Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p...
by Rinum on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:15AM
(#2978410)
If most trading is based on algorithms, wouldn't the market become predictable?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p...
by jsmcgd on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:59AM
(#2978586)
The culmination of the high quantity and frequency of the trades makes the relatively simple individual operations chaotic when considered in aggregate. Much like the weather.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p...
by nkassis on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:21AM
(#2978440)
Not exactly, it might be deterministic but that doesn't mean you can predict what will happen without running it. Same as understanding the forces of a hurricane doesn't let us make very good prediction on it's path without using huge amount of computer power to run the simulation.
Re:Algo trading rapidly replacing humans, warns government p...
by nandemo on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:58PM
(#2978829)
Even if the automatic trading becomes a majority of the traded volume, the impact of human trading might still be higher. That is, it could be that most of automatic trading doesn't move the price much in average, while human trades make the price jump more (in reaction to news, mergers, etc). Human trading can only be eliminated if someone develops strong AI.
Besides, a lot of what is called algorithmic trading is driven by human, "manual" decisions: say a fund manager wants to buy $10 million worth of stocks someone composing the S&P 500 today, without raising the price of ACME too much, so they use a piece of software that does that automatically.