Re:Enhanced IP: IPv4 with 64 Bit Addresses (2012) [pdf]
by toast0 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:22PM
(#29595212)
2012 wasn't a bad time to discuss alternate options. Now is maybe a little late, but that's arguable.
There's a whole generation of people and experience that wasn't able to enter the discussions in 1993 and is available now. Maybe new eyes or experienced eyes would have a better solution.
The problem is clearer now than then. IPv6 makes many changes to address many problems, but maybe only address space is a real problem, because only address space seems to be motivating people to join IPv6.
Of course, the downside is not a lot of people want to be on three parallel networks, it's a lot of work. But perhaps, if that third network were more desirable and easier to implement, it could get larger coverage in a shorter amount of time than IPv6. Sort of like how TLS 1.1 never had more users than TLS 1.0, but TLS 1.2 overtook them both.
You would need real consensus and commitment from lastmile ISPs, backbone ISPs, networking vendors, OS vendors, CPE vendors, mobile networks, content providers, etc, though and that's tough. The consensus on IPv6 seems to be clearly, we'll do it eventually, when we really have to (which for some networks was 2012, and some networks is now, and some networks seems to be never)
There's a whole generation of people and experience that wasn't able to enter the discussions in 1993 and is available now. Maybe new eyes or experienced eyes would have a better solution.
The problem is clearer now than then. IPv6 makes many changes to address many problems, but maybe only address space is a real problem, because only address space seems to be motivating people to join IPv6.
Of course, the downside is not a lot of people want to be on three parallel networks, it's a lot of work. But perhaps, if that third network were more desirable and easier to implement, it could get larger coverage in a shorter amount of time than IPv6. Sort of like how TLS 1.1 never had more users than TLS 1.0, but TLS 1.2 overtook them both.
You would need real consensus and commitment from lastmile ISPs, backbone ISPs, networking vendors, OS vendors, CPE vendors, mobile networks, content providers, etc, though and that's tough. The consensus on IPv6 seems to be clearly, we'll do it eventually, when we really have to (which for some networks was 2012, and some networks is now, and some networks seems to be never)