News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by johnthedebs on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @01:41PM (#2970523)
The problem isn't the psychological effects of needing to constantly lower prices – this happens all the time in the tech industry, and everyone in that industry is doing just fine psychologically.

Rather, it has to do with the fact that constantly down-shifting prices cause people not to buy nearly as often as they would if prices were stable or slightly inflationary. As a result of that, the economy slows down (sometimes dramatically).

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by ajross on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @02:46PM (#2970832)
Exactly. In the bitcoin world, you make more money by not investing the money you have and instead holding onto it in the hopes that you'll be able eventually convert it to a stable currency in the future. That's a disaster. Who, for example, is going lend their precious bitcoins to a risky startup when they can just sit on them and watch them appreciate?
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by stevenwagner on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:14PM (#2971212)
Finance 101, its called hedging. You can invest in dollars, euros, bitcoins, google, gold, food or whatever. They all have relative leverage and are all investments. Purchasing bitcoins means to investing in a share of the bitcoin economy. Its a startup currency which has never happened before. The increase in trading value has created an enormous amount of funding for bitcoin startups.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by brown9-2 on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @07:07PM (#2971917)
But what about the people that want to use it as a currency, to buy things? If everyone views it as an investment, and not a vehicle for trade, it will fail as a currency / never take off as a currency.

A lot of this logic is circular - the value will continue to rise because people will keep investing because the value will keep rising, etc.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Amincd on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:54AM (#2972681)
People are not all going to hold on to it and not spend. Some people are going to feel that due to hoarding, it won't become a currency, and hence it's not a good investment, and will be more likely to spend.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by jonnathanson on Thursday September 08, 2011 @06:55AM (#2973360)
"...due to hoarding, it won't become a currency, and hence it's not a good investment..."

Not necessarily.

The prospect that it's not a currency is what makes it attractive to hoarders. Hoarders/investors don't want Bitcoin to be a viable currency; they want it to be an investment commodity. And that's the crucial problem with Bitcoin: its use as a currency, and its use as an investment, are fundamentally at odds with one another. At any given time, it makes sense to be either buying/selling (hoarding) or buying/spending (transacting); at no point in time does it make sense to be doing both.

Transactors essentially believe that the value of Bitcoins will converge around a stable mean, thereby facilitating the currency's use for transactions. Hoarders believe the opposite: that the value will either be totally volatile (with lots of peaks and valleys against which to speculate), or that it will steadily climb.

Finally, we should distinguish between "selling" and "spending." A hoarder who wants out of the market will not spend his hoard; he'll sell it. A transactor also buys and "sells" Bitcoins, but in his case, "selling" involves spending them on goods or services -- not converting them back to dollars. This is a subtle, but crucial distinction. Both users buy into the market, but they exit the market differently and with different outcomes. And both will only be able to exit the market if there's liquidity in the form of willing new buyers or willing acceptors of BTC in exchange for goods and services. Each of those two outlets has a different liquidity dynamic, too.

(Sorry for the tl;dr)

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Amincd on Thursday September 08, 2011 @06:55PM (#2976014)
"The prospect that it's not a currency is what makes it attractive to hoarders. Hoarders/investors don't want Bitcoin to be a viable currency; they want it to be an investment commodity. "

Bitcoin will not be a good investment unless it's a currency. It has no other uses besides as currency. It's not a precious metal with industrial or ornamental uses for example. It's an abstract piece of data that could be useful in trade.

" Both users buy into the market, but they exit the market differently and with different outcomes. And both will only be able to exit the market if there's liquidity in the form of willing new buyers or willing acceptors of BTC in exchange for goods and services. Each of those two outlets has a different liquidity dynamic, too."

An investor who believes bitcoins will drop in value has the option of selling it or trading it for a good/service. Both accomplish the goal of getting out of a depreciating asset.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by brown9-2 on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:05AM (#2973941)
Some people are going to feel that due to hoarding, it won't become a currency, and hence it's not a good investment, and will be more likely to spend.

But if I as an individual consumer feel that bitcoin won't become a currency, why would I even be converting my money into bitcoin in the first place?

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by scott_s on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:50PM (#2971377)
He's talking about the situation where you already have bitcoins. If their value is deflating fast enough, then the most sound "investment" is to just hold onto them.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by danielsoneg on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @02:35PM (#2970777)
The other big problem is that debt loads don't drop along with prices - which effectively makes them rise. Falling prices (which lead to falling wages) + stable debt loads make it far harder for debtors to pay off their debts, which puts even further drag on the economy.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by euroclydon on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:06PM (#2971451)
Wow, for all I've read about Austrian Economics, I've never heard that simple yet devastating argument.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by kragen on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:00AM (#2972798)
Adam Smith talks about this phenomenon in Chapter IV (The Origin and Use of Money) in The Wealth of Nations:

“By means of those operations [inflating the coinage], the princes and sovereign states which performed them were enabled, in appearance, to pay their debts and fulfil their engagements with a smaller quantity of silver than would otherwise have been requisite. It was indeed in appearance only; for their creditors were really defrauded of a part of what was due to them. All other debtors in the state were allowed the same privilege, and might pay with the same nominal sum of the new and debased coin whatever they had borrowed in the old. Such operations, therefore, have always proved favourable to the debtor, and ruinous to the creditor, and have sometimes produced a greater and more universal revolution in the fortunes of private persons, than could have been occasioned by a very great public calamity.”

It follows, of course, that deflating the currency is favorable to the creditor and ruinous to the debtor; although I can't find where Smith says that, I think he does. In a sense it's worse: the creditor's losses in inflation are limited to the amount she originally lent.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by michaeldhopkins on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:34PM (#2971560)
Just to be clear, it's an argument against fiat currency as deflationary and inflationary shocks occur in those systems. The effects of deflation and inflation over time are countered with market-set interest rates -- higher savings and loan rates in an inflationary period and low-to-negative rates in a deflationary period. Yes, in a deflationary economy a (for example) -5.00% interest rate might be fair and would happen were it allowed.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by caf on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @08:16PM (#2972083)
Why would you ever lend money at a negative interest rate? You can always get 0.00% with virtually no risk just by socking the money away in a secure location. This is the heart of the problem with deflation (and deflationary currencies like bitcoin) - there's a 0.00% floor on the time cost of money.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by michaeldhopkins on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:56PM (#2972300)
Yes, you are right of course. The interest rate could not rationally go down below zero, but there would still be demand for loans during the deflationary period, so there would be other compensation (like equity in a business) in exchange for the load so that the risk/return would be proportionate to the risk-free rate of holding cash.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by caf on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @11:57PM (#2972577)
There will certainly be demand for loans, but the supply and demand curves for loans may not intersect anymore, meaning that no loans are made (because given a deflation rate of 5%, a nominal interest rate of, say, 1.5% (only a very small premium over the minimum risk-free rate of 0.00%) is still a real interest rate of 6.5%, which may be more than many of the loan customers are willing to pay.

In other words, deflation makes financing any risky enterprise much harder, so only the mostly highly profitable projects succeed. This makes sense, because in a deflationary environment just holding a pile of cash is a profitable endeavour.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by TruthElixirX on Thursday September 08, 2011 @01:55AM (#2972787)
Austrians don't advocate for a deflationary currency, they advocate for competing currencies. Rothbard, one of the "pillars" of Austrian Economics, even stated that The Great Depression was due to deflation not inflation.

Lots of people that scratch the surface of Austrian Economics immediately start shouting the ills of inflation and such.

Most "hardcore" Austrians I know would like a currency that's supply grew with economic growth. Economy grows by x measure then so does the currency, to keep it stable.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by euroclydon on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:39AM (#2974058)
Thanks. I knew this was wrong as soon as it left my keyboard.

I guess the problem we're having is that the Fed's mandate is to keep unemployment low, not to expand the currency as the population expands.

I really don't understand how a currency supply is supposed to track growth, when one of the means of controlling currency expansion, the discount rate, can actually stimulate growth sometimes, right?

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by iradik on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:23AM (#2973095)
Yes, instead of taking on debt people would be incentivized to save money before spending it.

With inflation you get the reverse effect: people are incentivized to take on debt to spend.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by stevenwagner on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:35PM (#2971308)
I would not short gold or Apple either, the risk would be huge! So are you agreeing that bitcoins will become worth more then? So I shouldnt take a bitcoin loan out, I should take a dollar loan out and buy bitcoins with it. Or you are saying bitcoins are bad so they will go down in value ... and I should... whaaat?
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by msbarnett on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:51PM (#2971385)
He's saying that the characteristics of bitcoins make it a lousy currency (people have little incentive to spend or loan it).

Whether or not it's an asset worthy of investing in is a separate question. (I'd argue that it isn't, but that's a separate issue from the characteristics that make it a bad currency).

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by jarek on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @10:08PM (#2972328)
As an investment, it's like gold but without the intrinsic value part and the "historically used as an investment for the past couple of millenia" part.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by guelo on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:40AM (#2972655)
The intrinsic value of bitcoin is as an uncensorable way to transfer money, for example to donate to Wikileaks when Visa and Paypal won't let you. It becomes more valuable the more governments try to stop transactions. This is why I'm bullish on it.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by jarek on Thursday September 08, 2011 @08:07AM (#2973533)
Oh, uncensorable? You mean as long as the government permits both parties to be connected to the internet. When they block either of you, it's about as good as a hundred dollar bill.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by caf on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:01AM (#2972586)
The intrinsic value of gold is quite a bit less than its market value, though - it's very hard to separate that from the "historically desired" aspect.

If you want intrinsic value, you're probably better off investing in good quality rifles.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by jarek on Thursday September 08, 2011 @08:08AM (#2973535)
Well, of course. But bitcoin doesn't have even that.

Though I would suggest that you would have to time your entry into the quality rifle investment market well to avoid getting hit by a speculative markup caused by people's expectations of their future intrinsic value.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Amincd on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:56AM (#2972687)
But this contradicts itself. If it makes it a lousy currency, then people wouldn't expect its value to rise, and hence would have an incentive to spend it, hence it would be a good currency and its value would rise.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by DennisP on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @03:39PM (#2971053)
Rationally, people should wait as long as possible to buy tech because they'll get more later. Instead, they buy it at a furious rate. Why is that?
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by khafra on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:24PM (#2971263)
stevenwagner shows by example why this isn't so, but to spell it out: If you were buying a CPU as an investment like a share of a mutual fund, to buy, hold, and sell, you'd want to wait as long as possible. In fact, you'd never buy one; we pretty much always expect the price of a given CPU to go down in the future.

But if you're going to use it to generate value, you should buy it as soon as your expectation for the marginal value it will generate is greater than the price of the CPU.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by DennisP on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:57PM (#2972302)
That makes sense, but what I'm wondering is: why doesn't the same argument apply to all products in the presence of deflation?

It seems to me the real problem of deflation is that debts get harder to pay off, not that people put off their purchases. But the "deflationary spiral" of delayed purchases is what people keep talking about, and I haven't heard a good reason why the tech industry is uniquely exempt from that.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by sethg on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @11:53PM (#2972567)
Deflationary spirals happen when the average price of everything, economy-wide, is going down. It’s perfectly normal for some things in the economy to get cheaper while other things get more expensive. Consumer technology is conspicuous and the way it gets cheap is conspicuous, but it accounts for a small proportion of what the average American spends money on. (The average American spends a small proportion of his/her income on consumer electronics because they’re so cheap.)
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by DennisP on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:34AM (#2974036)
Sure, but why does that make the difference? Why doesn't that incentive work the same way when it's one class of products, as when it's all products?

Also, there are several periods in American history when we had modest deflation and a booming economy. The Roaring Twenties was one. How did that happen?

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by sethg on Thursday September 08, 2011 @01:20PM (#2974776)
Consider the effect on wages.

If computers get cheaper while the average consumer’s disposable income stays constant, then people will just buy fancier computers, or spend less on computers and use their savings to buy more of other things, or be grateful that the cheaper computers make up for rising prices in other things they want (e.g., health care).

If the average price of everything goes down, then the average consumer’s disposable income must eventually decrease; to make up for the lost income, employers will have to either cut wages or lay off workers.

PS: The Roaring Twenties were not always so roaring. There was a depression in 1920–21, and according to the helpful St. Louis Fed graphs, there were two other recessions between 1921 and 1929.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by DennisP on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:10PM (#2975686)
First explanation I've seen that makes some sense.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by stevenwagner on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:02PM (#2971165)
I know! The iPad is going to be so much cheaper in 10 years. Im waiting.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by aschoen on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @03:34PM (#2971041)
The total number of bitcoins in circulation is capped, even though the total quantity of wealth in the world continues to increase. If bitcoins were the only currency used, then yes, this would cause hoarding problems. Does this mean bitcoins are flawed? No. It just means that there is a cap on how much wealth can be purchased with bitcoins.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by stevenwagner on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:39PM (#2971325)
It is 21.00000000 million-- or 2.1 quadrillion of the smallest-possible-unit.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Raphael on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:10AM (#2972818)
So every person on earth only gets 300,000 of the smallest possible unit?
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by stevenwagner on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:51AM (#2973145)
With the current software yes. It could always be expanded if need though.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by aschoen on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:39PM (#2971321)
In other words, prices of goods (in bitcoins) will (eventually) stop deflating, even though there is a fixed quantity of bitcoins, because other cryptocurrencies will be introduced.