Maybe this is the first step into getting our society to quit pretending we’re a generation away from human brains being irrelevant. If so I say that’s a good thing, there’s enough doomsaying about the world without trying to write off building cool technology as another apocalyptic fall into dystopia we’re on the verge of.
Henrietta's immortal cancer cells were necessary in a large number of modern medicines, including the testing of the mRNA vaccines (one of the cheapest ways to test for human compatibility is to use isolated human cells for tests).
I don't see the brain as any more special of an organ than Henrietta's cells.
I wouldn't call it a dystopian future: this is much preferred over say, Nazi experiments. But we as a society should strive for better ethics. Maybe not necessarily banning Henrietta cells, but maybe at least paying her family a bit more of the royalties?
HeLa cells are really, really important test subjects after all.
------
The real world certainly has different moral questions. Fiction can be used to think about imaginary problems and maybe even provide the discussion material for some real world examples.
But we must always ground ourselves back in reality as we make arguments. Lest we become like Don Quixote. (See what I did there? Lol)
Obviously it wouldn’t be this simple (probably) as the conscience depends on the body and it’s motor functions and outputs as a part of its subconscious. You’d replace those with whatever the wires were connected to and hope you were talking to the brain the way you thought. But assuming we could hand wave that it sounds like an ethical debate that could both be had at some point and allow me to sit out of.
Then again when I tried college ethics is the one class I dropped. I like to build things and be able to base them on things it’s possible to infer. Ill leave the ultra nuanced philosophy of what people should do in situations when there are no true answers up to better people than me.
that's a very impactful scene, but honestly there are moral/ethical red flags about many of the main characters from the very first episode.
And honestly, her flirting was mostly just trolling / fun. So I don't think anyone suspected the horrors of her designs until this scene.
An advanced AI named "The Three Magi" (which are 3-programs which vote for strategic effects) exists in the show. Without going too much into details, a problem occurs in the AI, so the lead scientist Ritsuko steps into the machine to check things out.
She comes with a circular saw. She cuts open one computer (the one named "Caspar") ... revealing to the audience that inside is a living brain, hooked up to a bunch of wires: https://imgur.com/MTZ7pzU
This is the first point where the audience probably starts to wonder about the ethics of the main characters. The later reveals of their bio-engineering / morals are more horrifying. But this is perhaps the audience's first look into the inner-workings of the NERV organization / science that they do.