[1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/08/us/glaciers-national-park-202... -- In 2020, Glacier National Park in Montana had to remove signs saying that the Glaciers would be gone by 2020, since the glaciers were still there.
Predicting a specific date limit for a specific area was probably not a great idea. Maybe someone wanted a photo-op. Disappointing. The point remains: faster-than-expected is going to depend on whose expectations you're talking about and at what time. But things are accelerating, and in the wrong direction. Also, some of the dozens of tipping points have likely already been triggered.
According to the latest Global Glacier Change Bulletin[1] compiled by the World Glacier Monitoring Service:
"The percentage of positive annual mass balances decreased from 28% in the 1980s to 9% (2017/18–2018/19), and there have been no more years with a positive mean balance for more than four decades. The melt rate and cumulative loss in glacier thickness continues to be extraordinary. Furthermore, the analysis of mean AAR values shows that the glaciers are in strong and increasing imbalance with the climate and hence will continue to lose mass even if climate remained stable (Mernild et al., 2013)."
Another infamous too-early prediction is Maslowski's 2007 projection of an ice free arctic by 2016 +- 3yrs. There will always be too-early predictions out there. But whether we're EOL in 2 years, 20 years, or sometime within a millenial's lifetime, I think is the wrong thing to be focusing on. [1]: https://wgms.ch/ggcb/
I'm saying a prediction about a specific timeline in years or decades is not important. Whether you're right that it was a few years or decades sooner than expected, or right that it was a few years or decades later than expected, doesn't really matter to me.
I, for one, might be a doomer, but have no illusions about us meeting goals to keep warming under 1.5C, or even 2C for that matter, and it is going to happen "faster than expected".
It's already too late.
Interestingly, before the IPCC was formed their precursor had set the magic number at 1.0 degrees C. Then IPCC set it to 1.5 degrees C. Then they moved the goalpost by changing the baseline from pre-industrial 1750 to 1900 (or maybe 1850). Personally, I'm not a fan of arbitrary numbers anyway. I prefer to look at significant events. For me, the big slap in the face will come when we see an ice free arctic ocean.
Could you elaborate + provide a few sources for this?
I'm not doubting you -- I'm just curious about this assessment and would like to understand how you've come to it.
There's some we have pretty good idea about (perhaps not exceptions to this rule, because we are to an extent already experiencing them to a certain extent) such as ice-albedo feedback.
No one talks of the "end of the world" being 2 years away.
There are some who speak of "tipping points" happening N years from now, but that is something very different. Right?
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-science-p...
"Climate change prediction: Erring on the side of least drama?"
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09593...
It was a lost opportunity to shift the Overton window, which led to the moderate — rather than the extreme — projections being labelled as alarmist.
Both-sideism works in your favor in the latter case, and if someone digs into the numbers a bit more, they would find that the alarmists outnumber the complacents.
The only real risk is that the alarmists provoke an "it's already too late to fix anything" response, which I don't think is terribly likely, as there isn't an upper bound on how bad things get until you hit a tipping point of civilizational collapse.
Because, well, nobody wants to listen to 'alarmists' and 'extremists'.
I say "depending on the source" because there are some extreme doom and gloom types for whom these changes are happening more slowly than expected. However, the difference is negligible. The doom and gloom types might say the end of the world is only 2 years away, which is extreme, but now even peer reviewed research in respected publications are starting to mention very severe outcomes within decades. In previous decades, these publications wouldn't publish anything like that at all, then eventually they began to publish papers that mention these events happening within centuries, and now papers are coming out with very serious consequences being only decades away. The really scary thing is that the likelihood of sudden catastrophic change (eg: methane bombs, Thwaites Glacier collapse) is increasing, which could make the shorter time frame predictions actually come true.