News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web3 is centralized by reilly3000 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:53AM (#29766740)
Agreed. The one dollar-one vote concept is fundamentally flawed, but has become the main model for crypto community governance. There aren’t a lot of viable alternatives, especially as there is no concept of a person, just free, infinite wallets and limited coins. As such, the interests of the wealthiest steer the entire community, and a bad actor could derail a project with malevolent use of voting powers. Democracy is messy at best, but where there are no ‘demos’ its nigh impossible.
Re:Web3 is centralized by mattwilsonn888 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:39AM (#29769012)
That's an interesting point. I would make the refutation that a system where large 'voters' in a DAO are forced to lock up their tokens after votes proportional to their power would prevent them from sabotaging the project, but if they had even more money at stake in a competitor its easy to imagine scenarios where such foul play may happen.

The interesting thing about governance is that it existed before the term: In Bitcoin the community governs the direction of the protocol by directing their hash power, perceived value, and simple use of the network towards their desired fork. You can't do this with contract tokens unless you want to fork the entire Ethereum Blockchain for the sake of one DAO.

Despite this limitation, if DAO pay to vote schemes could be combined with 'vote with your feet' you could have the clean, efficient governance of a DAO with the fully actionable emergency escape (a fork) in case foul play is sniffed out.

Re:Web3 is centralized by littlestymaar on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:46AM (#29767291)
> There aren’t a lot of viable alternatives, especially as there is no concept of a person, just free, infinite wallets and limited coins.

Sybil attack is the fundamental problem of the internet. (And proof of work was actually designed as a way to mitigate it)

Re:Web3 is centralized by kibwen on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:33AM (#29767227)
Note that "one dollar, one vote" describes a plutocracy, not a democracy.