News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by umvi on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:33PM (#29765165)
Nuclear pollution is scary but coal pollution isn't? I bet coal pollution has killed way more than nuclear pollution per plant.
Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by phs318u on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:07AM (#29766543)
You're conflating pollution (which I take to mean typical by-products of both fuel generation i.e. during mining, and power generation i.e. at the plant) and catastrophic destruction of the plant.

You may well be correct with respect to pollution - I don't know and certainly would find it tricky to determine (is there a consistent measure of "negative environmental impact" for comparing such things?).

However, with respect to catastrophic destruction, this recent example at a coal plant [0], pales in comparison to something like a Chernobyl or Fukushima.

[0] https://reneweconomy.com.au/worlds-newest-and-most-expensive...

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by sofixa on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:11AM (#29768094)
> However, with respect to catastrophic destruction, this recent example at a coal plant [0], pales in comparison to something like a Chernobyl or Fukushima.

That's not a catastrophic destruction, merely a generator explosion.

Wikipedia has articles on mining and energy accidents, and you can see there are far more catastrophic one with coal:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_accident

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by forgotmyoldname on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:49PM (#29765273)
I think part of that is due to nuclear power primarily being in decently wealthy areas with very strict regulations and high amounts of security measures being taken. Coal plants are in even the poorest, most run down areas and run by just about everyone. They’re the baseline for energy.

I support expanding nuclear energy in areas that are capable of doing so, but there are some places where nuclear would be an absolute disaster far beyond what coal could ever be.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by rich_sasha on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:11AM (#29766556)
You could imagine, if this were to be made a global priority, a UN organisation dedicated to running nuclear plants around the world, with protection by UN forces etc.

I can’t see it happening in the current anti-nuclear climate but I think it’s fixable.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by max002 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:14AM (#29766573)
Wont happen, there are much more nuclear plants set to be closed than created.
Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by merb on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:53PM (#29765296)
both are bad and scary? why even bring them up together? there is no need to bet because both are stupid so why should nuclear power be defended here?

do you know why there is no article how bad coal is? because everybody knows but unfortunatly most people do not understand how fucking bad fukushima even is, people like you that try to make nuclear look cool just because there exists something worse does not make nuclear look cooler.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by nindalf on Saturday January 01, 2022 @10:02PM (#29765355)
> why even bring them up together

Because reams of news articles are written about one but not the other, feeding the incorrect perception that one is vastly more dangerous than the other.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by olliej on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:31PM (#29765843)
Here's the problem with coal power, the damage is not equatable to nuclear plants:

There is no way to control the impact to the environment - areas immediately surrounding a coal plant have much higher cancer rates, the ground & streams becomes toxic, wider areas have heightened acid rain risks. Then you get to impact on the global climate. All this in a perfectly operated idealized plant.

In a nuclear plant that is run properly, not even perfectly, produces radioactive waste. No atmospheric pollution, no water pollution.

Major "normal" failures cause radiation leaks. These are so rare that the events are individually named. Accidents that result in atypical operation that don't even harm the plant, let alone cause external impact are all recorded, and systems are updated to prevent recurrence. Even major events like three mile island have not caused any excess deaths or cancers.

Catastrophic failures have basically be down to understood design flaws: Chernobyl had an RBMK reactor with know flaws, Fukushima had emergency generators in the basement despite being advised to place them higher up. Precisely because of flooding concerns.

As for waste: Nuclear waste is of course hard to manage, with most "solutions" being "bury it". Whatever the end solution is, we know it won't be as horrific as a coal plants solution: aerosolizing it and pumping it into the atmosphere.

A lot of noise is made about decommissioning a nuclear plant. Decommission a nuclear plant means deconstruction of the reactor and removing the remaining waste. There is no need to remediate the land itself. No one talks about decommissioning coal plants as they simply don't: the land on and around the site is left permanently toxic.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by sascha_sl on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:34AM (#29767231)
Not to deter from your point, but said basement was far far above the water line and even above the flood wall. And different placement would have been more risky for earthquake damage. The failing was the insufficient flood wall, which TEPCO very definitely knew about, with almost exactly this scenario predicted, not the placement of backup generators.
Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by bsder on Saturday January 01, 2022 @10:13PM (#29765413)
> do you know why there is no article how bad coal is? because everybody knows but unfortunatly most people do not understand how fucking bad fukushima even is

And most people have zero idea how bad coal is.

How many lakes and streams has nuclear destroyed? Nowhere near the number that coal has between both acid rain and mine runoff. The Monongahela river and its tributaries still have enormous sulfate loads.

How many people have died of nuclear radioactivity? Nowhere near the amount that have died of black lung.

And this is before we start talking about just how bad the pollution in Pittsburgh, Cleveland, etc. used to be and how many people died from that.

People don't understand even the tiniest fraction of how bad coal is. Nuclear power, even with accidents, is a saint compared to coal.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by ineedasername on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:16PM (#29765767)
Don't forget about decades-long fires burning underground due to mining accidents. Not small ones either, miles long:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_mine_fire

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by shawnz on Sunday January 02, 2022 @12:09AM (#29766023)
They should be brought up together because coal is in common use today, nuclear is well equipped to replace it, and nuclear uses about one million times less fuel than coal does to fulfill the same demand.
Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by techsin101 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:38PM (#29765875)
yes, coal doesn't lead to a choice between obliterating northern hemisphere vs living with 30x radiation.
Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by shepherdjerred on Saturday January 01, 2022 @10:52PM (#29765645)
Worst case for nuclear is probably worse than the worst case for coal. The planet might be transformed in unwanted ways due to global warming, but that's better than it becoming irradiated and inhospitable to life.

That being said I still think that nuclear is our best option.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by kortex on Sunday January 02, 2022 @12:25AM (#29766096)
Chernobyl was literally the worst case for nuclear power. The design flaws were myriad and the industry has learned a tremendous amount. It's not going to irradiate the whole planet, full stop.

Coal is killing the planet now.

Re:Tepco slow to respond to growing crisis at Fukushima plant by shepherdjerred on Sunday January 02, 2022 @12:32PM (#29770978)
Chernobyl could have been much, much worse. It was successfully contained.