News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by kevinpet on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:35AM (#2978495)
Parasitic HFT that doesn't actually provide liquidity is a consequence of rules that are designed to provide liquidity. Think of what you would "expect" if things were working right. Am I going to try to sell something at the exact moment a human needs to buy? No, I'm going to sell to a dealer who will hold it for a bit and then sell to a human who wants to buy. The dealer is purely algorithmic, so he may as well be replaced by a computer.

From the article "On the positive side of electronic trading, the panel said, liquidity has improved, transaction costs are lower, and market efficiency is generally better."

Relevant Monty Python: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExWfh6sGyso

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by pasbesoin on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:53AM (#2978565)
In my opinion, trading needs to be put on a stepped clock and draw from a randomized queue.

A position should be a position and not a matter of beating the other guy to a momentary, transitory state.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by paperwork on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:48PM (#2979063)
>A position should be a position and not a matter of beating the other guy to a momentary, transitory state

You are arguing to shut down the whole stock market then. Even value investors like Buffet are in the business of beating the other guy to understanding that given stock is over or under valued.

As for transitory state, the point of the stock market is to reflect what is thought to be the 'true' value of a company at any given time.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by wisty on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:53PM (#2979080)
If you added a little random noise to order timestamps, traders would have less incentive optimize for speed and would direct their efforts elsewhere.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by pasbesoin on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:17PM (#2979221)
An interesting idea for a less invasive / technically transformative change.

(And a new meaning for the term "jittery market". ;-)

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by pasbesoin on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:12PM (#2979195)
No, I'm arguing for a clock cycle that presents an inherent limit on transitory gaming and also allows smaller participants to compete on an equal footing (at least, with regard to order processing).

Once a minute, or something else. That's something the big brains can sort out -- earn those salaries in a productive endeavor, for a change.

Nickle and diming retirement investments does not, in my perspective, contribute qualitatively to society. (A bit baldly, and narrowly, stated, but a significant part of my point.)

Of course, in an increasingly global marketplace of trading, this probably does not have legs.

I see the market as connecting investors with investments. Spending heavily to leverage momentary arbitrage does not, in my perspective, add significantly to the base function of the market.

Such a stepped clock might also allow/aid some monitoring and capping of flash changes -- the continuing dread of many, that an unbalanced algorithm or combination will take the market down.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by paperwork on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:37PM (#2979303)
I guess I don't understand why 'transitory gaming' is a bad thing in the stock market.

I agree that it is immoral for Enron to reduce the supply of electricity, while towns are having brown-outs, just to raise the price. The same is true of hoarding much needed commodities, just to raise their price. I'm not even a big fan of speculatively buying up domain names.

However, stocks can not be consumed. For most people, there is no reason to transact in the financial market other than financial gain.

I don't see how this type of trading automated trading harms retirement investments. High frequency exists because exchanges now allow electronic transactions and automated matching. Algorithmic trading (which generally means automating the execution of large number of shares, such as institutional (retirement funds) orders) have also greatly benefited from same opportunities.

If the complaint is that when retirement funds buy or sell large number of shares, HF guys come in and pick them off -- this is no different from regular day traders (or even professional traders). In fact, large trades have no "right of way" in the stock market. If you are buying a million shares of some stock, other traders will react and raise the bid. This is not a subversion of how the market works, this is the essence of price discovery and how the market is supposed to work.

>I see the market as connecting investors with investments. Spending heavily to leverage momentary arbitrage does not, in my perspective, add significantly to the base function of the market.

But does it take away from the base function? Just because some rich guy is spending money on computers, routers, programmers and mathematicians does not mean the market is negatively effected. Surely the burden is on the critics to prove why HF is bad.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by pasbesoin on Saturday September 10, 2011 @02:36PM (#2982122)
I'll stew on this for a bit. Thanks for the response and the encouragement to think further on the topic.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by andylei on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:59PM (#2979595)
> Nickle and diming retirement investments does not, in my perspective, contribute qualitatively to society

actually, study after study shows that algorithmic traders improve things for "retirement investors". more algo trading leads to lower spreads, which decreases trading costs for long term investors.

think about who value investors had to buy from before algo traders. they bought from human market makers who were ridiculous inefficient, and as a result, had to charge huge spreads. these spreads have a material (negative) impact on investment returns for value investors.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by pasbesoin on Saturday September 10, 2011 @01:15PM (#2981929)
I guess I'm not currently competent to comment on this aspect; it is something I'll have to investigate.

I'm not opposed to automated trading. I do, however, think (well, have the perhaps unqualified opinion) it has become excessively focused on near time outcomes and pushing transaction volume in preference to the actual performance/outcomes of investment properties.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by seanc on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:02PM (#2978600)
It might sound like I'm quibbling, but while it is clear there are more algorithmic trades, the article does not provide any evidence that there are fewer human trades.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by jvdh on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:04AM (#2978363)
At some point we have to wonder what it is that this trading actually is for.

Investing in companies, fine. The risk that you take with your invested money evolves over time, true. But at some point it just becomes ridiculous that people are making money from 0.0001 fluctuations in prices.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by esrauch on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:18AM (#2978427)
Why would it be ridiculous to make money from a ton of trades on $0.0001 fluctuations in prices but not fewer trades in $1 fluctuations? It seems to me that your argument applies equally to human day traders and machine trading, neither of them are really related to investing in companies except in terms of setting the price and the oft-cited liquidity that they provide.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by SHOwnsYou on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:26AM (#2978458)
Flash crashes and short term volatility.

Also "oft-cited liquidity that they provide" >>

This argument is farcical to the nth degree. When the average time for HFTs to hold onto a new position is less than 30 seconds, I'd say they're merely claiming credit for liquidity that was already there.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by paperwork on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:02PM (#2979125)
>When the average time for HFTs to hold onto a new position is less than 30 seconds, I'd say they're merely claiming credit for liquidity that was already there

This is factually incorrect. A lot of ultra-high frequency trading refers to a practice where traders post a bid or an offer--their orders sit in the 'book,' waiting for other to come and trade with them. The traders who have bids and offers sitting out in the market are even referred to as liquidity providers (as opposed to liquidity takers). There are whole exchanges out there which offer rebates to such traders for providing this liquidity (which means you actually get paid by an exchange to post liquidity).

These guys are not in the business of holding positions, they are in the business of providing trade-able liquidity. A car dealer may buy your car, then turn around and sell it the same day--that doesn't not mean they are harming the car market.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by SHOwnsYou on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:19PM (#2979237)
If liquidity exists without HFT then it's not correct for HFTers to justify their existence by claiming they are liquidity providers.

I realize the semantics of this can be argued ("existing liquidity doesn't preclude or prevent the existence HFT" for example), but not only do I think that is a wash argument but it also misses the point entirely on the utility of HFT.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by paperwork on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:45PM (#2979337)
To paraphrase professor Krishnamurthi [http://www.cs.brown.edu/~sk/] "Just semantics. That’s all there is!"

HFTers don't have to justify their existence at all. They exist because they are able to profit and their existence is not against the law. As far ethics and morality, I guess that is what we are arguing here :)

Liquidity is not pregnancy, there can be a little of it.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by fleitz on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:43PM (#2979037)
Flash crashes and short term volatility don't affect investors, they primarily affect other traders.

The issue is not whether a 30 second hold on a stock is better / worse than a 3 year hold but whether stock markets still serve their purpose of providing capital for companies. The vast majority of trades are for stock that does not capitalize the company.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by paperwork on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:52PM (#2979354)
The stock market has never provided capital for companies. Companies generally sell their stock to investment banks (stock offerings, initial or subsequent). Those initial share owners turn around and sell in the secondary market -- what we call the stock market. When I buy shares of MSFT, they don't get my money.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by andylei on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:34AM (#2978494)
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1100635

"Algorithmic trading has sharply increased over the past decade. Does it improve market quality, and should it be encouraged? We provide the first analysis of this question. The NYSE automated quote dissemination in 2003, and we use this change in market structure that increases algorithmic trading as an exogenous instrument to measure the causal effect of algorithmic trading on liquidity. For large stocks in particular, algorithmic trading narrows spreads, reduces adverse selection, and reduces trade-related price discovery. The findings indicate that algorithmic trading improves liquidity and enhances the informativeness of quotes. "

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by hackinthebochs on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:16PM (#2978651)
Can you explain how this "improved" liquidity benefits actual people? It seems to be an assumption that any increase in liquidity is always beneficial. I've never seen an actual explanation arguing how.

To put it another way, how do we know the function of liquidity to net human benefit is monotonic (always increasing) rather than having a local maximum?

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by andylei on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:50PM (#2978789)
> For large stocks in particular, algorithmic trading narrows spreads

lower spreads means you pay less when you trade, simple.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by wisty on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:07PM (#2979161)
Basically, algorithmic traders are disrupting what traditional traders used to do. In the future, Wall Street will be replaced with a couple of big server farms, and a Demand-Media style bidding system for commoditized stock analysts.

Imagine it - "Earn cash in your spare time - estimate the future profits of Fortune 500 companies, and plug them into a structured database! Senior members represent us on boards of directors, telling CEOs what the computer thinks they are really worth! (payments contingent on the long-term value of your work)."

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by hackinthebochs on Friday September 09, 2011 @04:34PM (#2979722)
Forgive my ignorance, but how so? How does the wealth extracted from the transaction play into this (arbitrage extracts value from a transaction, ideally it's made up for through liquidity).
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by SHOwnsYou on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:43PM (#2978766)
What is improving liquidity? It greatly depends on how you look at it. Do more purchases provide more liquidity? Absolutely. If I previously had 10 buyers and now I have 100, I am absolutely more able to liquify.

However, to suggest that the entire 100 are needed to liquify when 10 will do (less than 30 seconds later I might add) is farcical.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by andylei on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:52PM (#2978797)
actually, if you read the next sentence, you'd see how they measure liquidity:

> For large stocks in particular, algorithmic trading narrows spreads, reduces adverse selection, and reduces trade-related price discovery.

its not just a question of who will buy, its a question of who will buy at what price. if you have more liquidity suppliers, spreads will thin and you'll pay less.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by SHOwnsYou on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:14PM (#2979205)
That doesn't really show how they measure liquidity, but even if it did, I'm not particularly interested in how the framers of the article you linked measure liquidity.

I freely admit that if you want to measure liquidity as the amount of buyers in the marketplace, then HFT definitely increases liquidity. However, to suggest that HFT is the only source of liquidity, as I've said twice before, is farcical.

Also, it is totally accurate that HFTers reduce spread in the marketplace. They also increase the spread when they are driving the price of a stock up. Also, HFTers aren't unique to affecting the spread in the market. Every large scale buyer can change the spread.

Not only that, but my original point regarding the provision of liquidity and HFTers claiming they provide the essential job of supplying it (ie: without HFT, there would be no buyers) and I used the short period of time of the average stock position holding to suggest that the liquidity exists regardless of the existence of HFT.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by Rinum on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:15AM (#2978410)
If most trading is based on algorithms, wouldn't the market become predictable?
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by jsmcgd on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:59AM (#2978586)
The culmination of the high quantity and frequency of the trades makes the relatively simple individual operations chaotic when considered in aggregate. Much like the weather.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by nkassis on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:21AM (#2978440)
Not exactly, it might be deterministic but that doesn't mean you can predict what will happen without running it. Same as understanding the forces of a hurricane doesn't let us make very good prediction on it's path without using huge amount of computer power to run the simulation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by nandemo on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:58PM (#2978829)
Even if the automatic trading becomes a majority of the traded volume, the impact of human trading might still be higher. That is, it could be that most of automatic trading doesn't move the price much in average, while human trades make the price jump more (in reaction to news, mergers, etc). Human trading can only be eliminated if someone develops strong AI.

Besides, a lot of what is called algorithmic trading is driven by human, "manual" decisions: say a fund manager wants to buy $10 million worth of stocks someone composing the S&P 500 today, without raising the price of ACME too much, so they use a piece of software that does that automatically.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by aristidb on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:21AM (#2978439)
Warns? I think that's awesome, but maybe I just love robots too much.

That, or people just fear things they don't understand, and robot traders are even harder to understand than human traders, I guess.

Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by rsanchez1 on Friday September 09, 2011 @10:38AM (#2978250)
They should just go the extra step and completely replace these people with computers. It's not like they're doing anything with their lives anyway.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p... by known on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:29PM (#2978974)
"If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." --Reagan