Re:Against 3x Speed
by sschueller on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:22AM
(#29622266)
I would prefer a plugin that could remove "ehm"s and pauses from speakers that are new to the game.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If only this wasn't necessary - a lot of online stuff has had a single 'take' done and minimal editing out of such time-wasting utterances or silences. And once you start to notice such characteristics in some poor speakers it can be a complete deal-breaker in terms of actually learning something.
Re:Against 3x Speed
by dredmorbius on Monday December 20, 2021 @03:21AM
(#29622513)
I have quite literally gone through long lectures and edited out such filler words (Audacity is good for this), where the material is sufficiently compelling (an extreme rarity).
It's really a telling level of contempt for an audience to allow unedited material containing excessive fillers to be released. I'm not at all a fan of the "one take, FI/SI" school of podcasts, and will bail out of virtually anything that features this.
For vapid voiceovers, I'll often just watch the video with sound off. My response is similar to how Douglas Adams described Marvin the Android hearing people count.
Not sure how well it removes "ehm"s, but I use unsilence[1] a lot for lectures. It removes the silent bits from a video file. It isn't a browser plugin however. You have to download the lecture before converting.
It works quite well in my experience.
I believe that’s what Overcast “Smart speed” does for podcasts. Would be nice to have for videos.
Pocketcast can remove silence at least. Not sure about filler sounds like ehm.
According to Pocketcast I've "saved" over 3 days by trimming silence and over a month by speeding up. I've listened to a lot of podcasts it seems ...