News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by dantheman on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:21PM (#2975019)
I have to completely disagree, there isn't enough innovation in the programming language space. The more people we have writing languages and the more people using them, the more quickly we'll discover new patterns and improved ways of doing things. Improved programming languages with better abstractions, better guarantees can allow whole new classes of programs to be written. Of course, they could be written using traditional techniques but the complexity and difficulty involved can make them almost impossible.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by vladd on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:27PM (#2975047)
Imagine Microsoft announcing a browser different than IE...

That's what Google is doing: a company famous for closing fast projects that don't get immediate traction launches a new programming language when they have Go out there already...

Programming languages are like platform APIs: they effectively lock-in you into their environment. If you're in academia or doing research, you're free to throw out there whatever you want, but I'm not switching my development into this, at this stage there's too much risk and no proven benefits.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by Rusky on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:44PM (#2975121)
So don't switch your development to it. It's an experiment- academia, hobbyists, and other people who don't care about getting locked in will try it out and learn from it. Then either the language will succeed and you can switch if it turned out well, or it will fail and the programming community will learn from it.

Just because Google is doing it doesn't mean it can't be an academic experiment. Experimentation with new programming languages is very much more useful than with new browsers, because you can't easily slap on new features to a programming language whereas you can on browsers.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by InclinedPlane on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:42PM (#2975783)
Paradox: how can a language become successful if it is only ever used in academia and hobbies? Look at perl, javascript, php, coffeescript, scala, etc. These languages became successful precisely because people started using them for production projects more or less on day 1.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by Rusky on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:42PM (#2976147)
Example: some hobbyist will write an amazing web app with it and then some small studio will pick it up and it can grow from there. A lot of hobbyists are also professionals.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by buff-a on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:24PM (#2975739)
Or it will succeed, you'll start using it, and then they'll pull the plug on it, or find some way to charge an outrageous amount of money for it.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by scott_s on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:46PM (#2975127)
I can't find details on Dart, but it sounds like it addresses a different need than Go.

Go is a systems programming language. Its goal is to supplant C and C++. I'm not sure what exactly they mean by "structured web programming," but it does not sound like a systems programming language would naturally fill that goal.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by icebraining on Thursday September 08, 2011 @09:54PM (#2976454)
That's the definition of Go, but I've been using it, and I wouldn't mind at all writing a web backend using it. Its very pleasant and high level, despite having low level features. The static duck typing definitively helps.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by aaronblohowiak on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:46PM (#2975131)
Go is not meant to be a web programming language, but rather a systems programming language.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by enneff on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:18AM (#2977465)
Actually, Go is great for writing web apps. Just not on the client side.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by estel on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:06PM (#2975456)
No proven benefits?

Not exactly a surprise for a language whose announcement has only just been announced.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:26PM (#2975041)
I completely disagree with your disagreement.

There is plenty of innovation in the programming language space. There is too much. We're too busy working out how to talk to the machines versus how to get problems solved. We're here to solve problems, not serve the machines.

In fact, the shortage is in computer-science research. There has been NOTHING as fundamentaly important as Knuth's work in the last couple of decades. It's an innovation standstill. Nothing fundamentally better than the UNIX and LISP paradigms is out there for example.

Until something fundamental changes, most of what we have will do the job fine.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pnathan on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:09PM (#2975209)
Agreed. Right now the only significant research breakthrough I've seen is the work on formal analysis of programs.

I have read hundreds of computer science papers from the 60s, 70s and 80s as part of my academic work, and frankly, everything I'm seeing today was conceptualized and/or invented then. It's staggeringly obvious if you read the sweep of history as written by journal article titles in, say, Software Practice & Experience, between 1970 and 2010. Somewhere in the late 80s things just peter out.

I strongly suspect a few things have come into play here.

* Disdain for formal mathematics by software writers. Mathematics is so absolutely key to heavy-duty breakthroughs in computer science.

* Increasing percentages of academics who never worked in the real world (and consequently knew how to get stuff done or what really matters).

* Lack of the academic industrial research labs such (Hi MS Labs! You are awesome! Keep it up please!). Also, lack of massive DARPA/DoD/DoE & NASA funding.

* The general decline of academic research quality, sacrificed on the altar of metrics (e.g., papers per year) & budget cuts.

* Friction caused by standards and legacy data & code. It's easy to innovate in a greenfield world. When you have to support five gazillion things & have 'batteries included', barriers to adoption are a lot higher.

I suspect major seminal work in the next decade will come from the Haskell crowd, since they are the most mathematics-heavy writers, and it is gaining traction in Microsoft and Google, which have the budget to support offbeat research.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by beambot on Thursday September 08, 2011 @08:51PM (#2976311)
So... you're given a blank check, either as a industrial research lab manager or DARPA program manager. What "revolutionary" research in CS would you champion?

It's easy to be critical from the sidelines. There are very smart people still working in this space, including Knuth himself.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pnathan on Thursday September 08, 2011 @09:38PM (#2976417)
Well, that's a good challenge. As it so happens, I do do research for my Master's, although sadly, it's just evolutionary, due to me not being bright enough, time & funds. Fortunately for my graduation date, I don't have to come up with something seminal. :-) I am working on some parallel debugging technology for an XMOS XCore chip. It's mostly a rehash of techniques...from the 80s. :-)

If I had a really revolutionary idea, I would have dug up a PhD program to sponsor me and be working on it, telling it everyone who would listen. I don't have that class of ideas right now. Research is hard, and takes a lot of very bright people collaborating for years and creating a good tribal knowledge to come up with really strong results. The MIT lab is a good example, as is the Bell labs.

For an evolutionary approach, I would like to revisit the on-demand compilation to native code of dynamic languages. Getting Python/Ruby/Perl to compile native on the fly would provide an efficiency boost. (Please note, Steel Bank Common Lisp already does this).

Another needed research area is a usable and robust certificate authority system. Diginotar/Comodo-style hacks need to stop, ASAP.

Yet another evolutionary approach would be to work on a provably secure/levels of trust style system for phones operating systems (c.f. early 80s DARPA research).

A more revolutionary research program would be to revisit the WIMP metaphors for computer use. Review the early Stanford/PARC research and take a different jumping off point. I strongly suspect there's a local maximum of awesome between pure CLI and pure WIMP, and we've not gotten there yet.

A more ambitious (possibly physically impossible?) project would be to determine how to create massive WiFi ranges: single WiFi hubs that easily cover a mile. Determining how to create, say, 10Gbit Wifi would provide a very nice public good.

I've had good success working with CSP-style parallelism, and would love to see more parallel constructions that use it (c.f. occam). That avenue may be the 'normal' way forward for parallel code.

None - NONE - of the above technologies is more than a rehash of old tech.

SCADA systems are sickeningly insecure/fragile. I would fund heavy-duty research into how to put together secure SCADA systems (Protocols, operating systems, control centers, etc, etc), and have them be a straightforward upgrade. I suspect that satisfying the constraints of SCADA systems would result in some interesting new knowledge.

Possibly a distributed yet authoritative CA system would induce some groundbreaking algorithms relating to trust and efficient distributed systems.

Automatic testing, verification, and reliability analyses based on Software Contracts instead of HM typing seems like it'd be fruitful to me, but I don't know the state of the art there.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by andrewflnr on Thursday September 08, 2011 @11:16PM (#2976627)
Thank you. You've almost single-handedly convinced me that it might be worth my time to do real research during my CS education. A lot of those sound interesting.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pnathan on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:07AM (#2976911)
Hi andrewflnr, thank you for your kind comment.

Nearly everything in the software/computer science world can be an area of active research if you start looking into it. It takes a lot of digging to get to the point of active research in some areas, particularly in the ones that have been well studied. Most of a typical undergraduate course will only prepare you for reading the research; most of a master's is about getting you ready to actually contribute something (the thesis). The PhD is where the real action starts happening for most people.

Why is that? The '10000 hours' in computer science is usually needed to get you to the point where you can start contributing significant work. It is absolutely worth your time to spend time working on real research. The caveat is the place of research determines the coolness. Some places... you run tests. Some places... you do some really awesome work. Look into REUs if you're still an undergraduate. Those are essentially internships for academics. They are paid. :-)

I would be happy to communicate further with you; my email address is in my profile.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by beambot on Friday September 09, 2011 @06:49AM (#2977623)
That sounds like a very good list. Just to throw my hat into the ring... don't forget about robotics. I really love my work:

http://healthcare-robotics.com/

http://www.hizook.com/blog/2010/10/16/pr2-robot-autonomously...

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by ThaddeusQuay2 on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:48PM (#2979346)
I won't be impressed by your robots until they can do this.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=c2JChnwv2Ws

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by danssig on Friday September 09, 2011 @10:22AM (#2978188)
Good list. There is also interesting work that could be done starting where Strongtalk and/or Self left off (well, Strongtalk is still alive afaik but progressing slowly). Image based programming is very different than "cult of the dead" programming and I think it still has a lot to teach us.

I'd also like to see more effort going into generic functions. This is clearly a superset of message passing and is more powerful (e.g. no need for the visitor or related patterns).

I'd also like to see effort put into exploring the CL conditions systems. Exceptions already made programming more robust, conditions give the developer full control over error handling.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by awj on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:22AM (#2978444)
> I'd also like to see effort put into exploring the CL conditions systems. Exceptions already made programming more robust, conditions give the developer full control over error handling.

In my opinion, almost every language I've worked with could be improved with a CL style condition system. (every language that already has exceptions could :P) I'd love to see a more popular language pick this up and run with it. Especially if there's been research/improvements beyond what you get in CL.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by joebadmo on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:06PM (#2976487)
IANACS, but I think the time is right for new ui paradigms too. Here are my thoughts: http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/9325300749/a-different-kind-o...
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by MaysonL on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:54AM (#2976879)
Given a blank check, I'd split it between Gilad Brachs for Newspeak development, and Alan Kay to further the work being done at VPRI.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by jules on Friday September 09, 2011 @06:39AM (#2977604)
For the field of programming language design ask yourself this question: what will programming be like in 50 years? Will we still be typing characters into VIM? I don't think so. Looking a little forward can go a long way.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by ajanuary on Friday September 09, 2011 @07:10AM (#2977651)
That's what they kept saying 25 years ago, yet look where we are...
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by apotheon on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:18PM (#2982865)
Well . . . what they said 25 years ago was probably about Berkeley vi, not Vim, so I guess in 50 years we'll be using something two generational advances forward from Vim.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by apotheon on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:26PM (#2982877)
Honestly, I think that in 50 years either we'll still be doing textual programming, just at a higher and more dynamic level, or we won't be doing any programming at all because the machines will have left our ability to contribute well behind.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by wyck on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:33AM (#2977279)
I would put together a team of super hero's that doesn't care so much about languages and goes straight for the guts of the systems, the 1's and 0's. That is what is holding everything back, it's a very primitive system. The future is in 3-d, literally. Multi-valued, multi-relationship, multi-patterned, the math is there, but no one has figured out how to make it into an actual machine yet.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:07PM (#2975676)
Thank you - this is my entire line of thought.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by Rusky on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:58PM (#2975176)
Language innovation is tightly tied into computer science innovation. There are plenty of paradigms that are fundamentally different and quite potentially better than UNIX and LISP out there- you just need to get out of that rut.

Mozilla's language [Rust](https://www.github.com/graydon/rust/wiki) is working on static verification (using typestate) and concurrency in a C/C++ level language.

The Haskell community has several people ([Conal Elliot](http://conal.net), [Luke Palmer](http://lukepalmer.wordpress.com)) who are working on new models of functional I/O such as functional reactive programming.

There is a lot of programming language innovation in parallel/concurrent programming that's just hitting mainstream- actor model, asynchronous programming, CUDA/OpenCL, etc.

The way you talk to the machine is an extremely important part of "how to get problems solved." If you can't express something without absurd amounts of overhead, you're not going to solve the problem that way.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:06PM (#2975200)
Look at the fragmentation in your comment above.

It should start with math and formal verification (top down) rather than with the language (bottom up).

Start here: http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/ewd10xx/EWD1036.PDF

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by jerf on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:48PM (#2975383)
You should read more of the links provided before just snarkily assuming that nobody in that set has a math background. To the contrary, it's hard to find people in that list who aren't coming at things from a formal angle.

Also, trying to beat people doing real work about the ears with ancient Dijkstra quotes stopped being helpful about 30 years ago. He's not the ultimate authority on how a programming language should look in 2011. If you're so sure you've got a good bead on the problem, why don't you go solve it for us then?

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by Rusky on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:43PM (#2975365)
I'm not sure what you're saying.

Do you honestly expect every PL researcher to all work on the same magical super-language? No- they're going to work on the problem in their area of expertise and create/modify a language to show off their ideas. Then a language like Scala or Haskell or Clojure can come along and improve on them or combine them.

Every field works this way. That's why there is more than one particle collider, more than one drug for each problem, more than one theory of particle physics, more than one programming language.

Your link talks about radical change over gradual change in computer science. It seems to support the idea of creating new and dramatically programming languages. The idea that "small" changes have large effects discourages the gradual modification of existing paradigms and languages.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by yxhuvud on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:23PM (#2975278)
The reason there is a lot of fragmentation is that there is a lot of different problems out there to solve. There are no pana cea that solves every problem at once.

It should start with a problem and then formulating abstractions to make the problem easier to solve. Or in other words with defining a language and then see what properties it has. Starting with the verifications gives you very well defined properties, but it doesn't solve your problems because you will then optimize your language for the wrong thing.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by naasking on Friday September 09, 2011 @10:31AM (#2978220)
What do you think a formal language is if not mathematical? Researchers invent little languages to distill the problem to its simplest components so its solvable, and then they generalize to other domains, if possible. That's how math is done.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by kunley on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:33PM (#2975320)
I disagree with your disagreement of the original disagreement.

Plenty of languages does not mean plenty of innovation; in the web programming there's certainly too less of it. Every new or currently fashioned language evolves to a point where community implements its own Rails in it. I hope you don't call this trend innovation because it's not.

There were some promising trends in web programming like use of delimited continuations, but they didn't make a breakthrough. Today's web dev still is a hack around stateless http protocol, requires you to know at least 3 languages and there are no composable components you could easily reuse. World definitely needs innovation in this area.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by Rusky on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:54PM (#2975409)
Definitely agree. Mainstream language design seems to be stuck on endless variations of Ruby, JavaScript, and Java. I would love to see as many new languages as we have now, but focused on more significant changes than "Lisp without macros and a slightly tweaked generics system."
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by hbbio on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:13AM (#2977455)
You should really check Opa, which has been discussed several times here. The syntax does not please everyone (and can evolve) but at least it is built on original concepts. See http://opalang.org. An alternative is Ur/Web if you're that curious.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by wnight on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:42PM (#2976563)
Like AI, if you define innovation as something large enough then we'll never get there.

I think there's a lot in the small steps. It's only by implementing a framework ten times that it'll be done really well. In one language you'd never get traction for the later frameworks. If each community does one with knowledge of the ones before them eventually a great implementation will be created.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by 0x12 on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:14PM (#2975698)
> In fact, the shortage is in computer-science research.

and

> There is plenty of innovation in the programming language space.

Are at odds with each other. All of the programming languages that we use today can trace their roots back to computer-science research, either in the dark ages or in the immediate past.

Things like software transactional memory and other goodies are the pay-offs from that research and those things are only now making their way into programming languages.

You can't have the one without the other. And that goes both ways, computer-science research needs to have people that try the concepts it comes up with in the marketplace to see what survives in an adversarial context, so that it will be able to make the next step based on what survived and what didn't. So that's two birds with one stone, it's a proving ground and the foundation for the next generation of concepts.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:48PM (#2975808)
Computer science != programming language. Computer science is at a far lower level of abstraction than meta-languages and compilers.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by scott_s on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:22PM (#2976098)
Most people I know consider programming languages and compilers a part of computer science. This set of people is mostly computer science researchers, some of whom (including myself) who do work in the area.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:48PM (#2976163)
That's at a very high level. It's part of, but it's not the driving force behind what is possible. That is the constraints of the universe and consequentially mathematics, on which there is little focus these days.

Programming languages and compilers are the easy part of the problem. Translation is almost completely solved. However, the abstractions over the top at both the conceptual and structural level (logic->machine) are definitely not solved.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by scott_s on Thursday September 08, 2011 @08:15PM (#2976237)
I disagree. I think the most pressing issue facing computer science right now is how to express and exploit parallelism in a way that most programmers can benefit in most applications that they write. The expression part of that problem is languages and compilers. The exploitation part of that problem is compilers and systems.

Anyway, it sounds like when you say "computer science" you mean what most of us call "theoretical computer science." You're free to define words however you want, but you should expect confusion when you try to communicate with other people using those words.

Theoretical computer science is still actively researched. You seem pretty confident that not much is going on, but do you keep up with their conferences and journals?

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:54AM (#2977170)
I do keep on top of things, but unfortunately the academic "industry" doesn't like to really push the boat out. Radicalism and original thought are frowned upon in the scientific community. Everything is the same ideas recycled and repackaged slightly differently.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by naasking on Friday September 09, 2011 @10:39AM (#2978253)
Completely disagreed. There is a lot of language creation, but little language innovation. Ruby, Python, Perl, Lua, JavaScript are essentially all the same language. Java and C# are the same, and very similar to the scripting languages just adding static typing. C++ is similar to the previous 2, just removing memory safety. What was so innovative about any of these languages? They are the same old imperative OO paradigm that first appeared in Simula and Ada back in the 80s.

Examples of languages that are innovative are Mozart/Oz, Haskell, Alice ML, Coq, Agda and Mercury. These completely redefine what it means to program, and all of them were created in the last 15-20 years. And if you think there haven't been great strides in each of these domains, then you're simply not familiar with them.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by llimllib on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:35PM (#2975082)
> There has been NOTHING as fundamentaly important as Knuth's work in the last couple of decades.

What work of Knuth's? TOACP? TeX? I'm a huge Knuth fan, but I don't see his work as fundamental to computer science, rather mostly as an amazing gatherer and editor of such work.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by wazoox on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:39PM (#2975569)
Read this and learn what Knuth did as his summer job in 1960 (he was 21 or 22):

http://ed-thelen.org/comp-hist/B5000-AlgolRWaychoff.html#7

here is the conclusion of the chapter:

"In 1961, the National ACM meeting was held in Los Angeles. The keynote speaker was Tom Watson, the Chairman of the Board Of IBM. Bob Barton was the second or third speaker after Watson. don and Lloyd and I were in the audience of approximately 1200 people. [...] "There are only three people in this room that really know how to write a compiler and I would like for them to stand up now. They are don knuth, Lloyd Turner and Richard Waychoff."

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by psykotic on Thursday September 08, 2011 @09:12PM (#2976353)
> I'm a huge Knuth fan, but I don't see his work as fundamental to computer science

You're talking about the guy who invented LR parsing.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pnathan on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:57PM (#2975171)
If I recall correctly, he invented rigorous algorithm analysis in the process of writing TAOCP.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by xyzzyz on Thursday September 08, 2011 @06:08PM (#2975869)
You might be interested in his resume:

http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~uno/vita.pdf

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by pointyhat on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:47PM (#2975135)
He formalised it which is the one thing everyone else had failed before. Plus don't forget things like KMP algo, METAFONT, TeX, literate programming etc.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by zobzu on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:11PM (#2976068)
plan9 singularity

both, similar in some concepts, just kills UNIX on the design stand point.

None of them are really used. Sad :( Eventually we will merge toward them tho, they're the future somehow. Not because they're "new" (compared to UNIX) but because they solve resource and security issues we have today. Also solves a lot of the complexity.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by MatthewPhillips on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:26PM (#2976111)
Unix survives because it's good enough. A successor doesn't have to beat it; it has to blow it away. [1]

http://www.faqs.org/docs/artu/plan9.html

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by apotheon on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:13PM (#2982856)
> There is plenty of innovation in the programming language space. There is too much.

No such thing. Innovation is a good thing, period. Perhaps what you find objectionable is the proliferation of stuff that people call "innovation", but really isn't very innovative.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by rabc on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:58PM (#2975175)
There is a lot of innovation in the programming language space, see what node.js is doing with javascript (I still remember the days when everyone let all the JS code to juniors programmers because no one liked JS).

Google should focus on fixing what's already done, not re-inventing the wheel again.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by fogus on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:20PM (#2975261)

    see what node.js is doing
Granted, Node.js is nice and all, but it's hardly innovative. It's built on an old language using ancient async tricks running on a VM built using old performance techniques learned during the development of an old language.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by hasenj on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:06PM (#2976055)
Putting a whole bunch of existing ideas together into a new form is what innovation is all about.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by sjwright on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:32PM (#2976124)
Putting a whole bunch of existing ideas together into a new form is what patent law is all about stifling.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by shortcharles on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:42PM (#2979543)
If your universe has a mere 400 old software ideas, and you choose 4 (e.g. JS, async, VM, hidden objects) your combination is one out of 1 050 739 900. That is the mathematics of innovation.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by munificent on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:00PM (#2975183)
> what node.js is doing with javascript

How is node.js innovating in the language space?

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by rabc on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:13PM (#2975224)
Giving a new way to work with it, making you rethink your async patterns.

node.js created a new world to work with JS, making it more powerful.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by jerf on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:50PM (#2975396)
It created a new world to work with in JS... by copying the async frameworks that already existed in numerous other languages. Innovative within Javascript, sure. Innovative, without further qualifications? Decades too late for that.
Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by munificent on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:04PM (#2975447)
> making you rethink your async patterns.

Call me crazy, but I don't consider forcing users to manually transform their code into hard-to-read continuation passing form much of a language innovation.

> node.js created a new world to work with JS, making it more powerful.

Sure, it gave it a new environment to run in, but it didn't make the language any more powerful than applets made Java the language more innovative.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by dasil003 on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:14PM (#2975699)
Node's primary innovation is in terms of A) unifying JS on a single high-performance platform and B) creating an ecosystem from the ground up where thread-safety is required at all times.

These innovations are significant, especially at the boots-on-the-ground level. That said, when people speak about lack of innovation in programming languages I think they are looking for more fundamentally new ideas. I don't want to be a cynic—all ideas are derivative after all—but I don't think Node qualifies.

Re:Google to announce "new programming language for structur... by yzhengyu on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:16PM (#2976084)
Hmm, I would reckon node.js is popular because of its inherent simplicity and tapping the greater javascript community, which is by far the most vibrant and energetic I have seen.

The things that it introduced - asynchronous, modelling as events, single thread execution - are not really new and already exist as libraries/frameworks [varying in increasing complexity] in Python, Java and Ruby.

Not that I am knocking node. If anything, its good more people are opening up to alternative, sometimes better, ways of modelling and execution.