Re:The gift of it's your problem now
by stavros on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:01PM
(#29742595)
That's not inherent to the word "obligation" any more than saying "I must do this, it is your right". It's fine as a concept, but saying "instead of talking about rights, we should talk about obligations" doesn't clarify anything, because my right is simultaneously your obligation.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The gift of it's your problem now
by lostcolony on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:48PM
(#29743046)
Right, but in so doing you're also switching the grammatical subject. The original statement assumes the same subject, moving from rights -> obligations implies a different meaning. I.e., when speaking of myself, "my rights" vs "my obligations" are very different things. Likewise when speaking of society, "our rights" vs "our obligations" also lead to a different dialog. The onus is on what we owe to others, rather than what we are owed, even though such a contract necessarily implies both.
That's exactly my point: Changing the word that's used doesn't matter, what matters is getting people to think of others instead of themselves.