News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web3 is centralized by jsemrau on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:39AM (#29766679)
My main concerns with Web3 are that it is "pay to play" in many aspects and it's less democratic than the existing Internet.
Re:Web3 is centralized by reilly3000 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:53AM (#29766740)
Agreed. The one dollar-one vote concept is fundamentally flawed, but has become the main model for crypto community governance. There aren’t a lot of viable alternatives, especially as there is no concept of a person, just free, infinite wallets and limited coins. As such, the interests of the wealthiest steer the entire community, and a bad actor could derail a project with malevolent use of voting powers. Democracy is messy at best, but where there are no ‘demos’ its nigh impossible.
Re:Web3 is centralized by mattwilsonn888 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:39AM (#29769012)
That's an interesting point. I would make the refutation that a system where large 'voters' in a DAO are forced to lock up their tokens after votes proportional to their power would prevent them from sabotaging the project, but if they had even more money at stake in a competitor its easy to imagine scenarios where such foul play may happen.

The interesting thing about governance is that it existed before the term: In Bitcoin the community governs the direction of the protocol by directing their hash power, perceived value, and simple use of the network towards their desired fork. You can't do this with contract tokens unless you want to fork the entire Ethereum Blockchain for the sake of one DAO.

Despite this limitation, if DAO pay to vote schemes could be combined with 'vote with your feet' you could have the clean, efficient governance of a DAO with the fully actionable emergency escape (a fork) in case foul play is sniffed out.

Re:Web3 is centralized by littlestymaar on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:46AM (#29767291)
> There aren’t a lot of viable alternatives, especially as there is no concept of a person, just free, infinite wallets and limited coins.

Sybil attack is the fundamental problem of the internet. (And proof of work was actually designed as a way to mitigate it)

Re:Web3 is centralized by kibwen on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:33AM (#29767227)
Note that "one dollar, one vote" describes a plutocracy, not a democracy.
Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:11AM (#29766821)
The existing internet is dominated by trillion dollar monopolies. How do you reconcile that Web3 is less democratic than a megacorp oligopoly than can unperson people at will? Web3 has decentralization, freedom of speech, anti-gatekeeping, permissionlessness and inclusiveness, at its core.
Re:Web3 is centralized by mattlondon on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:07AM (#29767112)
> Web3 has decentralization, freedom of speech, anti-gatekeeping, permissionlessness and inclusiveness, at its core.

We already have all of that in the existing web infrastructure, and have had it since the very beginning.

I can spin up a HTTP server on a raspberry pi running in my basement right now and anyone on the internet can access it for free and without any hinderence.

With web3 there is gatekeeping and centralisation as I cannot spin up my own server any more without buying crypto and then paying someone on a centralised database just so that I can do everything I could do before for free on my own.

Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:19AM (#29767167)
> With web3 there is gatekeeping and centralisation as I cannot spin up my own server any more without buying crypto and then paying someone on a centralised database just so that I can do everything I could do before for free on my own.

Web3 includes all of the previous web technologies and adds optional layers on top. It is a superset of all web tech. You can totally setup an HTTP server on a Raspberry Pi, that's totally still Web3, but good luck building a truly scalable multi-million user application and competing with AWS on that.

If your app is such that it relies on user-generated content, it wouldn't be Web3 for you to host it exclusively on your Pi, because the users generating the content would not own it, or have guarantees that the data on the Pi was not being manipulated or misused by you. The key idea of Web3 is user ownership and community ownership.

> With web3 there is gatekeeping and centralisation as I cannot spin up my own server any more without buying crypto and then paying someone on a centralised database just so that I can do everything I could do before for free on my own.

You can set up your stack however you like. You don't even have to be using cryptocurrency for payments to be "Web3". You could, for example, allow someone to login with their Ethereum wallet and use their ENS domain name as a username in your chat app rather than adding Google Auth. That doesn't even require a transaction on the blockchain, it's just verifying a cryptographic signature.

Re:Web3 is centralized by kortilla on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:07AM (#29767391)
Using certificate identities for logging in has been a thing since the 90s. It was (and is) still way better than passwords. The problem is that someone loses the cert and getting new ones is a usability disaster.

Websites intentionally switched to passwords because it was easier for users to understand. Web3 offers no breakthroughs here.

Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @06:17AM (#29767811)
Yes, when combined with ENS, I believe it does.

An Ethereum wallet linked with an ENS domain name is: 1) human readable 2) has an on-chain history that is verifiable and reviewable (important for establishing reputation in social applications) 3) benefits from UX improvements in Ethereum wallets, such as Argent's social recovery feature (https://www.argent.xyz/blog/argent-secure-decentralised-ethe...) as well as secure hardware wallets (which address the concern about losing a cert) 4) builds on the network effects of EVM-compatible wallets which makes the experience more familiar to more users 5) can integrate other features such as ENS-linked profile pictures, NFT verification, payments, crypto-based crowdfunding and donations seamlessly 6) user-owned

Can also drop the ENS altogether and embrace anonymity if the user or application desires. Still benefits from most of the above.

Re:Web3 is centralized by root_axis on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:41AM (#29767266)
> allow someone to login with their Ethereum wallet and use their ENS domain name as a username in your chat app rather than adding Google Auth

You're basically describing OpenID, which predates cryptocurrency by several years.

Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:49AM (#29768315)
Any tech that embraces decentralization and user ownership is considered Web3, in my mind. And any website or application that leverages that technology as a first-class citizen is considered to be Web3, in my mind. It does not have to be cryptocurrency related.

That being said, I think EVM-compatible wallet login will be stickier and have broader network effects as there are exclusive services you cannot access without it (unlike OpenId, which is merely an alternative to other logins).

There is also a major economic incentive to build user-friendly wallet experiences (such as Rainbow, Argent, and Dharma mobile apps) as well as browser plug-ins (Metamask, Coinbase Wallet, etc) and hardware devices (Ledger, GridPlus, etc) and I think that ecosystem of competition is going to produce some big UX wins that OpenId will never really be able to compete with.

Re:Web3 is centralized by robryan on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:31AM (#29768941)
Which has basically failed, probably because of complexity for regular users. I don't know much about the crypto version of this, but it is probably more complex for a new user to get started with.
Re:Web3 is centralized by lewispollard on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:35AM (#29767556)
> If your app is such that it relies on user-generated content, it wouldn't be Web3 for you to host it exclusively on your Pi, because the users generating the content would not own it, or have guarantees that the data on the Pi was not being manipulated or misused by you. The key idea of Web3 is user ownership and community ownership.

Aren't most NFT assets hosted on cloud platforms? OpenSea on GCP for example

Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @06:28AM (#29767867)
No. OpenSea is a centralized NFT marketplace not unlike how Coinbase is a centralized marketplace for fungible cryptocurrencies.

OpenSea uses GCP for hosting. But OpenSea does not own your NFTs nor choose where NFTs are hosted. OpenSea does use GCP as a caching layer for NFTs, since it's not scalable to fetch from thousands of different sources at load time.

An NFT is created by deploying a smart contract, and the creator of that contract is free to choose how that asset is hosted. Some NFTs are made entirely of on-chain (typically SVG) assets. Some choose IPFS and post the verifiable hash of the file on the blockchain (much smaller footprint and particularly important for large files). IPFS content must be pinned or hosted in order to guarantee availability and a lot of projects will rely on Filecoin or Arweave for decentralized archival of these assets. They may also host a pinning service on one of the big 3 cloud platforms for additional availability and responsiveness. In that case, even if the content was booted from the cloud co's site, the community could easily fall back on Filecoin or Arweave pin and move their content to another caching layer, with users having guarantee that the data matches the IPFS hash. And then again, some NFT projects do centrally host the content and metadata, and do so intentionally so that they can add interactivity or upgrades. For some NFTs, that's perfectly fine. It really depends on the goals of the creator. Not everything has to be perfectly pure. It's a spectrum of choice and optionality for users and makers. If you only want to purchase decentralized NFTs, then check the baseURI and contractURI of the contract (https://etherscan.io/token/0x1CB1A5e65610AEFF2551A50f76a87a7... as an example).

Re:Web3 is centralized by lewispollard on Sunday January 02, 2022 @06:52AM (#29767995)
Thanks for the clarification.
Re:Web3 is centralized by int_19h on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:17AM (#29767453)
> and anyone on the internet can access it for free and without any hinderence.

Well, right up until their ISP blocks your website. Or the DNS root removes your record.

Re:Web3 is centralized by root_axis on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:37AM (#29767241)
> Web3 has decentralization, freedom of speech, anti-gatekeeping, permissionlessness and inclusiveness, at its core.

No, web3 has "make as much money as possible" at its core - any of those other tertiary values are expendable in the name of getting rich. The trillion dollar companies also only care about getting rich, but they at least produce useful products, unlike the cryptocurrency ecosystem which is overwhelmingly made up of scams and vaporware.

Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @06:30AM (#29767871)
No, it doesn't. That's a narrative you are imposing in your own head based on dubious surface-level analysis despite being hugely unfamiliar with the space.
Re:Web3 is centralized by zaptheimpaler on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:32AM (#29766943)
For one, the author pointed out that Opensea NFTs are stored on the Google Cloud Platform, one of those trillion dollar monopolies.

Proof of stake means the largest stakeholders can unilaterally reject transactions. Technically the chain could fork. Practically, convincing everyone to move to a new chain seems about as difficult as everyone moving off Facebook because a few people get banned.

Proof of work means the richest people can afford more miners and completely control the chain.

So where is the decentralization? The only realistic decentralization I can make out is that its possible to build alternative chains, but that very thing is possible today. Its possible to build an alternate payment processor or social network if Visa bans your business, the really hard part is building it and getting the entire ecosystem to actually use it.

Re:Web3 is centralized by MrPatan on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:45AM (#29767283)
> Opensea NFTs are stored on the Google Cloud Platform

Other NFTs are fully on-chain, buy those.

This is such a weird argument to make.

Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:34AM (#29767232)
Opensea uses Google as a caching layer. NFTs on OpenSea can either be created by going through their centralized, counterfactual layer (which doesn't cost gas until someone purchases) or by deploying your own ERC721 smart contract to Ethereum or Polygon and hosting the content however you like. If you follow the ERC721 standard, you can take that NFT to any web store. It is not limited to OpenSea, even if that happens to be the most popular at this time.

> Proof of stake means the largest stakeholders can unilaterally reject transactions. Technically the chain could fork. Practically, convincing everyone to move to a new chain seems about as difficult as everyone moving off Facebook because a few people get banned.

> Proof of work means the richest people can afford more miners and completely control the chain.

> So where is the decentralization? The only realistic decentralization I can make out is that its possible to build alternative chains, but that very thing is possible today. Its possible to build an alternate payment processor or social network if Visa bans your business, the really hard part is building it and getting the entire ecosystem to actually use it.

On a POW system such as Bitcoin or ETH1, you'd need 51% or more of the hash power on the network, which is more than a hundred Google datacenters worth of hashpower, and you'd have to spend a vast amount of energy in order to execute the attack, and at the end of it all, the community would mount a fork and initiate a change that left your attack out of history. It is quite difficult to coordinate a vast amount of people to fork a major chain and have that fork be recognized as the New Bitcoin or the New Ethereum. That is where the decentralization comes in and where the guarantees of execution comes in. Blockchains are protected by cryptography and economics (game theory) as well as social consensus.

From V. Buterin: "Theoretically, a majority collusion of validators may take over a proof of stake chain, and start acting maliciously. However, (i) through clever protocol design, their ability to earn extra profits through such manipulation can be limited as much as possible, and more importantly (ii) if they try to prevent new validators from joining, or execute 51% attacks, then the community can simply coordinate a hard fork and delete the offending validators’ deposits. A successful attack may cost $50 million, but the process of cleaning up the consequences will not be that much more onerous than the geth/parity consensus failure of 2016.11.25. Two days later, the blockchain and community are back on track, attackers are $50 million poorer, and the rest of the community is likely richer since the attack will have caused the value of the token to go up due to the ensuing supply crunch. That’s attack/defense asymmetry for you. [1]"

[1] https://medium.com/@VitalikButerin/a-proof-of-stake-design-p...

Re:Web3 is centralized by paulgb on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:40AM (#29766973)
The underpinnings of the web are effectively decentralized; I can host a blog for a nominal monthly fee and have a bunch of hosts competing for my business. It’s only become centralized because we’ve allowed our attention to become centralized, and given it all to twitter/facebook/etc.

We’re already seeing the same thing happen in web3. OpenSea can (and does) remove NFTs from its marketplace if it wants to. Like the web, there are other markets you can use, and you could even permissionlessly start your own, but you’d be giving up the attention that comes from using an established platform.

Re:Web3 is centralized by kortilla on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:04AM (#29767378)
Dominated but not controlled. You can still run your own mail server, websites, etc all without depending on any FAANG infra.
Re:Web3 is centralized by brightstep on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:26AM (#29768912)
This is a real problem that will not, and can not, be solved by Web3. The power of corporate tyranny extends beyond the technological realm. It is political, cultural, and economic to name a few. You simply can't meaningfully challenge that with a technology alone.
Re:Web3 is centralized by systemsignal on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:19AM (#29766869)
Are you using any decentralized social networks significantly?
Re:Web3 is centralized by chrisco255 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:42AM (#29767272)
I've tried Mastadon and Matrix (using Element). I think they're two of the best examples. But I think for none of these have quite nailed the UX of existing social networks (Mastadon's not quite as good as Twitter and Element is not as feature-rich as Discord). I really think it's as much of a UX problem as a technology problem and not enough decentralized projects have top-tier UX and UI talent to compete.

Mirror (https://mirror.xyz/) is an interesting Web3 alternative to Medium. I think they have gotten a lot of the elements right. Blog posts are backed up to Arweave perma-storage and they have easy point and click integration for crypto donations (with automatic splitting for multiple authors), NFT auctions, and crowdfunding.

At any rate, I think decentralized social networks are still nascent and we haven't yet seen a break out success on the level of Discord or Twitter or Facebook, but I remain optimistic that it will come.

Re:Web3 is centralized by nicbou on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:26AM (#29768515)
Not only that, but the price is not adjusted to the local cost of living, making it more expensive to poorer nations. The payment gate isn't as high for every one.

I can't justify an internet that hinders the free flow of information.

Re:Web3 is centralized by JohnJamesRambo on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:18AM (#29766863)
You pay now by paying with your privacy. Someone makes great money by tracking you and selling it but it isn’t you.
Re:Web3 is centralized by nextaccountic on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:22AM (#29766883)
Web3 is even less private, since your stuff is stored in a public chain that can be deanonymized even years later.
Re:Web3 is centralized by mattwilsonn888 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:42AM (#29769039)
> Web3 is a grift.

> I am openly ignorant of recent innovations and make statements demonstrating I believe they don't exist.

Never change, HN.

Re:Web3 is centralized by nextaccountic on Monday January 03, 2022 @05:03AM (#29779105)
What do you mean?
Re:Web3 is centralized by ridethebike on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:26AM (#29766902)
not sure how web3 would solve any of that
Re:Web3 is centralized by JohnJamesRambo on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:36AM (#29767239)
Re:Web3 is centralized by echelon on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:33AM (#29766949)
> My main concerns with Web3 are that it is "pay to play" in many aspects and it's less democratic than the existing Internet.

You could say that Web3 is WebBourgeoisie.

Re:Web3 is centralized by ThomPete on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:50AM (#29766721)
Democracy isnt free. Pay to play is exactly what makes it democratic. Free is more like a benevolent dictatorship.
Re:Web3 is centralized by onethought on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:13AM (#29766833)
Clarification?

I can participate/play in my democracy with little to no cost. Unless you are arguing time (~20 minutes/year) commitments to vote?

Re:Web3 is centralized by ThomPete on Sunday January 02, 2022 @01:36PM (#29771948)
How is it little to no cost? You pay through taxes, value creation, allegiance and a bunch of other areas.
Re:Web3 is centralized by onethought on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:31AM (#29777993)
No, tax is only required on income, not related to whether I can vote or not. Don’t need to create value either. Not sure what “allegiance” means.