As for nat being a cludge, lets assume I have a simple small office network with two independent ISPs. Normally I want to send half my users out of ISP1 and half out of ISP2.
If ISP2 fails, I want to send them all out of ISP1, OK there's less bandwidth to go round, but better than having no bandwidth for half my users.
How do I do that with ipv6 without natting (assuming I'm not large enough to be running my own AS and peering with two different providers)
I don't have easy access to multiple V6-PD enabled providers to test this theory, and as someone with quite the neck beard I really don't know how I feel about ceeding this level of control to endpoints. But also, I'm not sure I hate it either.
Oh and don't forget link-local and a ula prefix for your local addressing requirements for pinters and whatnot that shouldn't be using dynamic discovery.
That basically doesn't work with real clients. They'll do dumb stuff like use address from provider A to send through the router advertising addresses from provider B. And take forever to do anything in response to prefixes that are advertised as no longer usable or simply no longer advertised.
V6 devices are expected to understand that and do the right thing, but Windows (10) doesn't, Linux was worse, and I don't remember what Android did and I didn't get around to testing FreeBSD, and that's all the OSes I have.
If you've got experience otherwise, I'd love to know, one of these days I need to setup IPv6 again, but what I'd really like to do is too much work, so I'm IPv4 only for the foreseeable future.
IPv6 works best when all addresses are globally routable (whether firewalled off or not). We're all so used to RFC1918 that we forget it was an ugly kludge that fundamentally broke how the internet was meant to work. IPv6 is the fix for that breakage: the address of every individual device can actually mean the same thing everywhere on the internet, as it was meant to be. L3 routing can be stateless again.
The primary intent of IPv6 is to replace IPv4, not coexist with it. Coexistence is transitory and not worth optimizing for over the future of the internet when V4 is dead.