WD develops both NAND ( via SanDisk / Toshiba ) and HDD. They know the roadmap of both HDD and NAND. There is nothing on the current NAND roadmap which suggest we get another significant cost reduction. As much as I want to see 2TB SSD below $99. I would be surprised if we could even get to that point by 2024. Today a portable 5TB HDD cost $129, ( or $109 with discount )
This is similar to DRAM, we might get faster, higher efficiency DRAM. But we are not getting any cheaper DRAM. The price of DRAM / GB in the past 10 years has had the same price floor.
HDD is in similar case, it is near the end of the S curve.
That's not how flash storage works. You can unplug a flash drive and put it on a shelf and it will keep its data. Here's a review of portable, external SSDs that don't lose their data when not plugged in:
* https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-external-hard-driv...
Are you thinking of DRAM perhaps?
Could not the same be said of the magnetism of the bits on spinning rust? What's the shelf life of data on an HDD?
Tapes also have magnetic charge, but are designed to be "unrefreshed" for longer periods of time.
Flash has a better insulator than DRAM, but it wears out with use and leaks more with higher temperature, densities, less margin with more bits per cell...
The fact that the SSD controller has to do anything at all to read data that was stored only a year ago is a hint that data retention on a SSD requires some (powered) effort.
- a switch from storing charge in a conductive floating gate structure to storing charge in a non-conductive charge trap layer (Intel's flash is the one holdout here)
- a switch from planar to 3D fabrication, allowing a huge one-time increase in memory cell volume and thus the number of electrons used to represent each bit, and also opening up avenues of scaling capacity that don't require reducing cell volume
- dedicating far more transistors to error correction in SSD controllers, greatly reducing the performance impact of correctable bit errors but also enabling the use of more robust error correction codes
Please see [1] for one source.
[1] https://www.ibm.com/support/pages/flash-data-retention-0
Additionally, lightly-used flash has error rates that are orders of magnitude smaller than flash that has reached or is approaching its write endurance limit. Which is why an archive-only SSD can very reasonably be expected to provide unpowered data retention far in excess of one year.
[1] For enterprise drives, the specified duration is shorter but the storage temperature is higher. The warrantied write endurance is also typically higher, so those drives are willing to take their flash to a more thoroughly worn-out state.
> Wikibon argues the cross-over timing between SSDs and HDDs can be determined using Wright’s Law. This axiom derives its name from the author of a seminal 1936 paper, entitled ‘Factors Affecting the Costs of Airplanes, in which Theodore Wright, an American aeronautical engineer, noted that airplane production costs decreased at a constant 10 to 15 per cent rate for every doubling of production numbers. His insight is also called the Experience Curve because manufacturing shops learn through experience and become more efficient.
[…]
> “Wikibon projects that flash consumer SSDs become cheaper than HDDs on a dollar per terabyte basis by 2026, in only about 5 years (2021),” he writes. “Innovative storage and processor architectures will accelerate the migration from HDD to NAND flash and tape using consumer-grade flash. …
* https://blocksandfiles.com/2021/01/25/wikibon-ssds-vs-hard-d...
Interesting prediction.