News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by foreigner on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:17PM (#29797981)
I never understood why these self-balancing toys are so underpowered. I want to see one built on top of a dirtbike engine that you need to wear serious body armour to use.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by mystickphoenix on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:22PM (#29798056)
What you're looking for is an EUC, Electric Unicycle. Most of the people in the local onewheel group I'm a member of that ride EUC's wear full motorcycle protection. At least one of them can go upwards of 45 mph.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by karmicthreat on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:43PM (#29798354)
They can be pretty dangerous if you are an idiot. IE this crash: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pahL4MPPOek
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by smithza on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:17PM (#29801402)
I am sure that man has many hours of safe riding. It is always the 10 seconds of deadly and uncontrollable trauma that necessitates safety gear. Self-confidence is often the hubris of humanity.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by bicx on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:55PM (#29799394)
I ride a OneWheel and it can test your nerves sometimes. However, just looking at the speed and stance of a EUC makes me more nervous. You could just open your arms at 45mph and embrace the car in front of you.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by johnsonap on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:36PM (#29798246)
Holy shit I just googled EUC's, those things look insane
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by Glide on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:50PM (#29798438)
They are insane. I bought one and learned how to ride it. It took a while and it was very frustrating before it clicked.

It's surprisingly intuitive once you get going.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by frankus on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:30PM (#29800819)
There are a lot of practical problems trying to build a balancing vehicle around an internal combustion engine.

They can't produce any torque at zero speed, they can't smoothly reverse direction, they likely can't produce enough negative torque at higher speeds, and their control bandwidth is probably inadequate for anyone but an extremely skilled rider.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by blacksmith_tb on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:20PM (#29798020)
Well, they already have a reputation as pretty risky to ride[1]. I am sure you could scale the motor and wheel up some, but I'd want some wearable airbags...

1: https://dailyhornet.com/2021/onewheel-lawsuits-pile-up-after...

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by johnsonap on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:38PM (#29798269)
Wow, I never knew folks had died on these
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by xboxnolifes on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:49PM (#29798435)
If something moves, and someone rides on it, someone has probably also died on it.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by johnsonap on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:27PM (#29798938)
very good point, I was more talking about the cause of death being a defect
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by howdydoo on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:44PM (#29799223)
But was there actually any defect? Anyone can claim anything in a lawsuit.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by bredren on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:20PM (#29799838)
There is broad consensus that the One Wheel could do more to warn riders of an impending nose dive.

For example, an audible tone the moment it shuts off the motor while underway.

There are other design changes that could reduce the danger of a nose dive that 3rd party manufacturers have pounced on including small wheels that allow the product to potentially slow instead of come to a dead stop when an edge hits the ground.

I don’t know what product liability is for continuous mounting evidence that an existing design is lacking obvious safety feature and choosing not to make changes or acknowledge this.

But I suspect ultimately this will end in a class action suit.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by howdydoo on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:48PM (#29800245)
Interesting. I bought the original model when it was new and I've been happy with it. I always just viewed it as something that was inherently risky, but worth it. The board does have a way of "communicating" with you when you're pushing it too hard, by leaning you back, and it seems pretty intuitive to me. Then again I used to be a skateboarder, so maybe my risk tolerance is outside the norm.

I assume these are the wheels you're talking about[1]. Pretty ingenious idea, although it does mess with the look of the board

[1]: https://www.etsy.com/listing/1069745398/onewheel-xr-safety-w...

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by bredren on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:44PM (#29800988)
The risk tolerance of skateboarders is probably the gold standard.

Expectations for safety have changed a lot,too. I raced ski team in high school. Helmets were optional and very few rec skiers wore them.

Now it seems unusual to see someone without one.

I’m aware of the haptic feedback the board is supposed to give when it is getting tired, though there are many claims of it not being produced prior to a nose dive.

Yes that product you linked is what I was describing. Note their description describes nose dives on the OW as “inevitable.”

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by shkkmo on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @11:08PM (#29805014)
Even with a correctly functioning OneWheel, pushing too hard into a hill or headwind can get you a into a nose dive without feeling any pushback.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by MisterTea on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:58PM (#29800392)
> For example, an audible tone the moment it shuts off the motor while underway.

If it has the ability to monitor battery life then it can certainly do stuff like emit an impeding dead battery warning tone and then gently decelerate to a stop.

Though I bet its an issue where the battery level is simply monitored via voltage. So lets say a 15% charged battery has enough current to push the rider along on level ground, BUT, the moment the rider hits an uphill, the current increases beyond what the now weaker battery can provide, the voltage drops below the battery threshold and the battery protection circuit shuts down. Very unsafe design.

A proper design would allow the battery and motor drive to cooperate so when the motor current demand rises to maintain velocity, the battery pack can tell the motor, sorry, I cant give you anymore and the motor drive can then decelerate or simply refuse to continue accelerating.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by miskin on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:11PM (#29801311)
The main problem is that to push you back, the motor actually has to go faster to get in front of your center of gravity and this is exactly what is hard when the battery is getting weak. That's why nosedives often happen when users want to go too fast, ignoring the pushback from the wheel and actually "rinding the pushback". At some point, the motor does not have enough torque to counter the push down on the front and give up. This causes the front side to collapse and we can all imagine possible results when feet "want" to stop and the head is going 20mph+. It's not that battery management will simply turn the device off (although it may also be an issue in some cases). Usually motor just becomes too weak to counter rider push for a short moment and the front part of the board hits the ground.

I do not have experience with Onewheel XR, but pushback on the Pint series is rather noticeable and hard to ignore when you hit set speed limit. Onewheel XR is said to have weaker pushback.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by bredren on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:49PM (#29801049)
> A proper design would allow the battery and motor drive to cooperate so when the motor current demand rises to maintain velocity, the battery pack can tell the motor, sorry, I cant give you anymore and the motor drive can then decelerate or simply refuse to continue accelerating.

These are good thoughts though even in your solution I suspect it points toward the idea that the design is fundamentally unsafe.

The reason is if the motor decelerates you still must be prepared for your weight to shift, even gradually.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by shkkmo on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @11:17PM (#29805068)
On a self balacing PEV, if the motor decelerates on it's own (without a weight shift from the rider), the resulting weight shift will not be gradual. You might tip forward slightly slower in comparison but the nose dive would still happen pretty much immediately. This is because in order to maintain speed, the CoM must be in front of the balance point.

The design of self-balancing PEVs isn't fundentally unsafe, but it (like most sports and means of transportation) does carry risks that you should be aware of and compensate for.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by johnsonap on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:36PM (#29800077)
Thank you for the context!
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by johnsonap on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:52PM (#29799339)
you make a valid point
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by micromacrofoot on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:43PM (#29799205)
Have you ridden one before? I hit 15mph on a onewheel once and have no desire to ever do it again.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by bredren on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:59PM (#29799463)
I rode 100 miles on one two years ago, and planned to take it to the Burn but after my second fall I decided to sell it and get a Space Horse from All City.

I was padded up for both falls but still sustained a sprain to an ankle and some pretty mean scrapes to my shoulder and arm.

My worst fall was due to the motor cutting out on a moderate acceleration uphill climb from stop. This is not unusual on the OW but is normally associated with a lower battery level.

I was pretty good with it, but in the end I could justify the potential for falls once every 100 miles, let alone 50.

They are fun to ride, though.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by MivLives on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:19PM (#29801436)
I put about 2400 miles on mine. You fall a few times in your first 100-200 miles but after that it really doesn't happen much, and normally only when you do something stupid.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by a9h74j on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @06:28PM (#29802491)
I've heard the phrase: You see people going fast on one-wheels, but you never see the same person doing so twice.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by zardo on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:42PM (#29798323)
I don't think the go-kart wheel in the middle of a skateboard layout would make for a good ride above ~35mph. Too twitchy in yaw and too limited in braking power by the geometry of the thing.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by MivLives on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:17PM (#29801399)
It's for legal reasons in a lot of places. Most places have laws about the max speed of motor powered devices. It's normally around twenty.

I've gone up to 24 MPH (on flat) when I had one, and have hit the ground going twenty. I'm honestly not sure more speed is a good idea as it just takes one little crack in the road you weren't anticipating to throw you balance off.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by michaelt on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:20PM (#29800696)
Single wheel vehicles have no brakes worthy of the name.

After all, when you brake hard with a car or motorbike or bicycle, it's the front wheel, well in front of the centre of mass, that does almost all the work.

In a single wheel vehicle, the wheel well in front of the centre of mass.... isn't there. In a unicycle that means you're flying off the front (it's even worse in a monowheel) so you'd better not be going faster than a man can run.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by Groxx on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:26PM (#29800775)
... which is why you lean back on these to brake, to shift your center of mass back so the wheel can slow you down. same thing in reverse for accelerating, otherwise you'd see people fall off non-stop at the beginning for the same reason you claim they can't stop.

your stopping speed is limited by how fast it can decelerate you, which is essentially the same as how fast it can accelerate you. it's not super fast to stop, to be fair, but neither is a bicycle going at high speed (though I'd expect the bike to be a little bit quicker to stop).

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by samb1729 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @07:50PM (#29803333)
My issue with EUCs is the complete lack of options in the case of power cutting for any reason, whether it be overheating or low battery charge or a resistor burning out.

Leaning back is not an option once the motor stops pushing the wheel towards you - it’ll roll and then tumble to a stop much more quickly than air resistance slows you down, so you’ll fly off the front.

I’d like for there to be a magic solution to this problem since the size of an EUC is very attractive. Rolling to a safe stop on my electric scooter is preferable in the meantime.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by Groxx on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @08:50PM (#29803908)
yeah, an instant loss in acceleration would certainly make you eat pavement in many cases. definitely a fair concern. I might claim that "I hit a rock slightly larger than that small rock I can usually roll over and now I'm in an impromptu pole-vault competition" is a more common issue with small scooter wheels than random power losses, but there's more personal control over that. (personally: crossing train tracks were my #1 fear and #1 fall cause on scooters)

either way, safety gear safety gear safety gear. especially since basically all these electric personal mobility enhancing whatsits are horrifyingly injury-prone compared to anything the size of a bike or larger.

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by MivLives on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:21PM (#29801477)
If you need to stop super fast you lean back so hard you're actually dragging the tail. There's a reason a lot of people put additional plastic armor on the bottom of these things.
Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by gregn610 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:47PM (#29801027)
Have you seen the original Australian bushpig?

https://youtu.be/0OV33C2JgIE

Re:DIY Onewheel – open-source self balancing skateboard by gnopgnip on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:31PM (#29800829)
You are limited in how fast you can safely go by how fast you can stop