News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:16PM (#29798790)
Einstein is a good example of a rare genius that helped push the species forward. Not sure what you are even hinting at here? Do you hate his hair or something?
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by dang on Thursday January 06, 2022 @01:11PM (#29827350)
We ban accounts that post flamebait like this, and/or take HN threads further into flamewar (which you did a ton of in this thread). Would you please stop doing those things?

We also ban accounts that use HN primarily for ideological battle, regardless of which ideology they're for or against, because that destroys the curious conversation this place is supposed to exist for.

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Thursday January 06, 2022 @07:47PM (#29833070)
I agree with your message and the purpose of it. There was no intention of conflict. I made some attempts to clarify that in the various responses, which mostly concluded with agreements.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by throwawaygh on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:44PM (#29799225)
Einstein is also a good example of a harsh critic of eugenics, both policies and underlying scientific theories.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:03PM (#29799524)
He was a critic of the pseudoscience and bigotry of the time. DNA wasn't even discovered yet.

I suppose maybe we have a different set of definitions we are using. I do not view my stances as compatible with those of the time.

When I think of eugenics, I think of Gattaca, CRISPR, cloning, saving lives, and gene therapy.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by mrtranscendence on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:23PM (#29799865)
> When I think of eugenics, I think of Gattaca, CRISPR, cloning, saving lives, and gene therapy.

You're entitled to your own mental states, but you're clearly not thinking the same thing that most people do when they think of "eugenics".

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:40PM (#29800119)
I have read a few books that talk of eugenics in the way that I am describing it. Matt Ridley for example (genome book covers it on a chapter).

Most discussions I have had on the topic with experts and such in their labs are usually in good faith with collective enthusiasm for what science can one day bring to humanity. It is only online that I encounter a sort of political extremism in opposition to the idea of leveraging what we know (of DNA) to make the world better.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by mrtranscendence on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:54PM (#29800344)
> Most discussions I have had on the topic with experts and such in their labs are usually in good faith with collective enthusiasm for what science can one day bring to humanity.

I don't doubt that. What I doubt is that most experts would happily claim, even among friends, that what they're doing relates to "eugenics", which isn't just a sequence of letters that you can find in a dictionary. It's inextricably bound up with a very dark history. Consider why the Wikipedia article for eugenics isn't just a short one-sentence statement that eugenics is about increasing the occurrence of positive hereditable traits.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @06:46PM (#29802698)
I understand your words, but that is not consistent with my experiences literally anywhere outside of social media where people are self censoring to conform to the puritanical zeitgeist of the moment.

In China, for example, it is generally considered outright irresponsible to not get genetic testing done, to not abort a fetus with the wrong number of chromosomes, etc. These topics are discussed very openly, matter of factly, etc.

On a separate note but still in response -- Wikipedia is not a reputable resource for anything even remotely political and is outright banned in classrooms (and some countries due to the politicized nature of the content).

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by mrtranscendence on Thursday January 06, 2022 @11:24AM (#29825571)
> In China, for example, it is generally considered outright irresponsible to not get genetic testing done, to not abort a fetus with the wrong number of chromosomes, etc. These topics are discussed very openly, matter of factly, etc.

And that's fine for China. This may even become the norm in North America and Europe at some point in the future. But that doesn't change facts: most people speaking in English will not talk positively about the term "eugenics", which has a crap ton of baggage that you're just ignoring.

> Wikipedia is not a reputable resource for anything even remotely political

That would be a fine point to make if I were citing Wikipedia as a source for a paper I'm writing. However, what I meant was that eugenics has a history that can't be sharply extricated from what you might believe is the literal meaning of the term. Words are more complicated than that.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by mrtranscendence on Thursday January 06, 2022 @11:48AM (#29825932)
As an example of what I'm talking about, no reasonable person would prominently display a swastika even though it's technically an Indian symbol of divinity. That's because it has an immense amount of baggage now almost inextricably bound up with its original definition; if you display a swastika people (at least in the west) will immediately connect it to Nazism.

Similarly, if I went on TV and proudly claimed that we should be doing eugenics, many would assume that I want to forcibly sterilize an underclass using unscientific ideas about heritability, and that I'm probably racist, too. I would have to do a lot of work to convince people that, no, all I really mean is that we should be able to do genetic testing to see if babies-to-be have the correct number of chromosomes (and so on), and decide to bring them to term based on that information.

Maybe you want to rehabilitate the term, which, OK, fine. But it's a mistake to assume that you can take the original definition of something and assume that's all the word "means" to people.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by staticassertion on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:37PM (#29799108)
Einstein opposed Nazi Germany (which aligned with eugenics) and outright rejected the idea of eugenics as a pursuit.

I suspect he would be disgusted at the idea of being used as an exemplar for eugenics.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:53PM (#29799356)
I don't think what I am talking about is quite the same thing. Perhaps it would be more diplomatic to call my stance here to be in favor of applied genetics. DNA the molecule of genetics was not yet discovered. I do think there is a lot of potential in the idea of, say, cloning someone like Einstein from samples that have been preserved. It would be very interesting to me if a nation state cloned such people and set them to work on modern problems of quantum physics. What could such people accomplish in their lifetime starting in the present with our current knowledge and proofs and technologies.

well Einstein was against this idea of, you know, German pseudoscience, where they had these men going through mountains in the Middle East and measuring skulls and what have you, I do think applied genetics is a very different science.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by throwawaygh on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:22PM (#29800731)
> Einstein... It would be very interesting to me if a nation state cloned such people and set them to work on modern problems of quantum physics.

This thread just keeps getting better. Do you... I mean... you do know why this is funny, right?

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @09:43PM (#29804358)
To be honest, no. No, I do not know why you find this so funny.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by throwawaygh on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @09:54PM (#29804431)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr%E2%80%93Einstein_debates

You keep evoking Einstein in contexts that would have him rolling in his grave. Imagine raising Einstein from the dead to tell him that he's the standard bearer of eugenics and a version of quantum mechanics that was not in his image. It's humorous.

You seem to know very little about science or its history but are quick to evoke scientism in defense of ideas that in actuality have very little to do with science.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Wednesday January 05, 2022 @09:07AM (#29809056)
>>Wiki

Fun read and all.

Thanks for that link.

Very cool.

>>You seem to know very little about science

Einstein the person, the history of his life, etc are fully separate from contributions to science. Science is, generally, not about cults of personality, history, or any of that.

I have a great appreciation, respect, gratefulness, passion, and enthusiasm for science, progress, and advancement of the species.

One does not have to study the trivialities of how Einstein took his coffee or tea in 1938 in order to appreciate the genius and scientific contributions.

>>You

This side thread with you seems fallacious in a way, but that is okay. I respect you and think there is definitely a place in the world for people who do well in their careers and also worship their idols from history.

You know, all of that said, don't you think it would be cool and maybe beneficial to the species if cloning technologies were perfected and experiments were done where genes like those responsible for the entity you know as Einstein were cloned, given new names, new lives, and such? I wonder what would happen. It would seem such experiments are indeed coming in the future, and I do not think the historical trivialities of one's life have much to do with this scientific curiousity that many a biologist wants to explore.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by throwawaygh on Wednesday January 05, 2022 @07:44PM (#29817525)
> fallacious

This entire thread is an aside about an anecdote about how one guy's wife decided not to have kids and therefore there's a Great Replacement of the Mensa Members By The Non-Mensa Members.

Anyways.

What exactly were we talking about again?

Oh. Right. A really stupid paper.

Want to stay on topic? Reply to this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29798887

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by champagnois on Wednesday January 05, 2022 @12:20PM (#29811837)
As he is a hero of sorts to you, here is EINSTEIN on the, to him, obvious difference in value between the stupid and the brilliant:

>>In 1918 he was asked by the mother of a brilliant German biology student to dissuade her son from joining the front in the First World War. Einstein complied and wrote: “Can this post of yours out there not be filled by an unimaginative average person of the type that come 12 to the dozen? Is it not more important than all that big scuffle out there that valuable people stay alive?”

>>And in 1922, Einstein told his close friend, the physicist Paul Ehrenfest, whose 4-year-old son had recently been diagnosed with Down syndrome, that he agreed with his decision to institutionalize his son rather than care for him himself, because “valuable people should not be sacrificed for causes without any prospects, not even in this case.”

Source: https://time.com/5314704/einstein-diaries-racism/

Einstein can be seen above quoted as saying things that are very similar to my own writings. Regardless, I just found this interesting today and thought you'd enjoy it.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by Apocryphon on Thursday January 06, 2022 @12:59PM (#29827126)
There's nothing similar between those quotes and your writing about how Einstein should be cloned and then made to work on quantum physics.

As an aside, those quotes come from earlier in his life. It's uncertain if he held the same opinions as he grew older and matured. People's views do change over time, as we can see with Einstein's rueful feelings over the a-bomb.