News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by degenerate on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:30PM (#29727997)
In today's telecom world where everything is tracked and logged down to the microsecond, it's extremely angering that the only reason we still get robocalls is because the players in the telecom game are making a lot of money from letting them happen.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by mrjin on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @06:50PM (#29731654)
Nope, the problem is not what you thought of. The low level communication protocols did not consider security issues when they were designed as at which time every peer could be trusted, and thus no Authentication & Authorization mechanisms were incorporated at all. That was not really a problem until VoIP became a thing. Before VoIP it would be extremely hard if not totally impossible to fake a caller id, but with VoIP there is no longer a physical port associated with a caller, so technically everyone can claim to be anyone as long as they have the service end point details as there is no way to validate if you really are who you claim to be, so don't be surprised when picking up a call from your own number. Doesn't look good, isn't it? Unfortunately, there is no easy fix without an overhaul of the telecom infrastructure by replacing all legacy equipment that does not support A&A. I'm wondering if that is ever going to happen.

But you were right about one thing, telecoms do profit a lot from the robocalls.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by cogman10 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:11PM (#29732304)
Funnily, the FCC rules around porting numbers has lead to a lot of this problem.

Telephone numbers used to be handled pretty much like IPv4 addresses. A telecom would get a block of numbers and distribute those to their customers. It wasn't really possible for you to move your number from one carrier to the next.

The 2003 rule change around number porting forced a bunch of upgrades to telecoms to make it possible for any phone operator to send out a call for any number.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by inetknght on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @11:18PM (#29733549)
> The 2003 rule change around number porting forced a bunch of upgrades to telecoms to make it possible for any phone operator to send out a call for any number.

Are you trying to claim that's the reason that anyone can forge a number? Because I don't buy it. Just because you're forced to accept an inbound number doesn't mean you don't log where the number came from -- the peer service provider at the very least.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by EricE on Saturday January 01, 2022 @03:05PM (#29762114)
"Just because you're forced to accept an inbound number doesn't mean you don't log where the number came from -- the peer service provider at the very least."

And then what are you supposed to do with the peer service provider data? How the heck does that help an operator?

The whole point is VOIP and the porting rules broke the implicit trust relationships that used to exist, and the low level call routing protocols don't have a solution for that - because it could have never been a problem before VOIP and the new porting rules.

Until the underlying call routing protocols for long distance get enhanced, this problem isn't going to be fixed any time soon. And I'm not holding my breath on an overhaul of what is fast becoming legacy infrastructure. And in a VOIP only world establishing trust will be no easier, maybe harder, than doing so with email today - so that's not the answer either :p

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by adrr on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @11:54PM (#29733758)
Carriers know who originated the call. There are reciprocal compensation deals between the carriers to terminate call on their networks. They know exactly who originated the call because someone is paying for it. Calls aren’t free. Rural areas are especially pricey to terminate calls too which is how freeconference.com exists.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by EricE on Saturday January 01, 2022 @03:09PM (#29762158)
VOIP gateways upended that end to end accountability. I suppose the baby bells could just refuse all calls from VOIP gateways further relegating them to irrelevance. Good luck ever convincing a cell phone provider to do that.

Actually if phone providers would prefix calls from VOIP gateways with an asterix then I could set up a rule to just force all of those to voicemail by default. Would probably kill 90% of the bogus calls. Hell I'd pay an extra $5 a month for that feature.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by heartbeats on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:16PM (#29731887)
Can't you just impose chained liability?

If I get a robocall, my carrier owes me $100. They can then collect $100 from the peer they got it from, etc.

This will cause carriers to only peer with good carriers, not fly-by-night VoIP clown shows.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by tasty_freeze on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:40PM (#29732075)
OK, let's say your plan is put into effect.

I will set up a front company, and create thousands of phone customers that are hard to track back to me. Then I'll have my front company call all of my 1000 fake customers repeatedly. Those customers collect $100 each for every call from the phone carrier, and when the phone carrier tries to collect from the originator, poof, they don't exist anymore.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by cogman10 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:15PM (#29732336)
Better make sure your front company can't be traced back to yourself and those fake customers can't be traced back to you otherwise you've just committed wirefraud.

Very likely, if this $100 fine came into play, the first change telcoms would implement is verifying every single line in and out to make sure this exact situation can't happen. Will be cool to need a passport and birth certificate to get a new phone number.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by nine_k on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @10:11PM (#29733097)
Have you tried to get a new mobile phone number without a passport or other such ID in the US?

In many countries, it is impossible to get even a VoIP number without showing an ID, and in some (like Bulgaria) it should be a local ID.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by lstodd on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @10:59PM (#29733441)
As long as you don't try the most obvious approach, that is just buying the sim straight from one of the official operators, the thing is quite simple.

In Europe, esp eastern europe, like Bulgaria, there's a vast market of stolen phones, stolen or resold sims. You'll have to ditch them after several weeks of course. But it is not in any way impossible.

I'd guess it's the same in Americas.

It's been several years since I worked at an MVNO, so I can't say much about how do you get number capacity nowadays, but back then that was literally the least problem imaginable.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by supertrope on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:48PM (#29732149)
The carrier will soon require a security deposit or guarantor.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by GoblinSlayer on Thursday December 30, 2021 @04:58AM (#29735291)
A whitelist works well for me. Call centers here have big randomized pools of phone numbers, so blacklisting them is impractical, and sometimes I do expect a call from a call center.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by downWidOutaFite on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @11:47PM (#29733712)
VoIP wasn't worth the destruction of the highly reliable trusted voice network.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by dehrmann on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:22PM (#29732393)
> the players in the telecom game are making a lot of money from letting them happen

I don't think my cell carrier is making anything on the spam text I get. At this point, it's also a negligible cost to them.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by tenebrisalietum on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:58PM (#29728481)
Phones and snail mail have been supplanted by equivalent Internet services, and both are trying to stay alive/relevant by selling out to annoying commercial interests.

Telegrams gave way to phones, but it was never possible to spam someone with telegrams, and they had a cost per word.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by tdeck on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:34PM (#29729005)
If telcos want the phone to be relevant, this is the wrong way to go about it. Just 10 years ago I answered my phone when it rang, even with an unknown number. Does anybody do that anymore? It's become nearly unusable, for example, as a way for businesses to contact customers they have an actual relationship with because of all the spam.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by ryandrake on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:29PM (#29729589)
Imagine if nobody ever used or knew about traditional phones, and then someone came up with the "Phone app":

"Yea, so here is an app you will love! Install it, and it allows anyone, anywhere, anytime, to interrupt whatever you are doing on your device, background whatever app you are running, cause it to ring, buzz, and notify! Further, if you press the green button, it will allow that random person to start talking to you."

Even if it managed to get past either of the app stores' rules, who would install such an intrusive app?

Yet, every smartphone sold today has that exact annoying app pre-installed!

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by phkahler on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:31PM (#29730951)
Imagine if it also reliably indicated who was calling you and had super easy blocking capability.

Also, what if you could set time and day for availability - i.e. for work related numbers.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by lamontcg on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:56AM (#29734088)
Be nice if you didn't actually have a phone number and you exchanged cryptographic keys with someone touchlessly when you were in physical contact. Then you'd have two-way ID verification, and if a merchant abused that by leaking their key material (or if it leaked in a hack) you could revoke that key's permission.

A large weakness with existing communication systems (phone, e-mail, physical mail) is that its a pipe where anyone in the world can blast at you, often anonymously.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by DangitBobby on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:58AM (#29734092)
Yeah, why would anyone want an app like Facebook or Discord or Skype or Teams or Google Meet or Zoom or the littany of other apps that have some version of the functionality you just described?
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by charcircuit on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:53PM (#29729885)
Why would you frame it like that? It's all about how you market it.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by thewebcount on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:39PM (#29729067)
> It's become nearly unusable, for example, as a way for businesses to contact customers they have an actual relationship with because of all the spam.

On top of that the telcos are joining in on the fun. I am an AT&T cell phone subscriber and in the last month they’ve started robo-calling me non-stop to sign up for their ailing DirecTV service. Who in their right mind would subscribe to that with all the better streaming options available? But the worst part is that they technically aren’t breaking the rules themselves because we do have an existing business relationship (if you can call paying my bill on time and doing everything in my power not to otherwise interact with them a relationship).

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by jlarocco on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:11PM (#29730084)
I'm not 100% sure, but that may be a scam.

I recently got one of those, and I'm not an AT&T customer.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by BoogerDan on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:29PM (#29732439)
Supposedly, some of these are scams. But DirecTV admitted to hiring Telecel Marketing Solutions to place robocalls. There have been multiple class-action lawsuits against AT&T for such things.

It's bizarre that AT&T would sabotage the usefulness of their own customers' telephone service, but this is a bizarre world.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by monkpit on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:35PM (#29731008)
A scam or a dodgy 3rd party (or both?). DirecTV has a reseller program where anyone can become a “retailer”.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by thewebcount on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:28PM (#29732435)
OK, fair enough, but in my book it’s still on AT&T because they have to know this is going on. They must be getting complaints about it.

Oddly enough I remember DirecTV doing this ~20 years ago. It was the first time I was willing to pay for CallerID. DirecTV (or some representative that had that as their outgoing name) called me several hundred days in a row. I ended up making a game out of it, seeing how many times they’d call back if I never answered.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by GoblinSlayer on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:23AM (#29735465)
What. You mean AT&T being your carrier is the only relationship between AT&T and spam? And how many unanswered calls they made? Here spammers give up after 6 unanswered calls or so. Not sure why they give up though, but eventually it becomes quiet.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by tehjoker on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:53PM (#29729889)
I'd really like to be able to use my phone for real relationships with natural persons too even if they're not in my contact list.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by ktkoffroth on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:18PM (#29730823)
I recently questioned this when setting up my mother and grandfather with TV and internet for their new house. The internet TV provider either don't have, or charge so much extra for channels they consider "essential" (that's another issue) that it's not worth getting the service, as the price is equivalent or more to a satellite TV provider.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by monkpit on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:34PM (#29730986)
But you’re assuming that the ATT/DirectTV calls are legit and direct from HQ. DirecTV is resold through 3rd parties all the time, I am pretty sure these calls are from a 3rd party or even a scam.
Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:17PM (#29730144)
> Who in their right mind would subscribe to that with all the better streaming options available?

Large swaths of the US can't get usable broadband. These people use satellite TV services. Of course that market is already developed so growth requires pestering the people with better choices available.

Re:Report to Congress: Robocalls and Transmission of Mislead... by ridaj on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:21PM (#29730179)
US telcos know at best two things at this point: keep the network up and collect rent. They cannot solve complicated social problems like spam or internet security. They just don't have the skills or the willingness to invest. We will all continue to pay them if only for internet access, and for a good price too thanks to countless mergers leaving consumers with few choices, but they are otherwise transforming into dumber and dumber pipes at a pretty fast clip. There's more profit to be made for them being a dumb pipe while device and OS manufacturers pick up the security / spam slack for free (eg, how much is anyone actually willing to pay for spam filtering) because it lets them provide a trusted environment to sell apps and ads in.