Re:Ask HN: Private Alternatives to Alexa?
by nullc on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:22AM
(#29562406)
> you can choose whether it is stored or not
You choose to tell them to store it or not. Due to third party doctrine you have very little legal protection for material you voluntarily provide to a third party. Even if apple behaves honestly and has no vulnerabilities or compromises they may be forced to hand the data over.
And the fact that you don't know this says to me that Apple is in practice unethically exaggerating the level of privacy they're able to provide.
You choose to tell them to store it or not. Due to third party doctrine you have very little legal protection for material you voluntarily provide to a third party. Even if apple behaves honestly and has no vulnerabilities or compromises they may be forced to hand the data over.
And the fact that you don't know this says to me that Apple is in practice unethically exaggerating the level of privacy they're able to provide.