News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by patrickod on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:34PM (#2956415)
What legal issues are there with the Apple employees and not the plainclothes police officers carrying out this search ? Are Apple in the clear here seeing as Calderon agreed to the search ?
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by sophacles on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:43PM (#2956424)
Well if they mis-identified themselves as police, that in itself is a crime, whether or not he agreed. Further, if anyone in the DA's office actually cared[1], there would be a decent case for criminal trespass since the guy did not let in Apple employees, but police officers in his mind... further a creative DA could probably even try for fraud if anything was damaged or property was lost since it was under false pretenses.

[1] Nothing will come of this... gotta protect the nice big corporations even if they occasionally get it wrong. That guy was surely a common fellow, pure worthless evil most likely, otherwise Apple would not have suspected him. This is good enough for any DA to ignore the law that might otherwise protect that common trash.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by sixtofour on Saturday September 03, 2011 @01:02AM (#2956540)
Exactly, nothing. It's a company town.

Consider that the actual police were there at all. They probably didn't each go on their own initiative. Apple's guy called an SFPD guy, who arranged for the officers to go along. So someone in the SFPD hierarchy was in on it.

No one in the SFPD is going to testify, or state during an investigation, that the Apple corporate police said anything that would lead the victim to believe that Apple's people were real police. Even though that was the whole point of the officers to be along, so the words "San Francisco Police" could be spoken, with all implications that come along with that.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by 0x0x0x on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:37PM (#2956417)
Yes, I would think so. Anyone basically has any right to anything you allow.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by pyre on Saturday September 03, 2011 @01:08AM (#2956548)
But this is aggravated by the SFPD's presence. Sounds like things went down like:

1) A group of people show up at his door in plain clothes.

2) Some of them identify as police officers.

3) They ask him about the iPhone 5 and he denies it.

4) They threaten him a bit and then ask him to allow a search of the premises.

5) Since, from his perspective, there are a bunch of police officers threatening the immigration status of his family, he consents.

6) Two people from the group (Apple employees) enter the premises and search for the iPhone. He assumes that they are police because they are all in plain clothes (no way to tell them apart without asking to each each badge).

Seems to me like the police used their muscle to strong-arm the guy, but then stopped short of doing the search themselves (because that would be illegal). Since the guy consented to the search, then there may not be anything illegal about the Apple employees performing the search.

This whole thing stinks:

* Sounds like the ex-police security guy that Apple hired got some of his buddies to use their badges to get him in the door.

* The police performed a search without technically performing a search.

* The Apple security employees impersonated police officers without technically impersonating police officers.

My take:

A bunch of police officers (and an ex-cop) were behaving badly on their off-hours and now the SFPD is going to go into CYA-mode. No charges will be brought. Nothing will happen to anyone. Maybe the Apple security guy will get dressed-down by his superiors for being so heavy-handed and causing bad press.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by ScottBurson on Saturday September 03, 2011 @01:53AM (#2956615)
Agreed, it stinks. But I think the real responsibility here lies with the SFPD officers, who deliberately conveyed the false impression that everyone in the group were police. I don't know if there's a law on the books against a police officer representing another person as a police officer, but if not, there damned well should be.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by RexRollman on Saturday September 03, 2011 @08:25AM (#2957138)
You're right. The cops knew what they were doing was wrong or else they would have entered the home as well.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by username123 on Sunday September 04, 2011 @08:24AM (#2959287)
My take:

KNOW your rights. Nothing stinks here. As one of the videos below states: If police is entitled to a search then they will just break in and do a search. If they ASK for consent, and even more, if they threaten, they KNOW that they are not entitled.

Keep the door shut and don't given up your rights.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDJrQBwJpqk

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XtBvalUVKU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7RYH8Py6lY

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_ckcdtQ95w

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by pyre on Sunday September 04, 2011 @01:45PM (#2959875)
That's all nice and dandy in a vaccuum, but it discounts the real world where the police will make threats to get what they want. You're argument is like claiming that an RIAA case has no legs to stand on... It sounds nice until you're the one that has to spend a fortune on lawyers to prove that.

Also, you're telling me that /nothing/ here stinks?

How about:

- This was likly an 'off the books' operation until it hit the media. This is why the SFPD spokesperson thought that no police were present.

- This was likely a bunch of officers using their badges to help a friend in their off hours. Now the SFPD is probably feverishly writing up paperwork to make this look legit to cover for the cops in question.

- The cops in question committed what amounts to fraud by implying that the Apple employees were cops.

Don't point out that the guy didn't know his rights and act like that is the only thing wrong with this picture.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by tensigh on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:10AM (#2973184)
No, it's simple "Do you have a warrant?" If the answer is anything other than "yes, here it is." you shut the door.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by shabble on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:22AM (#2956477)
Going completely off topic, there are, at least in some places, irrevocable rights which cannot be overruled by consent. In the UK, R v Brown[1] "ruled that consent was not a valid legal defence for wounding and actual bodily harm".

I believe there is also law (again, varying by jurisdiction and treaty obligations) to prevent a person from consenting to their own slavery. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Indentured_se... seems to cover it briefly, but I can't find a better reference immediately.

[1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Operation_Spa...

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by 0x0x0x on Saturday September 03, 2011 @01:19AM (#2956562)
Sigh. I emphasized "basically" precisely to avoid this discussion.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by dfc on Saturday September 03, 2011 @02:59AM (#2956719)
Basically? Saying basically just avoids any real discussion of legal distinctions.

When you said "basically" did you also mean to prevent discussion of duress? False pretenses? Fraud?

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday September 03, 2011 @05:15AM (#2956941)
Oh come off it, calm down a bit.

He said basically IMO because he meant "of the subset of actions against your person or property that you can legally consent to the further subset of those you have freely consented to are those actions that you can not properly object to being performed".

It's an internet forum not rendition of statute.

He can't say anything that "prevent"s proper discussion on an open internet forum. If you wanted to discuss informed consent, duress or fraud why not just do that.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by 0x0x0x on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:09PM (#2957513)
Thanks. That's exactly what my use of "basically" meant and FFS since this is HN I will be sure to note that in the future. :)
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by burgerbrain on Saturday September 03, 2011 @10:22AM (#2957317)
If he wants to make a comment discussing giving away your rights, he should damn well be prepared to discuss it's legality.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by 0x0x0x on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:06PM (#2957503)
Oh please. Use a little common sense next time you post. Anyone who attends, what sixth grade, knows there are some rights you can't give up and my comment was merely an attempt to avoid some tired lengthy discussion of that.

From what we know the "suspect" consented to a search of his apartment. That's the end of at least this part of the story.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by burgerbrain on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:30PM (#2957555)
The general population barely knows what rights they have, let alone what rights they cannot give up. It is an important aspect of the conversation.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by dfc on Saturday September 03, 2011 @11:32AM (#2957421)
I'm not sure I understand what you meant by:

"of the subset of actions against your person or property that you can legally consent to the further subset of those you have freely consented to are those actions that you can not properly object to being performed".

I do not understand the "consent to the further subset..." Part. Its not a sentence construction I am familiar with.

Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:50PM (#2957586)
Sorry that would be my legal training. Perhaps you can attempt to construe the sentence in the spirit it was written (like with badly drafted law ;0), you sound like you're intelligent enough to do that. Commas aren't free you know ...
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by dfc on Saturday September 03, 2011 @07:46PM (#2958410)
No worries. I was not trying to be a jerk, I really did not understand how the two parts of the sentences worked together.
Re:Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday September 04, 2011 @04:25AM (#2959065)
>"of the subset of actions against your person or property that you can legally consent to, the further subset of those you have freely consented to are those actions that you can not properly object to being performed" //

http://imgur.com/AK6Cu