News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by socillion on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:06AM (#2983390)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2691452 contains discussion of that clock from a few months ago.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by tylerneylon on Sunday September 11, 2011 @05:21AM (#2983527)
I love the dream of building things to last. If humans left earth this instant, what would remain useful in 1000 years? Most of what we use today would perish, so there is a sense of overwhelming disposability or high-maintenance around our lifestyles.

Rather than viewing this disposability as a weakness, perhaps we can see it as an element of wise design. By analogy, the human body leans heavily towards self-repair rather than monolithic permanence. Perhaps it is a good thing that our day-to-day designs depend so much on active use and maintenance. If no one continues to use it, why does it need to keep working?

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by v21 on Sunday September 11, 2011 @06:30AM (#2983578)
This only works if design is whole-lifecycle design - if the cheap disposable crap we produce (and rely on, and luxuriate in) can be taken apart and reused after. If cheap fashion predominates, with clothes that fall apart after a season, you need a plan for disposing of those clothes more urgently than you need a plan for disposing of clothes that last a decade.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by troels on Sunday September 11, 2011 @06:43AM (#2983589)
So, I admit I didn't last all through this article, but there was a mention of titanium. I assume rare metals are needed to build a mechanism that is durable enough to last 10.000 years. But how are they going to deal with the fact that rare metals are also very desirable? I can guarantee that it won't take 10.000 years for someone to steal it and repurpose it.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by AngryParsley on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:03AM (#2983610)
The clock is mostly stainless steel, and it will live in a cave in a rather remote location. If civilization collapses in the future, there will be much easier things to steal.

If they really wanted to prevent theft, the builders could alloy the metals with something poisonous or radioactive. But that's harder than it sounds. Not much stuff stays dangerous for 10,000 years. If I were in charge, I'd build some cool Indiana Jones-esque traps. :)

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by gwern on Sunday September 11, 2011 @10:47AM (#2983867)
> If they really wanted to prevent theft, the builders could alloy the metals with something poisonous or radioactive. But that's harder than it sounds.

I'd also point out that such a technique would run opposite Long Now's goal of having visitors - I mean, it's hard to build a clock that lasts 10k years, hard to contain radioactive materials in casks buried underground in salt flats for 10k years, how much harder would it be to do both simultaneously?

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by pjscott on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:54PM (#2984808)
They want people to come in and periodically wind the peripheral parts of the clock. That's kind of incompatible with building an Indiana Jones dungeon.

Actually, you know what? Forget about clocks. I want to know how we can make elaborate dungeon traps last thousands of years.

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by tekacs on Sunday September 11, 2011 @10:33AM (#2983841)
Given that the majority of Titanium's cost is in its processing, its cost is pegged to that of electricity, in a way - should we improve our energy tech (something that we're undoubtedly going to be working on for a while yet) the cost of Titanium should drop with every breakthrough - by any time that one could steal those metal components they may very well be cheap to manufacture...
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by CurtHagenlocher on Sunday September 11, 2011 @08:16AM (#2983663)
Are you implying that titanium is rare? It's the ninth most common element in the earth's crust.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by troels on Sunday September 11, 2011 @08:24AM (#2983673)
It's rare in its pure form though, as far as I'm aware. And I guess even steel has some value.

Point being that over 10.000 years (heck, let's just say over 100 years), someone is going to tear that thing apart and use the components for some thing else.

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by Luyt on Sunday September 11, 2011 @08:27AM (#2983678)
But also: The processes required to extract titanium from its various ores are laborious and costly (WikiPedia)
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by geuis on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:56AM (#2983444)
I'm not sure I like that the article opens by giving most of the credit to Jeff Bezos, "Billionaire Amazon.com founder Jeff Bezos has a long-term plan...". Yes, he is footing the bill for the Clock, but its hardly his.

Danny Hillis's concept and planning and the Long Now Foundation all preceed Bezos's involvement.

It would be much more genuine to attribute Jeff Bezos as the sponsor of the clock, but not as if it was entirely his idea.

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by jcrites on Sunday September 11, 2011 @09:55AM (#2983779)
It sounds like Jeff and Danny have known each other for a couple decades, and have been working actively together on the clock for at least 5 years. It also sounds like Jeff may have had significant involvement in helping to put the team together and actually make it happen, and he's philosophically invested in its purpose.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by ginsweater on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:57AM (#2983508)
Yeah, this article seriously rubs me the wrong way. The tone throughout is "Rich Nerd Buys Cool Toy." And in that context a lot of the talk about the clock's "greater purpose" comes off as bootlicking.

If I were Bezos, I'd be particularly upset about what the writer puts into his mouth about the Gates Foundation and other charities - "Well, Bill Gates has already cured AIDS and malaria, so all that's left for me is to build a fuck-off huge clock!"

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by michaelbuckbee on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:33PM (#2984578)
While this article seems solid, I think it might push the gee whiz engineering aspects of the project (of which there are many very impressive ones) too much.

Bruce Sterling has a wonderful critique of the clock project and suggestions on how to impart it with some sort of higher level cultural permanency.

http://blog.longnow.org/2008/08/03/bruce-sterlings-sharp-war...

What is really heartening to me is that much of the clock design seems to have taken this into account: the constantly change chime sequence, the difficult to access location, etc.

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by jtagen on Sunday September 11, 2011 @10:17AM (#2983809)
I wish there were more technical details - the engineering behind building something designed to last 10k years would make for a great article.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by gwern on Sunday September 11, 2011 @10:44AM (#2983858)
The real cleverness seems to be in Hillis's mechanical digital logic for time-keeping; I looked up the patents once to look at the diagrams, and realized I had no idea what I was looking at. (Still looked pretty cool, though.)
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by Simucal on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:34AM (#2983480)
Neal Stephenson's novel, "Anathem", was partly inspired by this clock.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by escapegoat on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:52PM (#2984134)
I would add, for you silicon valley/SF residents, that longnow.org puts on monthly lectures (http://longnow.org/seminars/), some of which are very interesting. E.g. the next speaker is Timothy Ferriss.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by donnaware on Sunday September 11, 2011 @06:42PM (#2985097)
This is a giant waste of money.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by maeon3 on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:12PM (#2984516)
In 10k years, in the year 12011. the human race is going to be extinct one way or the other, either we all kill each other over resources or we advance way beyond biological and physical barriers, I hope someone finds this clock and thinks, how quaint.

Though it will probably just be a novelty, as we would stumble upon a hole in the ground some animal left in the jungle. The animal thinks it's a genius, we shrug and say eh, I could make that in 5 seconds.

Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by adrianN on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:06AM (#2983454)
They should make it count down to the Amazon Clock Apocalypse in 12012.
Re:How to Make a Clock Run for 10,000 Years by shasta on Sunday September 11, 2011 @09:58AM (#2983783)
That will be the story in the year 4000: ancient Americans believed the world would end in 12012.