News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by LeoPanthera on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:01PM (#29561551)
Maybe this is an obvious answer, and therefore not one you're interested in, but there's Siri.

Although audio is sent to the cloud, you can choose whether it is stored or not, and whatever you pick, Apple's privacy policy is very strict.

HomePods are mostly advertised as music playback devices, but I mostly use mine as a HomeKit control device.

Homebridge allows you to control non-HomeKit devices via Siri: https://homebridge.io

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by colordrops on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:59PM (#29561925)
This is a terrible suggestion. "Taking Apple's word on it" is not a valid privacy strategy. Companies have shown time and again that they lie about what is happening behind the scenes, or even just change their policies for the worst. Then there are rogue employees, such as the Ubiquiti fiasco, and secret government data collection, such as PRISM, of which Apple was a participant.

Apple has broken trust multiple times, including the FBI back door, and the CSAM fiasco. They are a public company beholden to shareholders, not your trusted friend from college. Even China has strong leverage over them due to their manufacturing and market there. They are fundamentally no different from Amazon.

The poster is asking for a private solution this is emphatically not it.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by LeoPanthera on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:20PM (#29562055)
> "Taking Apple's word on it" is not a valid privacy strategy.

I respectfully disagree.

If Apple says "we don't do X", and then is shown to do X, that would be a massive PR disaster.

Whereas Amazon makes no privacy promises at all. In fact, they promise the opposite.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by cglong on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:19AM (#29562981)
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:32AM (#29563369)
This was changed as far as I know. Do you have evidence otherwise?
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by krono on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:50AM (#29566669)
Claiming that whatever has not been proven false must be true is the exact opposite of how it works.

We have evidence and even admittance of abuse / improper handling in the past, but I'm unable to find any evidence that things have changed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Thursday December 16, 2021 @03:48AM (#29576337)
It seems like it was changed.

https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2019/08/28/apple-apologizes-for-lis...

I was just asking a question, I wasn’t attempting some sort of gotcha. I really don’t care that much.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by smoldesu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:10PM (#29568728)
Do you have evidence that they changed it?
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Thursday December 16, 2021 @03:49AM (#29576340)
https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2019/08/28/apple-apologizes-for-lis...

This. Is there any reason I should think this is not accurate?

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by kornhole on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:41PM (#29562181)
Granted that Amazon doesn't pretend too much to not be spying on you. Carefully read Apple's policies and statements to see where they give themselves plenty of wiggle room. Unfortunately most consumers' knowledge is no match for their PR and legal team's. Apple markets their products on privacy, but countless studies and analysis finds this to be a lot of theater.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:31AM (#29563365)
What’s the strongest evidence you have that proves this?
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by ummonk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:12PM (#29562005)
Unless you design your own hardware and build your own fab to manufacture it, you're always taking the word of at least one company.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by colordrops on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:43AM (#29562844)
This is like saying that you might as well be an alcoholic since you smoke cigarettes.

That's why you use VLANs on your home network and open source operating systems on your phone and computers. It reduces attack surface area. It's on your property and you can analyze where data is being sent.

With cloud services, you have no idea what's going on with the data once it is on someone else's servers.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by novok on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:38AM (#29562487)
Yeah the same logic applies to any network connected device you buy that has microphones on them.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by theshrike79 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:20AM (#29562990)
"The CSAM fiasco" was just geeks on the internet being geeks on the internet. And some really bad marketing on Apple's part.

The feature itself was perfectly fine, very few people even bothered to read up on it and focused on "OMG APPLE IS SCANNING MY PHOTOS!" without any nuance.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by Rastonbury on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:28AM (#29563729)
No it was because there were fears that oppressive regimes would pressure apple to scan and flag anti-government images.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:39AM (#29563413)
Yeah, they absolutely were not scanning photos and anyone with basic knowledge of how hashing works should know that. I was really disappointed with some of the reactions a saw coming from this community, which totally lacked any nuance or acknowledgment of how serious the issue of child abuse is.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by ericd on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:58AM (#29564760)
How is running a detection algorithm on one’s photos not “scanning” them?
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Thursday December 16, 2021 @03:42AM (#29576302)
It’s a bit of a stretch to say generating a hash from a file is scanning. Most computer science terms like this are metaphors, but when I create a scan with a ‘scanner’ I can create an exact copy of what was scanned.

Since creating a hash from a file is a one way process that you cannot reproduce the original file from the hash output, I would not call this a scan. All you can do is match to known child porn files.

But yes, go ahead, make more pedantic excuses on why we should protect people that hold child porn.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by ericd on Thursday December 16, 2021 @09:47AM (#29578643)
It’s not the creation of the hash of a single file that’s the “scanning” here, the scanning is the act of doing that to all of your files and looking for a match. Scanning is just looking over something for something specific. Scanning a hard drive isn’t copying it, nor is scanning the horizon. In the case of a scanner, I suppose it’s probably called that because it moves over a page with a bright light and camera to find the dark bits.

There are types of hashes that aren’t for finding exact matches. My thesis in school way back when was building something for image near-duplicate detection using a sort of hash made out of the image features detected. The output of a neural net run on an image is also a sort of hash in a (maybe) semantically meaningful vector space. And then you can look for similar or nearby vectors. This isn’t just useful for finding one type of image.

So, in case you didn’t realize, and you’re actually arguing in good faith, no one is arguing against this because they want to defend sex offenders, so you can leave that out in the future, unless you want to seem disingenuous. It’s because it makes it easy to create a population-wide dragnet for other things. It’s not hard to apply something similar to find photos taken at a protest, for example. Or pictures of a specific person you happened to meet.

Anyway, have a good one.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Thursday December 16, 2021 @11:02AM (#29579547)
> There are types of hashes that aren’t for finding exact matches. My thesis in school way back when was building something for image near-duplicate detection using a sort of hash made out of the image features detected. The output of a neural net run on an image is also a sort of hash in a (maybe) semantically meaningful vector space. And then you can look for similar or nearby vectors. This isn’t just useful for finding one type of image.

What's the point you're trying to get at here. I think it's well understood that there can be false positives -- but can you tell me at what rate of false positives it makes this type of child abuse detection unjustified? Also can you tell me what rate Apples system would cause a false positive. If for every one billion people(hypothetically of course) that are caught with child abuse images, one innocent person is asked to unlock their phone to prove that it's a false positive to a court, I think that's a fine trade off to make. I understand it's unpleasant for that one person, but I don't think you're correctly weighing the suffering to children this could help stop.

> It’s because it makes it easy to create a population-wide dragnet for other things. It’s not hard to apply something similar to find photos taken at a protest, for example.

This is in my opinion where thinking of people on your side is wrong and fundamentally dealing with these hard and nuanced issues on the wrong conceptual level. If the government wants to create a population-wide dragnet there are a lot of other ways to also do that. If for example an iPhone was a literal perfect privacy machine it would simply be forbidden from being sold in totalitarian countries that wanted that type of dragnet.

The thing that you're fundamentally missing the point on, in my opinion, is that the thing that protects me is not the technology, it's that I live in a democratic country that has laws to stop such thing as being prosecuted for just attending a protest. The police can listen to my phone calls and read my mail _right now_ but what keeps that kind of thing from being used against me in an unfair way are the courts. Fundamentally I don't think any technological solution can save any of us if we live under a totalitarian government.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by smoldesu on Thursday December 16, 2021 @08:02PM (#29586330)
Boy, there's a number of misconceptions here. I was considering not responding, but you're so wrong here that I just can't walk away and let you continue to spread this kind of blatantly wrong handwaving.

> If for every one billion people(hypothetically of course) that are caught with child abuse images, one innocent person is asked to unlock their phone to prove that it's a false positive to a court, I think that's a fine trade off to make.

How do you know the false positive rate yet? Not only has Apple not implemented it yet, but people have shown that

a. NeuralHash can correlate two completely unrelated, undoctored images

b. Hash collisions are be manually designed with minimal effort and changes to the source image

You're pulling this hypothetical figure out of thin air, it may as well be one in a hundred or one in a trillion.

> I don't think you're correctly weighing the suffering to children this could help stop.

That's not the problem here. If people want to continue to store photos of child exploitation on their iPhone, they can do it with the flip of a switch. Once you disable iCloud, Apple stops client-side scanning altogether. That arguement is a whole lot of bark with no bite, and unless Apple did the unthinkable (eg. store hashes for every photo you ever took regardless of it's status on iCloud), it's never going to hold water.

> If the government wants to create a population-wide dragnet there are a lot of other ways to also do that.

Oh, like they already[0] do[1]? iMessage has been wiretapped since 2013, it's an open secret at this point that Apple is deep in bed with domestic intelligence agencies. Denying this is just refusing to acknowledge a truth that has reared it's ugly head again and again and again.

> If for example an iPhone was a literal perfect privacy machine it would simply be forbidden from being sold in totalitarian countries that wanted that type of dragnet.

Countries like China, who demanded that Apple give them complete control over their domestic data[2], a request that Apple happily complied with? If they give foreign markets complete control over iPhone data in their respective countries, imagine for a moment how trustworthy their behavior is in the United States, the same country that decides if they're a monopoly or not and sets their tax rates.

> the thing that protects me is not the technology, it's that I live in a democratic country that has laws to stop such thing as being prosecuted for just attending a protest

If you think that's what they care about then you're missing the point entirely too. People aren't paranoid that they're going to be thrown in jail for legal action, that's frankly silly. What the United States wants is two things: your trust and your data. They could care less if you're cooking drugs on your property, selling weapons illegally or, in many cases, exploiting children. If they actually cared about those things, they'd divert some of the national budget to addressing those issues. Instead, they take that money and invest it in surveillance. Billions of dollars get poured into black budgets every year, with margins that constantly expand. The NSA regularly backdoors encryption standards, the FBI regularly designs exploits and incorporates them into US infrastructure. If any of our surveillance programs want to backdoor an iPhone or introduce vulnerabilities into iPhones, Apple has no recourse.

> The police can listen to my phone calls and read my mail _right now_ but what keeps that kind of thing from being used against me in an unfair way are the courts.

What keeps them from doing that is that it's a pointless, fruitless endeavor to try and criminalize their entire nation. It wouldn't be hard to arrest the majority of US Citizens, it would just be expensive and time-consuming. A much more appealing effort is to keep tabs on everything you do, everywhere you go and everyone you talk to. That way, if you become a legitimate threat to the state they can zero you before you cause any real damage. Make no mistake, every government is only out to save their own skin. You may disagree with it, or find it silly, but that's realpolitik for you.

> Fundamentally I don't think any technological solution can save any of us if we live under a totalitarian government.

Finally, your first reasonable argument (and it's a concession to the point the other commenter was making in the first place). There is no way that we're living in a world where our government lacks the competence or resources to effectively monitor us at every corner. The reason why this concerns people is that it allows governments to collect data on what kinds of photos their population has saved/synced with the cloud. Apple is given a black-box list of irreversible image signatures that the government themselves consider harmful, and there is literally zero transparency that goes into this process. We have quite literally no idea how any of this works, and have no way to verify that it isn't being abused. Your trust in Apple and the US Government has to be unreasonably high to confidently say that this won't be abused in some way.

[0] https://reason.com/2021/12/07/secret-documents-show-which-me...

[1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2012/04/apple-holds-the-mast...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-apple-icloud-insigh...

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:35AM (#29590375)
>You're pulling this hypothetical figure out of thin air, it may as well be one in a hundred or one in a trillion.

I agree, but it’s just as had waving when I say maybe it’s low chance that there are false positives, as it is when you’re freaking out at it being a hypothetically high number of false positives.

> That's not the problem here. If people want to continue to store photos of child exploitation on their iPhone, they can do it with the flip of a switch. Once you disable iCloud, Apple stops client-side scanning altogether.

If it’s so much under the users control why do you care or feel like this is an invasion of privacy then? I’ll say I feel like it’s still useful because criminals make dumb mistakes that incriminate themselves all the time — and this is a fine balance between being overly invasive and catching some people that store abuse images.

> Oh, like they already[0] do[1]? iMessage has been wiretapped since 2013, it's an open secret at this point that Apple is deep in bed with domestic intelligence agencies. Denying this is just refusing to acknowledge a truth that has reared it's ugly head again and again and again.

Yes, everyone knows this stuff, but just because it’s happening does not mean it can be used to incriminate someone in court unless there is justified prior suspicion which a judge issues a warrant for. That’s where the transparency is, at the court level.

> Countries like China…

This is a silly example, it makes me sad to say, but people in China are going to have their personal freedoms violated in very harsh ways regardless of Apple operating there of not. Unfortunately that’s the reality of living under totalitarianism — I don’t know why you’d even bring this up when I am clearly stating that what really protects people is living in a free democratic country with a well functioning court system.

> If they actually cared about those things, they'd divert some of the national budget to addressing those issues. Instead, they take that money and invest it in surveillance. Billions of dollars get poured into black budgets every year, with margins that constantly expand. The NSA regularly backdoors encryption standards, the FBI regularly designs exploits and incorporates them into US infrastructure.

I don’t wholly disagree, but I don’t see the connection with the original point. Also, you’re talking about governments as a monolith, which is a mistake. Any government is made of may departments and people, when you say ‘if they actually cared’, who’s the ‘they’? I think it’s really silly to say no-one in any part of the FBI cares about stoping child abuse for example. Sure I get that the CIA does not care, but that’s just not their job either.

> If any of our surveillance programs want to backdoor an iPhone or introduce vulnerabilities into iPhones, Apple has no recourse.

Maybe, maybe not. What is your hypothetical scenario for this? Can you explain how you think they’d do this where Apple has no recourse? Also who is the ‘they’? When you just say ‘they’ in a handwaving general way you sound conspiratorial. Are you saying they’d do it and apple could not detect it? Or that they’d coerce apple and apple would have no legal way to stop them?

> A much more appealing effort is to keep tabs on everything you do, everywhere you go and everyone you talk to. That way, if you become a legitimate threat to the state they can zero you before you cause any real damage. Make no mistake, every government is only out to save their own skin. You may disagree with it, or find it silly, but that's realpolitik for you.

This is where we depart the most. I’m European, In my opinion, America, with its two party non proportional system is a very poor example of democracy that is quite susceptible it corruption because of it’s concentration of powers. Just because you guys don’t live in a well functioning democracy does not mean that’s the case for the whole world — you’re projecting a bit here. I guess we agree in our mistrust of the US. Hopefully you guys don’t slid more on that totalitarian scale even more I guess.

> There is no way that we're living in a world where our government lacks the competence or resources to effectively monitor us at every corner.

I guess you don’t know about off grid log cabins that have no cell signal ;-)

> Apple is given a black-box list of irreversible image signatures that the government themselves consider harmful, and there is literally zero transparency that goes into this process. We have quite literally no idea how any of this works,

I think this is the point you’re wrong here, if there is a false positive I believe even in the US that you’ll be able to simply exhibit the source image that caused the false positive in court, if it even gets that far, which I think probably not, and prove innocence. The hash match is not the proof that you have child abuse images — it just starts a process of review. I think in practice it’ll start a process where a manual review will happen where someone will look at your source image and say, oh yeah, that’s clearly a false positive, and then it’s done. I’m sure we’ll know more where the first people get cause with this mechanism because it will still have to be prosecuted in a public court and at that time we won’t have to speculate so much.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by bratwurst3000 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:02AM (#29566836)
They are Not scanning the photos But if there is a positive scan of the hash of a photo then the photo will be send to a human to check. Now with a certain error rate it is sure that humans working at apple will see privat photos that don’t have child pornography in them .
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by dsomers on Thursday December 16, 2021 @03:44AM (#29576315)
What are we talking here, 1 in 1 billion. I just can’t care that much unless there’s real evidence that the error rate is really high.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by bratwurst3000 on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:47AM (#29673171)
I dont know the error rate of image recognition but it is certainly more than one in a million. More 1-10%. But i dont want to talk the idea of apple down. I am okey with them scanning THEIR servers for childporn. As long as the keep away from MY phone.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by theshrike79 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:34PM (#29595400)
Three positive matches to known child pornography.

The chance of that happening in the real world is astronomically small.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by bonniemuffin on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:53PM (#29561891)
+1. I have Siri, Alexa, and Google home devices in my house, and Siri is the best in terms of competence and privacy. Alexa feels like being bugged by a creepo who keeps trying to sell me stuff. (We got rid of the Alexa.)
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by fartcannon on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:59PM (#29561928)
They all spy. Alexa is just the most obvious. You should get rid of them all.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by LeoPanthera on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:22PM (#29562064)
I hate writing "citation needed", but, citation needed. That's a big claim.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by smoldesu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:22AM (#29562736)
Apple owns up to sending a certain amount of telemetry[0] back home, but we have no way of verifying what it is since the traffic is encrypted. It's impossible to know what data it's collecting and sending back, or even how anonymized that information is. On top of that, Siri invocations are recorded and saved for 6 months, and then retained for an additional 2 years after being dis-associated with your account. Once again, there is no way for us to verify Apple's claims here; we could definitely have another iMessage scenario on our hands where they just keep all that data anyways, and when they're called out on it they simply blame the USA and try to look as powerless as possible. Like the other commenter suggested, it hinges solely on how much you trust a single company. This single company in question is located in the domestic United States, is known to comply with intelligence agencies, and has every reason in the world to kiss up to American authority. I'll let you do the math here.

[0] https://www.cnet.com/home/smart-home/homepod-echo-google-hom...

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by colordrops on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:46AM (#29562851)
UFOs, cold fusion, and reptilian overlords are big claims. A company driven by profit with a history of questionable practices doing shady things with data is in no way a big claim. It's happened countless times.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by marginalia_nu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:46PM (#29570027)
I find it pretty funny how the business model is pretty much exactly that of BonziBuddy.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by Clampower on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:31AM (#29566406)
??

I have Alexa through Sonos for years. It has never tried to sell me anything? What’s the context of these upsells?

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by nullc on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:22AM (#29562406)
> you can choose whether it is stored or not

You choose to tell them to store it or not. Due to third party doctrine you have very little legal protection for material you voluntarily provide to a third party. Even if apple behaves honestly and has no vulnerabilities or compromises they may be forced to hand the data over.

And the fact that you don't know this says to me that Apple is in practice unethically exaggerating the level of privacy they're able to provide.

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by kingcharles on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:20AM (#29562991)
The third party doctrine has changed though, since US v. Warshak and Carpenter v. US, right?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Warshak

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carpenter_v._United_States

Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by danielheath on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:55PM (#29561902)
I've never used Alexa and sort of assumed it was the same thing as Siri, but I'd permanently abandon the iOS ecosystem the first time Siri tried an upsell.
Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa? by tzs on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:41AM (#29565177)
Would it work to turn off the microphones on your HomePods, turn off listening for "Hey Siri" on your phone, iPad, and Macs, and set your Apple watch to the "raise to speak" setting, and then do all your voice control through the watch?

If that works, that might be a solution for people who want the convenience of voice control but do not want an always-listening microphone in their house.