News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by arcticbull on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:15AM (#29766580)
> It wasn't that long ago we used to worry about whether fuel was renewable or not, and about pollution and other environmental externalities in general, not just CO2.

These are the same thing in common parlance. High CO2 emission plants are fossil fuel driven, and those are of course non-renewable.

Wind, solar and nuclear are renewable, sustainable and low CO2. Nuclear in particular also produces very little waste as a function of power generated and extraction of uranium from seawater could fit the renewable definition.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by hammock on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:16AM (#29766585)
I guess you missed the entire headline and article where it says they will call natural gas green.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by arcticbull on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:18AM (#29766592)
It only gets the label if it's greener than existing solutions. They're not letting perfect be the enemy of good.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by belorn on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:52AM (#29768332)
There will almost always exist solutions that are greener than natural gas. The practical reason to choose natural gas over those are costs, sacrificing the environment in order to save money.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by fivea on Sunday January 02, 2022 @06:12AM (#29767786)
> It only gets the label if it's greener than existing solutions. They're not letting perfect be the enemy of good.

That sounds very idiotic to me. One of the biggest environmental threats is global warming, which is caused by reintroducing carbon into the atmosphere through the use of fossil fuels. It makes no sense at all to label fossil fuel usage as green just because they manage to come up with an arbitrary line in the sand for unrelated pollutants and in the process ignore carbon emissions.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by input_sh on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:54AM (#29768701)
It's caused by an ever increasing amount of CO2 in the atmosphere, and it's solvable by drastically decreasing that amount. Its origin is nowhere in that equation.

> and in the process ignore carbon emissions.

Natural gas is the best of the worst, and it contributes to the solution in the specific case where it replaces even worse options (like coal plants). I'd argue that <270g CO2 per kWh is far too high of a threshold, but that's still at least a half of what even the "cleanest" coal plants produce per kWh.

It's not the best solution and nobody is arguing that, but it is a solution in very specific circumstances.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by unionpivo on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:37AM (#29768597)
> They're not letting perfect be the enemy of good.

The best you can do sometimes, its just to be less bad. If you can replace coal or diesel powered power plant into modern gas powered plant, you will emit a lot less CO2 for equivalent power.

Solar and wind are not enough jet. We need something that can produce electricity 24 hours a day, or on demand. The "greenest" such tech are nuclear and gas.

I have high hopes of geothermal, maybe replacing a lot of gas, but we are not there jet.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by nameisname on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:10AM (#29768422)
The threat is humanity. The amount of pollution that will ultimately be created by the gas plants is a drop in the bucket compared to humanity overall and will largely be offset by renewables.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by lrem on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:26AM (#29766899)
Aren't they aiming to do that for plants that will be using synthetic methane as alternative to battery storage?
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by fivea on Sunday January 02, 2022 @06:09AM (#29767766)
> Aren't they aiming to do that for plants that will be using synthetic methane as alternative to battery storage?

I saw no reference to origin or source or type of gas.

All I saw were references to low emissions.

It seems they decided to redefine "green" as "not coal".

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by onethought on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:18AM (#29766864)
Nuclear is not renewable… right? Ie there is a finite amount of nuclear material on earth and it’s not overly abundant either.

Am I missing something?

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by fennecfoxen on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:33AM (#29766946)
There's 5.5 million tons of known uranium reserves. If you took our current reactor fleet and replaced it with fast breeders, this would supply it for 30,000 years. There's also 4.5 billion tons of uranium dissolved in seawater. Then there's thorium.

You're missing that.

Technically not renewable, but in the long run, neither is the Sun.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by donny2018 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:10AM (#29767123)
Hopefully, fusion energy will be reality way before we will be close to depleting known uranium resources.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by cm2187 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:35AM (#29768224)
At the current pace, 30,000 years sounds about right,
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by AstralStorm on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:22AM (#29768874)
It's not that bad, currently at breakeven point for laser fusion and close to that for magnetic containment fusion. Half a century should be enough, but we lack the time.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by rsj_hn on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:22AM (#29766880)
Breeder reactors can create more fuel, but even without these, there is a substantial amount of uranium that this is a non-issue. By the same token, solar is also non-renewable since it requires real resources mined from the earth which are in finite supply and solar panels are not 100% recyclable (and especially not the batteries required to make solar reliable). In this sense, nothing is renewable -- even hydro will run out eventually when the earth cools and plate tectonics comes to an end.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by otherme123 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:28AM (#29767504)
Anyway, nuclear is never included in the "renewable" bucket, because the fuel has to be harvested and doesn't renew on a human timescale. Nuclear is green, because its net emissions are almost zero.

OTOH burning wood is renewable, but not green, and also not sustainable. So nothing inherently good about being renewable.

It's pointless to have a practical classification to then come with "technically..." and some weird and unpractical reason.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by arcticbull on Sunday January 02, 2022 @12:13PM (#29770678)
> Anyway, nuclear is never included in the "renewable" bucket, because the fuel has to be harvested and doesn't renew on a human timescale.

You can make the case that it does - if you count uranium in seawater. Theres enough dissolved there now to fuel all the reactors on earth for 60,000 years. Geological processes continually replenish the dissolved uranium.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by otherme123 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @01:52PM (#29772161)
Yes, and you can argue that coal and oil are currently being created... very slowly... from dead trees and what not. So renewable vs non-renewable doesn't make any sense anymore.

Lets make another name: "energy which source can get replenished in less than 100 years (a life time), as wood, or less, as solar, wind, waves, and can be practically harvested with current methods i.e. not fussion or matter dissolved in the sea". That's the whole phrase you should use from now on instead of "renewable".

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by arcticbull on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:31PM (#29772695)
Solar isn't something that can ever be replenished. There's a fixed quantity of fuel in the sun. Once it burns out, it's gone. That provides the input energy into the process for solar, wind and wood.

With breeder reactors the uranium in seawater would last us 15 million years at current nuclear power consumption levels. If that's not renewable...

There's no such thing as infinitely renewable.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by otherme123 on Monday January 03, 2022 @04:03AM (#29778763)
I though it was already clear that we were talking human scale. And you still talk about 4,500 million years as non-renewable, but 15 million years (plus 100% magic ocean harvesting) as renewable. At no point anybody said "infinitely renewable", and you arguing it makes that a strawman argument.

Renewable is defined, like it or not, as a source that replenishes in a finite human scale (roughly, 50-100 years). Sun, waves, hydraulics and wind "replenish" everyday. Wood takes about 30 years. If you find yourself saying things like "15 millions years" or "60,000" years, it's not renewable.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by ben_w on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:49AM (#29767646)
> solar panels are not 100% recyclable (and especially not the batteries required to make solar reliable)

While I can believe that we don’t have a current recycling chain set up for these, I absolutely do not believe that they are genuinely non-recyclable.

We make both of these out of a variety of literal rocks, extracting trace elements and purifying them greatly in the process of manufacture. Even in the worst case, it’s easier to start from the end products than from rocks.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by pyrale on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:35AM (#29768975)
Nothing is indefinitely renewable. In the end, the second law of thermodynamics is an immovable barrier. When we talk about renewable, it's never endless, it's renewable within reason.

When it comes to nuclear though, the people claiming it's renewable usually refer to the presence of uranium in seewater, which is leeched from the ocean floor. That fits within the "renewable within reason" frame I talked about before. The issue with making that case is that collecting uraium from seawater is experimental reearch at this point ; it's definitely not an industrial process. Other examples of people conflating research with established industrial standards include people claiming we can get rid of nuclear waste with new reactors, or people claiming that we can recycle wind turbine blades.

A reasonable case to be made is that, while nuclear is not renewable, the reserves we have is enough to let us buy another century of research and a reasonable chance to find more long-lasting solutions, whether it would be a great storage technology, fusion, new fission technology, a smart grid or whatever.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by iso1210 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:18AM (#29768465)
Solar is not renewable, at some point the sun will die.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by Krasnol on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:39AM (#29768250)
You're missing the fact that many EU countries failed to invest into renewables in the recent year and now need to greenwash what they have instead...
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by gefhfffh on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:31AM (#29767526)
Nuclear is sustainable? Tell me more
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by arcticbull on Sunday January 02, 2022 @11:56AM (#29770419)
Nuclear is definitely sustainable [1]. There's at least four billion tons of Uranium dissolved in seawater, enough to power humanity until the heat death of the universe [+]. We just have to figure out how to get it out. [2] The amount in the ocean is constantly replenished through geological activity so one could even make the case its renewable too.

[+] There's 5.5 million metric tons of known uranium deposits. Switching to breeder reactors, which produce more fuel than they consume, would allow that supply to match current generation capacity for 30,000 years. Then there's the 4.5 billion metric tons in seawater. That'll get us 15 million years worth of power.

[1] https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/3-reasons-why-nuclear-cle...

[2] https://www.pnnl.gov/news/release.aspx?id=4514

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by kewrkewm53 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:44AM (#29768643)
Anything that helps avoiding a climate catastrophe short-term is a good idea since it buys us time to switch to truly sustainable sources.