Today, I just don't have a need to do such things. Whenever I encounter this weird behavior, I just stop interacting, because I have a feeling it's some 13-16 year old wasting my time.
Facebook isn't arguing this from a neutral standpoint. They are arguing from the position of the company that stands to lose their business if society decides murderers shouldn't have guns.
Social media platforms create immense value as well. I might not be a user but I can see how it helps a lot of people as well.
Do we enforce license on people to use social media platforms?
I think the problem is misalignment of incentives. If I'm incentivized to increase engagement, then I can think of some pretty ridiculous shit to say that will get lots of people clicking downvote and shouting at me.
I think these platforms could have been more proactive in setting those cultural norms that evolve into fruitful social interaction.
You will see a lot of toxicity and you can find several deleted or heavily downvoted comments.
As even HN front page and commenr section is algorithmic. Vote brigading happens here as well for posts and comments.
I personally like that they try to play down controversies instead of optimizing for engagement from them.
Imagine a big social media platform doing it. Just because some topic became a flamewar if it gets removed, one party will blow it up as them being censored. When these posts are started by your ruling lawmakers, it can even be cited as contempt. It is an extremely tricky thing for big social media platforms to moderate content.
Thousands of years of tribalistic evolution can't be removed in just a few decades, this is a lot on how humans interact.
Example found after 10 seconds of Googling: https://www.vice.com/en/article/3da838/an-attempted-suicide-...
In any case, he is right. Look at the pattern, any large social network has these issues, which more or less seems like is related to how people interact. Twitter is massively toxic, Reddit is. Back in day Tumblr which was not current social media huge also used to have content Facebook gets blamed for.
Give a platform for people to publish and share and every opinion has the chance to be there.
It also doesn't have to be a massive broadcast platform, messaging platforms with small communities in the form of groups have these issues on a smaller scale. Though broadcast does make it worse.