News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by kitcar on Saturday September 10, 2011 @09:15AM (#2981515)
While I do believe the film industry needs "disrupting", I do not believe this was the point of the article, nor does it make any good arguments to back up a thesis of "disruption".

"6. Tricky Hollywood Accounting" - this is purely a contract negotiation issue, and it is is no way a hollywood-specific problem - in all lines of businesses you will find companies which try to setup "royalty fee" or similar buyer-controlled expenses to dry up profit to ensure as little is paid out as possible to the seller. A good negotiation team will prevent this, both in Hollywood and elsewhere.

"5. Extorting Theaters" - this is bullshit for 95% of theatres. The large movie theatre chains in North America have leverage over the studios, as while there is a large number of movies available at any given time, there are only a relatively small (fixed) number of theatre screens. The price and revenue split of a film in a theatre is based on supply and demand; movie theatres do not cut the exact same deal with studios for every single film, instead they negotiate based on the expected results of the film. In the cases where movie theatres don't think the film will do well, the studios basically get screwed into subsidizing the movie theatre to show the film. In cases where the movie is expected to do very well, the theatres end up giving up more for the right to have it on their screen. I'm sure small independent theatres are a different story, but in all businesses small players have less negotiation power, and therefore get worse deals.

"4. Fake Reviews" - this is just the work of dishonest marketers - I don't understand how it is a reason to justify disrupting the movie business.

"3. Copyright Bullshit" - this is a US specific problem, not a film business wide problem, as copyright laws change by country. It could also be viewed as a good thing for producers in the film business, as they can profit off their films longer.

"2. Strangling Consumer choice" - again, its a contract issue and has much in common with 6, Extorting Theaters, and the resulting supply and demand struggle. Theaters don't want to pay as high a price for a film if its available in other channels, as that means attendance/viewership will be lower. Same with TV stations, Pay-per-view, and so on. Therefore, if studios want to be able to actually pay for the film they produced, they have to be very careful as to where and in what order they show their content.

"1. Stealing Scripts" - This is just not a film business problem. People steal ideas everywhere, all the time. Stealing ideas is easy, creating a good product is hard.

(Edited after my morning coffee to clarify submitter's thesis versus articles thesis)

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by technoslut on Saturday September 10, 2011 @12:18PM (#2981797)
>1. Stealing Scripts" - This is just not a film business problem. People steal ideas everywhere, all the time. Stealing ideas is easy, creating a good product is hard.

It sounds as if you're trying to justify this approach as well as the others listed. We all know this but the reason it happens is because the writer needs a studio to finance the film. This the most reprehensible of all those listed because it punishes creativity.

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by kitcar on Saturday September 10, 2011 @01:32PM (#2981965)
Not trying to justify anything, but rather suggesting pretty much all the issues outlined are issues in every major industry, and hence highlighting them as being specific and unusual to the film business is incorrect and unhelpful.

An idea for a movie is a very different thing from a finished script, similar to an idea for a new business is very different than the execution of the new business.

If we applied the "you owe me money because I had the movie idea first" logic to the tech world, facebook owes friendster money because they stole friendster's idea.

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by technoslut on Saturday September 10, 2011 @02:50PM (#2982173)
I can't speak for every situation and whether there was a finished script. I may be an idealist but, from a standpoint of morality, any business that abuses the power they have is severely lacking.

There are differences between Facebook and Friendster and I've always felt uncomfortable with the way Zuckerberg behaved in the early days of Facebook. I will argue that Zuckerberg's vision was greater that than just the Winklevoss' original idea.

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by vacri on Saturday September 10, 2011 @11:26AM (#2981713)
That was a lovely piece of spin-doctoring, breaking down the argument into small atomic parts to neatly excise the 'whole is greater than the sum of the parts' essence.

Also, "everybody does it" is not a defence for shady ethics or illegal activity.

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by Taft on Saturday September 10, 2011 @01:07PM (#2981921)
Seems like the parent comment equates "This is a general problem in x industry" to "stop rabblerousing about problems!"
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by DevX101 on Saturday September 10, 2011 @10:39AM (#2981636)
The author never said Hollywood needs disrupting. The HN poster did.
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by jackfoxy on Saturday September 10, 2011 @11:00AM (#2981670)
Real title "6 Things the Film Industry Doesn't Want You to Know About". IMO there are few legit reasons for changing an article name for a HN posting. This lowers the quality of HN.
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by Cushman on Saturday September 10, 2011 @11:47AM (#2981743)
"6 Things the Film Industry Doesn't Want You to Know About" sounds like I'm accidentally reading Gawker. "6 places for disruption" sounds like people are talking about startups.
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by _delirium on Saturday September 10, 2011 @12:22PM (#2981806)
Yeah, but I think that's what makes it a bait-and-switch. It's a Gawker-type article that was retitled with a more appealing-to-HN branding.
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by burgerbrain on Saturday September 10, 2011 @12:32PM (#2981832)
That's exactly why the title shouldn't have been changed. It's the same shit, but disguised so that it won't be (correctly) flagged.
Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by kitcar on Saturday September 10, 2011 @09:27AM (#2981535)
and as a followup, I think there are a few stronger arguments available to support their thesis:

- Bloated production costs due to a slow migration to newly available production techniques

- Lack of adoption of alternative distribution / pricing models

- Bloated production costs due to unionization / inefficient use of labour

- Lack of interest in non-traditional formats for storytelling (i.e. produce "commute length" content for distribution to smartphones/tablets, versus 1.5hr long form content?

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by Sharlin on Saturday September 10, 2011 @10:37AM (#2981633)
"3. Copyright Bullshit" - this is a US specific problem, not a film business wide problem, as copyright laws change by country. It could also be viewed as a good thing for producers in the film business, as they can profit off their films longer.

Unfortunately, anything the US does on this front, others will follow. The media giants very much prefer internationally consistent copyright laws, and they have the power to lobby the US government to exert considerable political pressure on other countries. It's not just the lobbiers themselves we have to worry about here in the Euroland.

Re:Why the film industry needs disrupting by zobzu on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:17PM (#2982860)
Don't worry 3 and 2 are worldwide issues. In the EU copyright has just been extended another 30 years, THIS VERY WEEK.

USA is the country with the most choice also, and yet consumer is strangled. Well just guess how it is for the rest of us, Netflix doesn't even remotely exists anywhere else. anywhere

Based on this I have the tendency to trust the article author on the other points (which I don't know about)