judge didn't see this for what it is.

They are abusing the process to make the FDA and Pfizer look bad by requesting an absurd number of things and not scoping out things that they obviously are not entitle to. Pfizer, like it or not is entitled to have their trade secrets protected. Like it or not, Pfizer and teh FDA have a responsibility to protect the private healthcare information of patients who participated. That takes time. If I was a vaccine trial participant I would be suing the pants off these loons.

I feel like I'm living in crazy town...go read the emails that these loons attached of their own email conversation with the FDA. one person (the FDA rep) is trying to have a serious and productive conversation, the guy from PCP (or whatever) wants to stand on a street corner and shout. They attached this in support of their own lawsuit

Extraordinary claims require at least some effort. It isn't the job of everyone to engage and disprove everything stupid people say...at some point saying 'this dude is a loon' is a sufficient counter to 'why won't you debate me'. The preponderance of evidence, including engagement with things like the American Conservative and Joe Rogan as a source of healthcare information meaningfully suggest against taking these people seriously and that's all that is necessary.

[0] https://phmpt.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/032-Appendix-in...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:37PM (#29846526)
I have this old quaint idea that government shouldn’t have too many secrets. That an informed public requires open records.

to flip what you are saying around, I believe that every government record should be born publicly available unless explicitly rendered secret (under review, of course). That is, I shouldnt have to file a FOIA, the agency should file a “Request for Secrecy”

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by avs733 on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:46PM (#29848094)
I think it’s quaint that HN is so confident they know what should and shouldn’t be kept confidential by the government without seeing them.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Saturday January 08, 2022 @10:07AM (#29852313)
I dont. I specifically mentioned the mechanism that state secrets should be generated by: by the government proactively making something secret.

Otherwise everything is automatically an openly available record.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Jimmc414 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:32PM (#29845120)
US citizens are legally entitled to this information.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by avs733 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:43PM (#29845227)
>this information.

what information...exactly what information?

if I file a FOIA request for the presidents tax return and it gets denied for a legal exemption is that the government hiding something?

There is a FOIA process, there are things that are exempt from disclosure - that is part of the law as well.

FDA follows a process, outlined here: https://phmpt.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/023-FDA-Appendi... (page 5+)

In reality, the plaintiffs are the ones slowing the process of releasing this information down by being unreasonable. it means FDA is reviewing and denying OBVIOUSLY privileged or exempt documents that the group only asked for to then waive about the number of documents that the FDA 'wOuLdN't DiScLoSe'.

If you are playing quantitative games with FOIA request document numbers you are acting in bad faith. When you are trying to scope as many exempt documents as possible into your request so you can later use that number to push your narrative, you are acting in bad faith. Because when you aren't interested in the content of the documents, nothing you are doing has anything to do with serious efforts at transparency.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by chaps on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:19PM (#29845660)
You gotta realize that these gov agencies give bad faith arguments to say that they can't release records routinely. These government agencies know full fucking well that these records will be responsive to FOIA and yet they still don't make efforts to make it accessible and releasable to the public. Same goes to Pfizer. It's our responsibility as a public to make sure important information like this isn't being hidden.

Their litigation is aggressive, there's no doubt there. But does that mean the information isn't any less important? Back when the pandemic started, a lot of FOIA nerds were hesitant to submit FOIAs because of the issues around quarantine, WFH etc. At the end though, transparency is such a fundamentally important part of our understanding of our own governance that it's important that we don't hold back on important issues like this.

It doesn't even really matter too much if the organization won't use the docs themselves. Their litigation is making it available to the public. If they're not going to look through them, someone will.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Jimmc414 on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:18PM (#29845640)
We are not talking about a request for POTUS tax returns.

The process is defined by the Freedom of Information Act itself and not the Department of Health and Human Services. Here is the act https://www.justice.gov/oip/freedom-information-act-5-usc-55... and by law there only 9 exemption categories that allow a US agency to withhold information. They are: 1. classified information for national defense or foreign policy 2. internal personnel rules and practices 3. information that is exempt under other laws 4. trade secrets and confidential business information 5. inter-agency or intra-agency memoranda or letters that are protected by legal privileges 6. personnel and medical files 7. law enforcement records or information 8. information concerning bank supervision 9. geological and geophysical information

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by joshuamorton on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:15PM (#29846306)
> We are not talking about a request for POTUS tax returns.

You're right, we're talking about random private citizens medical information, which falls under 6. That's what the majority of the pages requested are, and why it'll take so long to redact them: they're mostly clinical notes about people like you and me. The relevant information that won't be redacted is already publicly accessible.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Jimmc414 on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:00PM (#29847357)
People like you and me who willingly participated in a public funded study. If Pfizer did not anonymize the data from the beginning that is foolish at best.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by avs733 on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:31PM (#29848006)
…they wouldn’t be allowed to anonymize data they submit to the fda

Honestly this discussion is insane, this entire discussion presumes a bunch of people selling snake oil are more credible than the people trying to make sure drugs are safe. The “well the fda screws up sometimes” is only useful to that argument if you have already picked the narrative you want. Otherwise it’s like saying I’d rather go to see with a cannibal I have never met than my younger brother because he bit me once when we were kids.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:28PM (#29846427)
Dont worry, Federal agencies aren't shy to redact.

Or perhaps they’ll be “anonymized” which is tech’s go to term for running roughshod over our secrecy.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ds206 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:30PM (#29845085)
Trust the science. Btw, my name is Science ;)
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by staticassertion on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:54PM (#29845358)
> Why do we care about this? Does he also have bad taste in summer outfits?

You can feign ignorance here but the answer is obvious. Anti-vax talking points are far more common in conservative media.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Jimmc414 on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:39PM (#29845881)
For the sake of argument even if they were conservatives or anti-vaxer or felons or insurrectionists the Freedom of Information Act still applies to them.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by staticassertion on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:42PM (#29846586)
The initial statement was questioning their motives, not to remove the FOIA.

> My guess is it's a group of charlatans looking to sell their own COVID cures

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by colpabar on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:43PM (#29843746)
Well I for one am glad that FOIA requests don't depend on whether you like the people filing them. I find it absolutely ridiculous that asking for this data is seen as a bad thing. Why are pharmaceutical companies suddenly beyond questioning?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by geofft on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:51PM (#29844642)
To be clear, I am not saying "This FOIA request is bad because I don't like the people filing them." I agree transparency is good, and I in fact think it should be the default, no FOIA necessary, including and perhaps especially for things like medical approvals. That means the assumption of it being made public should be built in at every step of the process, including notes of patient trials.

I am simply responding to the comment above that asks, who are the people who are requesting the information, and what is their agenda. That is also a very important thing to know for a vibrant public discourse.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by colpabar on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:23PM (#29845025)
Fair enough; thanks for elaborating.

I just can't help but think that pfizer did this on purpose - not making redacted versions of their data, knowing it would take the FDA forever to do that if it ever got FOIA'd.

[dead]
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by colpabar on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:17PM (#29844952)
Of course people are going to cherry-pick things that suit their narrative from this massive amount of information. But that's the game. If there are questionable things in this data, then it's up to our public health officials to explain them.

This vaccine is a new type of medicine that was produced faster than vaccine before it. It also seems to work. But regardless, we all deserve to see every bit of information about its production, especially now that people's jobs depend on them getting it.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Mountain_Skies on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:55PM (#29844686)
Humanity is who is asking for answers.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Robotbeat on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:48PM (#29845294)
Looking for answers or looking for ammunition in an ideological war against vaccination?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Karunamon on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:08PM (#29844839)
Hiding information and general untrustworthiness harms credibility, which is a chicken that's going to come home to roost the next time there's a public health crisis.

The CDC blew a lot of its credibility with the (arguably noble) early lie about masks not working.

Pharma companies probably don't have that much to lose.

Now it's the FDA's turn.

"We must hide legally-required-to-be-available information because some people may misuse it" is a path with unlimited abuse potential, best avoided.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Robotbeat on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:42PM (#29845916)
Look, again, I’m not suggesting any legally required information should be hidden. But if you think the end result of releasing massive amount of even totally-above-board information is going to be increased public trust, then you must have sleepwalked the last 6 years.

There’s a good case to be made that releasing this is the best course. But let’s not pretend that public trust won’t be eroded because it takes an order of magnitude more work to disprove bulls### than to make it up (or twist it) in the first place. And it isn’t any particularly information I’m talking about, simply the vast quantity involved.

The vaccine becoming political is probably the worst thing to happen to humanity in the last 2-3 years. Worse probably than COVID itself.

EDIT: just thought of one possible solution or at least mitigation to the “Bull### asymmetry principle” when combined with massive data dumps: Limit the amount of material that can be requested. Any specific dates or whatever could be requested within the stack. Or if a representative sample is desired, the entire dump is sectioned in pieces and each section is securely hashed. The one doing the request can then request, say, up to 100-1000 sections and each such section can then have its hash compared. That ensures the random selection is random to the satisfaction of the requesting party. And it limits the amount of bulls### that needs to be countered to some reasonable level. Otherwise, any attacker will be able to overwhelm the public with endless claims from a massive stash of requested documents.

This doesn’t limit the amount of work for scrubbing PII, though, since you’d have to scrub it before hashing or the hashing wouldn’t be recreatable. But at least you’d limit the amount of unique bulls### that’d need to be countered.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Karunamon on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:47PM (#29848706)
The FDA could've had the policy that the data is scrubbed and made available as its ingested. And, quite honestly, I see this complaint of theirs as one made in bad faith. Once they have no other choice, they'll comply in a lot faster than 3/4 of a fucking century.

Really, I see FOIA requests as failures of government; as in they represent the government being poked to be transparent when transparency should be the default.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:13PM (#29844114)
“[…] tweets links to The American Conservative”

Cant blame him though. It is a great magazine.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ethbr0 on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:54PM (#29844681)
What do you find great about it? (Honestly asked as a non-reader unfamiliar with its content, aside from the implication of the name)
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:08PM (#29846223)
What I like most is that, whilr unapologetically conservative, they are fair and will acknowledge faults in the right and good in the left.

Take their editor Dreher. Dreher is a very social conservative, and economically populist. So is he a Trumpist? He despises Trump specifically for his character shortcomings and has no patience for someone who cant see Trump do any bad. Dreher also has complete intolerance for incivility towards his opponents.

Also, I havent found any other publication explain the damage that cars have caused America than their segment “The new Urbs”. Only Ivan Illich’s quip that cars average 5mph come close to the poignancy.

For TAC the car’s sins aren't CO2 emissions. The sin of the car is that it ripped our cities apart. For TAC, the electric car isn't the solution but a mere bandaid.

They are unabashedly anti-war and anti-interventionist in a manner that Mark Twain, or Smedley Butler would be were they alive (ie many of them, like Twain and Butler, made the mistake of believing the establishment narrative on foreign intervention and are furiously making amends).

Finally, TAC is a gateway to sober conservative intelligentsia, which exists, is very broad and very rich. How many have heard of Roger Scruton compare to Hannity?

EDIT:

Some criticism is in order.

They appear to be a talent incubator, a lot of their columnists are recent grads. They’re great, but they don't last long and I miss some of the old guys (especially their urbanism guy)

They are increasingly a christian focused magazine, which is fine by me, but does limit their palpability for HN readers. That being said, i suspect believers of any faith would be more comfortable reading TAC than NYT (in my experience religious people are more comfortable with people of other faith than with secularism - but its a long and off topic point)

Finally, about the ME coverage. Its simple, its not in the US interest or our problem. Agreed. However their stance on Israel is softer than it was but harsher than mainstream media. Everyone has a problem with men in the middle.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ethbr0 on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:43PM (#29848083)
Thanks for taking the time to make such a thorough reply. I might give it a read.

As someone who leads liberal, but feels conservatives also have many good points, in addition to serving as the necessary counter-argument that strengthens everyone in a discourse, it's been hard to find sources in the Trump era that advance traditional conservative values in good faith.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:38AM (#29848942)
Np, you asked in good faith you deserved an honest opinion. To drive my first point home, a pean to Dennis Kucinich in on their front page right now.

That’s not to say you’ll like it. But they’re fair and honest about what they believe (no “dog whistles” or whatever)

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ethbr0 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @09:01AM (#29851743)
The dog whistle stuff bothers me in the abstract (that it happens at all), but less so in the specific (where it feels like playing hidden words on a speech).

What irks me more is when people can't / won't enunciate their core beliefs as part of an argument.

If you think lower taxes create greater economic growth and freedom, then mention that! If you think higher taxes create greater economic growth and freedom, then mention that! But don't dance around the issue with five pages of rhetorical devices and examples, and never mention why you're advocating a position... as your core belief.

Read a couple articles last night, and enjoyed them. (Well balanced) food for thought.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Saturday January 08, 2022 @10:24AM (#29852496)
To drive their honesty, anti-dog whistle nature and the inexperience of many of their colunist’s, you’ll often get a needlessly shocking but otherwise well argued column. Like a teen having fun shocking staid middle aged people; this is un-conservative, of course so I disagree.

(Declan, Im looking at you. You’re too intelligent to act like a shock jock)

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by amanaplanacanal on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:30PM (#29845768)
If you are a liberal interested in what conservatives think about things, without going full Q crazy, you could do worse.

If you are interested in anti-trump conservative thought, The Bulwark is another good source.