That is, the right and legitimacy of that right, is restricted to the state.
Absent this, one of three conditions exist;
1. There is no monopoly. In which case violence is widespread, and there is no state.
2. There is no legitimacy. In which case violence is capricious. This is the condition of tyranny (unaccountable power).
3. Some non-state power or agent assumes the monopoly on legitimate violence. In which case it becomes, by definition the State.
A "non-state" actor would ultimately need some recourse to compulsion to avoid the 2nd condition being elected by some other power.
https://archive.org/details/economysociety00webe/page/54/mod...
Neither private corporations nor supranational orgs have something like a parliament, checks and balances or elections.
Global connectivity is alright, but I'd rather not have my ability to take part in democracy replaced with the ability to make memes and like random stuff on twitter.
And if this guy believes we won't need any method for organising and distributing power in the future, because it'll all be distributed ancap magic on the blockchain, I'll have some bridge NFTs to sell to him.
Memes in the larger sense of contagious ideas are as political as it gets and have been driving social action for millennia.
If Martin Luther's time used TikTok, his 95 Theses might've been set to a catchy dance routine.
If you squint really hard. I think this overlooks the following points:
- The "election" is not fair: It's extremely easy to buy additional votes (i. e. stock) and extend your influence - this results in certain investors having orders of magnitude more voting power than others. On the other hand, when you don't own stock, you don't have any voting power at all, even though the company can very much affect your life.
- There is no clear process to appoint candidates. In a parliamentary democracy, potential candidates can choose between different parties to try and run for - or even found their own party. In a corporation, candidates for the board are chosen from within the company.
- There are no checks and balances and no constitution. The C-suite and the board are maybe comparable to a government, but there is no equivalent to a parliament or an independent judiciary. The board has no other obligation than ensuring revenue.
1. "The election is not fair/can be bought" Democracy's got that one all right.
2.a. "no clear process to appoint candidates" I'm sure the process is explicit in company bylaws or country laws.
2.b. "In a corporation, candidates for the board are chosen from within the company." Hmm, I thought public company board members were typically chosen from outside the company but I could be wrong.
3. "There are no checks and balances and no constitution." Most companies have "bylaws" which govern their operations.
The biggest difference between company and government is that companies are subordinate to governments while governments (or confederations like the EU) are only ever have peers, there is no higher entity to which they answer. And that in turn allows companies to somewhat outsource enforcement of (by)laws and contracts to governments. The sci-fi trope of trans-national mega-corps answering to no government puts companies at the level of, or even higher than, countries, and then they need private armies of soldiers, not just of lawyers.
The only reason civilian governments exist is thei are best way of extracting value out of economy to be spent by armies.
Armies don't serve governments and people. We all serve the armies. And if somebody stops, armies take over and mix things up so they can keep exctracting value, being powerful and doing nothing of economic utility.
The book’s central thesis is an expansion of the ideas in TFA. He predicted something like bitcoin in the book and opined on how a supranational currency would inevitably lead to something of an anarcho-capitalist existance. He spends a lot of pages on the loss of nation’s monopoly on violence.
https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/The_Sovereign_Individ...
In his view, countries would ultimately be forced to bid for citizens to choose to put down roots there. The would become more akin to privately owned and run civic service enterprises.
For what it’s worth, i finished the book thinking he underestimated the desire for many humans to live near where they were born but i was impressed that he predicted bitcoin about 30 years ahead of its time.
I mean, the first part of that prediction seems desirable and increasingly reality. Already today, it's gotten a lot more common to migrate between countries (at least if you're rich and/or qualified enough and have the right country of origin...)
As for the second part, I'm continuously amazed how free-market fundamentalists seem to view "my way of the highway" as a viable way to run a state.
If I get to choose in which one of three authoritarian countries I want to spend my life, this will not magically make the countries stop being authoritarian due to some nebulous competition.
People would accept the most stable or well-managed currencies (or switch into them quickly, if they're using currency as a store of value), and so deter chancellors from debauching their national currency.
Sullivan does a pretty good job (and a much better one than I'd thought reading through the first part of the book) of predicting and laying out the fault lines of our present Internet, including some eerily accurate scyring of our present wars on facts and institutions, as well as the rise of monopolies and the fall of traditional journalism.
- They are going to have to figure out how to cater for nation states monopoly on violence and all the coercive power this gives them. I think this is a bigger thing than some people realise.
- One way of demonstrating this might be to demonstrate they can deliver outcomes that are better for people than the efforts of nation states can provide. I don't think we have seen this so far and I am skeptical that this will ever be the case.
Diffusion of power amongst international corporations? I think we are experiencing the high tide of powerful corporations that can play one jurisdiction over another. I think nation states will increasingly and successfully to defend themselves, in groups if need be, against these players. For similar reasons, I don't think we will see change coming from the crypto currency movement, or for other decentralising technologies to make this happen. I think the only alternative in the short to medium term for competent national governance is a failed society and regression in measurable human outcomes.
Supranational bodies? The authority of UN bodies seems to be draining away, they are hollowed out and their purpose become obscure.