News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by JaimeThompson on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:56AM (#29552185)
Flash has to be powered so the contents of each cell can be refreshed so data isn't lost which make it a less than optimal solution for long term archival storage or offside backups. Simply storing the physical media is easier than maintaining and keeping secure systems to plug the flash devices into.
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by throw0101a on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:15AM (#29552407)
> Flash has to be powered so the contents of each cell can be refreshed so data isn't lost

That's not how flash storage works. You can unplug a flash drive and put it on a shelf and it will keep its data. Here's a review of portable, external SSDs that don't lose their data when not plugged in:

* https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-external-hard-driv...

Are you thinking of DRAM perhaps?

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by nisegami on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:25AM (#29552536)
No, they're referring to bit rot on flash storage due to slow leakage of the charge that represents the data. It occurs on long time scales, definitely years. But the more bits per cell (SLC vs TLC vs QLC), the more likely it is.
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by throw0101a on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:54AM (#29553900)
> No, they're referring to bit rot on flash storage due to slow leakage of the charge that represents the data.

Could not the same be said of the magnetism of the bits on spinning rust? What's the shelf life of data on an HDD?

Tapes also have magnetic charge, but are designed to be "unrefreshed" for longer periods of time.

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by labawi on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:59PM (#29555802)
Tapes and HDDs are magnetic. Flash and DRAM is electric. It is easier to create magnetically stable structures (magnets) than non-leaking capacitors.

Flash has a better insulator than DRAM, but it wears out with use and leaks more with higher temperature, densities, less margin with more bits per cell...

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by AshamedCaptain on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:28AM (#29553428)
I remember there was some analysis done on the SSD of an old early model Surface Pro showing that with age the SSD would become slower at _reading_ data that had not been modified recently. EDIT: It was this story https://mspoweruser.com/samsung-releases-firmware-update-for...

The fact that the SSD controller has to do anything at all to read data that was stored only a year ago is a hint that data retention on a SSD requires some (powered) effort.

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by wtallis on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:45AM (#29553709)
Slower read speeds on old data is indeed a symptom of the SSD controller having to use its slower and more thorough error-correction mechanisms to recover data. However, since the first few generations of Microsoft Surface machines, the SSD market has made several relevant changes:

- a switch from storing charge in a conductive floating gate structure to storing charge in a non-conductive charge trap layer (Intel's flash is the one holdout here)

- a switch from planar to 3D fabrication, allowing a huge one-time increase in memory cell volume and thus the number of electrons used to represent each bit, and also opening up avenues of scaling capacity that don't require reducing cell volume

- dedicating far more transistors to error correction in SSD controllers, greatly reducing the performance impact of correctable bit errors but also enabling the use of more robust error correction codes

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by JaimeThompson on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:34AM (#29552642)
Depending on the design of the flash, the storage temperature, and other factors that data can rot.

Please see [1] for one source.

[1] https://www.ibm.com/support/pages/flash-data-retention-0

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by selfhoster11 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#29553229)
That's what I'm thinking. If flash-based archives require servicing to keep their data, there are systems that provide far better trade-offs for similar amount of bother.
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by edoceo on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:11AM (#29552371)
Can you put them in a battery powered box, with no data connection? I'm thinking my little consumer grade APC could power one for many days (months?). I'll have to check the numbers
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by wtallis on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:59AM (#29552988)
You don't need to keep SSDs powered continuously. You just need to power them on periodically and read all the data on the drive so the SSD controller has the chance to notice data degradation and repair it before it becomes unrecoverable. This does not need to be done more often than once per year. For SSDs that are exclusively used for archival and thus never approach the end of their rated write endurance, it may be adequate to do this once per decade. Basically, any backup strategy that includes a sensible amount of testing and verification should suffice.
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by JaimeThompson on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#29553217)
IBM, Samsung, Intel, and other manufactures of flash and flash based products disagree with you on that only once per year time frame. As flash gets more and more dense leakage from the cells becomes a much more difficult problem to solve.
Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by wtallis on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:24AM (#29553360)
Last time I checked, those companies were still adhering to the JEDEC standards for how they define SSD write endurance, which is based on how worn-out the flash can be while still meeting certain unpowered data retention thresholds. For consumer SSDs, that threshold is one year unpowered and stored at 30°C. [1] All of the challenges of unpowered data retention are already being addressed in the normal course of bringing new generations of flash and SSDs to market, even though nobody is yet making drives specifically tailored for that use case.

Additionally, lightly-used flash has error rates that are orders of magnitude smaller than flash that has reached or is approaching its write endurance limit. Which is why an archive-only SSD can very reasonably be expected to provide unpowered data retention far in excess of one year.

[1] For enterprise drives, the specified duration is shorter but the storage temperature is higher. The warrantied write endurance is also typically higher, so those drives are willing to take their flash to a more thoroughly worn-out state.

Re:Western Digital HDD boss mentions archive disk drive idea by selfhoster11 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:13AM (#29553210)
At this point, you might as well just invest in a tape library