News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by dcow on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:04AM (#29611506)
That’s not a threat. A threat would be, “I’ll sue you if you don’t comply with my request”.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by MR4D on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:23AM (#29611593)
You’ve clearly never dealt with lawyers very much. The implied threat is pretty obvious to those that have.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by tiahura on Sunday December 19, 2021 @02:21AM (#29612099)
Lawyers don’t imply potential litigation, they are quite explicit.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by MR4D on Sunday December 19, 2021 @09:09AM (#29614060)
It depends on what they are doing. A lawsuit is explicit, as is a contract. But a Cease & Desist may or may not be explicit.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by tiahura on Sunday December 19, 2021 @11:11AM (#29615002)
Then they’re not very good cease and desist letters. A C&D should state exactly what you are asking them to stop doing and exactly what will happen if they don’t. That way the other party can’t claim they didn’t understand later.

Search C&D samples on google and see for yourself.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by MR4D on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:57PM (#29619418)
You mean like this?

“Your failure to abide by your Agreements will result in [redacted] pursuing any and all available remedies, including but not limited to injunctive relief and monetary damages.”

So, I don’t consider this very specific (you may, and that’s fine but then our disagreement is about something different).

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by tiahura on Sunday December 19, 2021 @07:38PM (#29620273)
Yes, language like that. Put it this way, a cease and desist should contain an IF THEN. If you don’t stop copying my CD then I will sue you for injunctive relief and monetary damages.

Contrast that to the subject email. There’s no if you don’t respond then I will sue you. It’s not a threat, it’s a request and the requestor’s reference to a statute that they think might apply.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by watwut on Sunday December 19, 2021 @02:38AM (#29612163)
No, not in first contact fish for mistake email.
[dead]
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by MR4D on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:50AM (#29611721)
I’ve been on the internet since before Al Gore invented it. I’ve seen more crappy stuff from lawyers all the time. Remember, in the US, you do not need a reason to sue someone. A friend just got sued by a guy who tried to by his house for some BS reason. Trust me, stupid stuff happens.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by Godel_unicode on Sunday December 19, 2021 @01:22AM (#29611886)
Bet he heard about that by some method other than email ;)
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by MR4D on Sunday December 19, 2021 @09:08AM (#29614044)
Ha! Good point. But then his was an actual suit, not a threat.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by rectang on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:11AM (#29611539)
Interesting. Do you or any of your associates send these sorts of notices to anyone?
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by throawayblahads on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:24AM (#29611601)
EDIT: Some grammar, and minor clause clarification in second-to-last paragraph.

Yes, frequently. And throwaway.

About once a week, I pick an account in my LastPass collection, and initiate the following process:

1. Initiate a CCPA data request using a form or email, and I always include language about the timeline. I am not a lawyer, I'm just a person.

2. Then, once I have the data, I delete the account. I'm trying to purge my web presence before I move out of California. I have about 200 accounts left, and have done this with 50.

Admittedly, these are all large businesses, so far. Think Google, where I've worked myself, so I know they are equipped to handle it. But, I will be working my way down to small businesses eventually, and I am surprised to find out that simply quoting the statute (which is what I do) is considered anything but vaguely legally threatening. If the website doesn't fall under CCPA, or hell, if it does, I just expect it to be ignored. I mean no ill will.

I'm personally pretty conflicted, since I actually fully agree with this [1] about the study being unethical, but if I send an email as an individual to a website with my data, quoting a California law, that doesn't seem wrong to me, even if it causes $10k in legal costs, since my request is truly genuine and not intended to cause harm.

I would agree that there is a distinction at the study level, but I'm not exactly sure why.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29599553#29601020

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by seanhunter on Sunday December 19, 2021 @01:21AM (#29611884)
The distinction is super clear to me. You as an individual are exercising genuine data subject access rights granted to you by law. They are a researcher prentending to be a data subject exercising rights in order to gather data for their study.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by eigenvalue on Sunday December 19, 2021 @02:25AM (#29612112)
Even if what you are doing is "legal" it seems abusive as hell to me, especially if it is ever targeted at a smaller company or person like in the OP's case. Why are being so difficult? Why don't you find something more useful to do with your time instead of making others jump through idiotic hoops out of some misplaced sense of justice?
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by weeks on Sunday December 19, 2021 @03:52AM (#29612436)
“Buy, receive, or sell the personal information of 50,000 or more California residents”

If a business engages this type of activity, they need to have a scalable process for providing California residents with their data.

Describing a California law passed by a majority of voters as “idiotic hoops” is a miss.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by throawayblahad2 on Sunday December 19, 2021 @09:07AM (#29614042)
EDIT: Spelling, formatting,

(Same person, another throwaway, my bad.)

I imagine that for some companies it is difficult, and to the extent that I feel a 'sense of justice' about it, I would hope that my efforts help the organization (or single person, acknowledging that) set up a process to handle this.

I'm *genuinely* not trying to be abusive though. It's *extremely important* that consumers have the ability to exercise their data and privacy rights.

I'm not that old (mid 30s), but genuinely much of the data I have on the internet was put there when I was an actual child. And it's still there. This is actually one of the first times I've posted in *years* online. I really want to delete *almost everything*. Note in my OP, I said I worked at Google. I quit, because although I actually think ad targeting and the surveillance network are actually okay-ish, I wanted to opt-out myself, on both ends. So far, this decision has cost me 250k USD personally (if I calculate out the opportunity cost since I quit, just so far). And for the websites/apps I do still use, I donate some amount of money per year. OK, maybe I'm a freak, I really do think this stuff is important.

What would you suggest I do? Leave all my data online? As I said, in my cases, I was an actual child (those COPPA things did nothing to stop me), and this is, so far, a really effective way at getting places to delete my data. Maybe it's because they're "scared" of the law, but you know, then the law is working. Before, nobody responded to my deletion requests, and many websites had no option to delete. As a libertarian-ish person, this is a clear win for the consumer in terms of "coercive power of the state being used to create a framework that increases net freedom".

I am open to being wrong though! Let me delete all of my data first though so I don't have to do this again.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by charcircuit on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:21AM (#29611585)
Yes, I have had friends jokingly say they would request the information I have on them because of GDPR.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by progman32 on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:32AM (#29611635)
Responding to throwaway, I think the critical difference here is that you're making the requests in good faith. The researcher was making these (could be interpreted as vague) requests deceptively.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by throawayblahads on Sunday December 19, 2021 @12:38AM (#29611660)
Yeah, I think that's right. But it does raise an interesting point. The meta-point of the study was a good one, I think, which is to "study privacy on the internet".

I'm soooo behind that (one reason I am disappointed in the ethical lapses here)—I've often considered publishing the steps I take for each website on a substack or whatever, to help other people. Sometimes, it can be hard to figure out (1) if your data can be requested-to-be-deleted, and (2) how to even do it.

Clearly, the deception was bad; I guess, just thinking out loud, how could this study have been done ethically? Perhaps, sign up real people to request the data, and transparently include a notice that this was part of a study?

The last bit is the tricky one; including that might skew the results in favor of websites being compliant.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by dcow on Sunday December 19, 2021 @01:21AM (#29611877)
If I understand correctly the sentiment is that the study is not in “good faith” by virtue of being a study. That’s where I’m genuinely ethically confused. It’s not like the study is bad faith (like they’re trying to trick websites into something illegal then sue them). At worst it’s neutral faith. But why is that unethical?