Re:Search engines and SEO spam
by fragmede on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:23PM
(#29783297)
How do you fight brigading, the organization of groups elsewhere to collectively vote on something? Eg white supremacist groups get together and vote down everything by people of color, and vote up their pages about how great they are?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Search engines and SEO spam
by giantrobot on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:00PM
(#29783886)
Randomly select votes that are actually recorded. Then add in metavoting that votes on the votes with random sampling. At Google's scale with a sufficiently random sampling you'd be extremely hard pressed to successfully brigade or spam the voting.
Google could easily use its current fingerprinting to constrain (to an extent) multiple votes. Even knowing only a portion of the population will participate in the voting they can use a Wilson confidence interval[0] or similar to properly weight votes.
Random sampling works here since you're not guaranteed one vote per user per page and the outcome in binomial, seen and downvoted or seen and not downvoted.
[0] https://www.mikulskibartosz.name/wilson-score-in-python-exam...
easy, voting blocs, you assign yourself to the results of people who vote similarly to you. additionally there'd be local and regional blocs too. I can't think of a reason that the naive everyone sees everything everyone else is doing would work in the long run. That's Twitter, and it's garbage.
This is a great point. I would think Google could rank users from low quality to high quality in terms of the quality of the websites which they recommend or downvote. Tricky business and could be difficult to control, but basically the same thing they currently do for websites, but extended to humans.
Re:Search engines and SEO spam
by numbsafari on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:14PM
(#29784077)
How does Google already handle this exact problem on YT?