News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by rwmj on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:09AM (#29623502)
> CZ predicts 80% of people will accept crypto payments within five to ten years.

That's a very specific prediction. I'm going to predict that this will not happen. In fact if it's 1% I would be surprised. The reasons are that the systems simply couldn't support such a transaction rate, and it's far too volatile to be used a currency. (And anyway how many businesses accept gold as payment? Approximately none)

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by Comevius on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:31AM (#29623666)
So far no one really could use cryptocurrencies as currencies because of this, they remain an asset class, in truth a Ponzi scheme. Circumventing governments, banks and payment processors seems alluring until you realize that there is a reason for every single regulation. Once you learn all the lessons you are back to fiat money and centralized banking systems despite their imperfections.

It's like those hippies in that South Park episode.

Man 2: Right now we're proving we don't need corporations. We don't need money. This can become a commune where everyone just helps each other.

Man 1: Yeah, we'll have one guy who like, who like, makes bread. A-and one guy who like, l-looks out for other people's safety.

Stan: You mean like a baker and a cop?

Man 2: No no, can't you imagine a place where people live together and like, provide services for each other in exchange for their services?

Kyle: Yeah, it's called a town.

Driver: You kids just haven't been to college yet. But just you wait, this thing is about to get HUGE.

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by charbuff on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:24AM (#29623603)
Things have moved very quickly since this was true. For comparison, [1] Visa claims at it's maximum to achieve 24,000 transactions per second (tps), and Mastercard 5000. The work on the Bitcoin Lightning Network is moving ahead to help achieve [2] "approximately 1 million transactions per second."

Another crypto currency in use today is Solana. That runs at around 50,000 tps, beating the higher end of today's credit processing networks.

[1]: https://utilli.com/2021/04/26/the-lightning-network-is-poise... [2]: https://www.kraken.com/en-us/learn/lightning-network

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by moffkalast on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:49AM (#29623788)
Yeah though credit card processors don't have dusting attacks and smart contracts to deal with, so it probably balances out.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:14AM (#29623531)
One would assume that Visa (yes they already announced support of crypto) etc transactions would be off-chain, so network transaction rate isn't that important.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by croon on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:26AM (#29623615)
So it will be cryptocurrency in name only. We are truly living through a bubble of stupid money. I have no idea where it's headed but I hope anyone getting hurt can take it.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by nikanj on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:29AM (#29623648)
My shoeshine tells me it’s headed to the moon!
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:41AM (#29623733)
Nah, there is still the blockchain underneath, the only difference is that changes are synced later.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by croon on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:46AM (#29623770)
> the only difference is that changes are synced later.

Says who? You've just ignored the trustless part of cryptocurrency, what are you left with?

I get the hypothetical of why [cryptocurrency of choice] could be useful, even if I don't subscribe to the idea of a trustless society functioning.

But if you sidestep the one thing it's laboriously designed for (trustless by PoW, or stake/other), why even bother?

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:05AM (#29625042)
If changes are not synced later, Visa just paid for my lunch. Why not...

I don't have to sidestep it forever and ever since I buy lunch via VisaBTC. And me buying lunch changes nothing about me receiving funds.

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by croon on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:29AM (#29625274)
How is that different from just settling between banks? There's an end record of transactions with traditional banks already. You just trust the end result to be accurate.

The only selling point of bitcoin was that everything was recorded and immutable, and thus volume was transparent. If all of these transactions happen outside of the blockchain (until later, maybe) you can fudge around with trading volume, and game the market, which exchanges have already done.

You are literally just describing banking as it has existed forever, but with less oversight.

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:52AM (#29625515)
Nah, oversight is even better than before.

I am describing banking without the issues of banks. No need to have a headache because my transaction from Iran to EU is lost somewhere in between without any traceability whatsoever, etc; no need to have a headache because the receiver didn't realize it'll cost them $100 to receive money internationally, etc; no need to think about the hardship of pulling my own money out of the bank while I'm not in my home country, etc...

Then there's smart contracts - show me a bank that supports it? Show me groups of banks (because not everyone has the same, right?) that support it among each other?

> all of these transactions

Again, that's your mistake. That most transactions happen off-chain doesn't mean all or the important ones do. And it also doesn't mean there aren't cross off-chain network transactions - e.g. VisaBTC to MCBTC needs a blockchain to happen in a trustless way. Trust is easy when it's Visa to MC but not so easy when it's EU to Iran banking system.

> You just trust the end result to be accurate

Hahahaha, good luck in Africa...

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by croon on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:22AM (#29625873)
> Again, that's your mistake. That most transactions happen off-chain doesn't mean all or the important ones do. And it also doesn't mean there aren't cross off-chain network transactions - e.g. VisaBTC to MCBTC needs a blockchain to happen in a trustless way. Trust is easy when it's Visa to MC but not so easy when it's EU to Iran banking system

Doesn't matter if it's all, just that some can be. The issue is that the transaction ledger and the "currency" or asset is the same thing. That exchanges or Visa et al are implicitly trusted with out-of-blockchain transactions means that there's no longer a natural relationship with the finite number of BTC or the veracity of the blockchain. You have just started outsourcing trust again, which IMO is fine, but why the rodeo then.

Pick a lane, you can't have both. It's no longer trustless if you try to do both, at least not on the (speculated) asset value level.

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @12:09PM (#29627156)
No need to pick lanes, I have both today.

I am going to prefer on-chain BTC transactions to make international business transactions in thousands of USD.

I don't need the full force of trustlessness to buy my lunch - the risk to me is that I get a free lunch. Yeah I could use a classic payment card - but then I'd have to keep shuffling my funds around and that's not fun.

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by croon on Monday December 20, 2021 @04:33PM (#29630598)
> No need to pick lanes, I have both today.

No you don't. You have a speculative asset no longer bounded by the designed limit of BTCs, where banks, i mean exchanges, can create volume out of thin air outside of the ledger, as long as something is later cleared on-chain. Ergo, back to square one.

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by genewitch on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:27PM (#29628991)
In a single sentence that makes sense, what is a smart contract?
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @04:40PM (#29630678)
A program that defines what happens with the assets bound to it.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by ciupicri on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:22AM (#29623589)
Then they wouldn't be quite cryptocurrency transactions.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by emteycz on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:02AM (#29625627)
Did I pay with crypto? Did someone receive crypto? Then it's a crypto transaction.
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by charbuff on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:34AM (#29623677)
You'll be surprised to know that a cryptocurrency transaction is a record on a ledger of a transfer of some value. Whether it happens "off-chain" or not does not discount it being a crypto-currency transaction. What the poster above is referring to are "level 2" solutions, for example [1] the Lightning Network for Bitcoin. In short, the crypto is being transacted on one network, then that record is finalized along with others on the Bitcoin ledger.

[1]: https://cointelegraph.com/bitcoin-for-beginners/what-is-the-...

Re:The most powerful people in crypto by nathias on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:35AM (#29623690)
your reasons wouldn't even be true 10 years ago but today this is just willful ignorance
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by anonymoushn on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:49PM (#29629290)
You were sending 10k TPS of stablecoin transfers on a public blockchain in 2011?
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by nathias on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:43PM (#29631432)
no, there were other soultions to volatility
Re:The most powerful people in crypto by anonymoushn on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:48PM (#29629269)
We have public blockchains deployed today that can do tens of thousands of transactions per second, and those transactions can be for tokenized fiat currency.