News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by LinuxBender on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:32PM (#29523077)
Best vs Worst? That doesn't feel like the right way to look at things. Nuclear is probably an appropriate medium term solution for some locations until battery storage is better and more affordable at mass scale. Being a pragmatic minimalist I believe all options should be on the table and grab what option suits your geographic location and load requirements best, factoring in initial costs, time to deploy, cost to support, cost to tear down, environmental impact, local politics, operational longevity... all of these things being complicated topics on their own that vary wildly by location.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:31PM (#29523525)
A lot of those costs come from over cautiousness on the part of regulators. Requiring that radiation exposure on site all the way to the fence line must be not more than 15mrem per year is just silly. You get more than that walking into a granite building or taking the subway. Remediation requirements also bizarrely require remediation to far below background levels. Former uranium mines in NV have the lowest measurable radiation levels in the whole state.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by cannaceo on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:03PM (#29523776)
Funny how that can work. We can’t use natural fruit puree for cannabis edibles because they won’t pass pesticide testing.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:05PM (#29523795)
Yeah, it’s really wild. You get more mrems per year living down wind of a coal plant than you would living in a nuclear plant’s control room. You get more from eating bananas.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by bryanlarsen on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:55PM (#29523729)
Battery storage is already sufficient and inexpensive enough for deployment today at costs less than nuclear.

A 3x overbuild of solar+wind in an optimal mix, along with a continental grid and 3 hours worth of batteries is all you need for 99.99% reliability: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z

https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/electrify

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:10PM (#29523839)
You need lots of transmission lines for that to work, and high voltage transmission is expensive to build, eats up land, and is opposed by every community it passes through.

I’m 100% in favor of lots of renewable use, but it’s not always a great use of land, prevents rewilding (with solar), and in the case of solar uses a ton of water. The latter being a major concern in arid regions.

A lot of nuclear’s cost comes from shifting/overly tight regulation, legal prohibition of reprocessing, legal prohibition for long term storage, and graft. The latter will be a problem with large scale renewables once they’re large enough.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by bryanlarsen on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:31PM (#29524019)
You're right about the transmission lines.

Land use of required solar is only a few hundred square miles in the US. Not a big deal.

Nuclear's biggest cost is just that the US is very bad at doing big projects. Just the steam turbine in a nuclear plant is enough to make nuclear uneconomical, that's why coal plants are so much more expensive than natural gas.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:24PM (#29524431)
That’s because solar produces a tiny fraction of our energy mix. Replacing a single average US reactor with solar would require something like 200 square miles.

Nuclear’s problem is badly written regulation and insane environmental review policies. That and the one off nature of their construction. We need to standardize and rewrite regulation based on probabilistic risk rather than worst case scenario planning and the linear non-threshold model.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by bryanlarsen on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:26PM (#29524832)
I mistook. Enough solar for the US is a 200x200 mile square. Still fairly insignificant, much less than the amount of land dedicated to parking lots.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @06:59PM (#29525518)
NREL estimates 14,000,000 acres or 22,000 square miles to go 100% solar, or the entire Mojave desert.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:21PM (#29525675)
So, about 1.4% of the total area of agricultural land in the US.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ncmncm on Sunday December 12, 2021 @04:21AM (#29528210)
Given that solar can be installed on existing agricultural land, both increasing crop yield and reducing water use, land for solar is not even a small worry.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:09AM (#29529326)
It's also smaller than the land area currently used by fossil fuel production (1.3% of US land area.)
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:54PM (#29525966)
Yeah, which is a ton. You necessarily need to put it somewhere sunny, connectable to transmission, serviceable by roads, you need water, and it can't be too cold or hot for reasons of efficiency. The space and logistics aren't trivial.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Saturday December 11, 2021 @08:19PM (#29526125)
It's not an unreasonable amount of land to power an entire country. I mean, does anyone complain that agriculture is impossible because it uses 72 times that much land?
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by kwhitefoot on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:21PM (#29523934)
We have a lot of the transmission lines already although of course we need more. The major missing part is interconnects between countries, or regions of large countries like the US. Germany has an over supply of renewable energy on occasion but is unable to export the energy so it simply drives the price negative in Germany while prices are high elsewhere.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:29PM (#29523992)
This is both a political problem and an energy sovereignty issue. You could turn Libya into solar Russia, but would you want to do that?

My other concern is that such a complex and interconnected system is likely to be fragile in unexpected ways.

And none of this addresses the land area required for base load solar.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ephbit on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @03:06PM (#29556791)
> ... concern is that such a complex and interconnected system is likely to be fragile in unexpected ways.

I second that.

The robustness of the current global energy supply system based largely upon solid, liquid and gaseous fuels stems from its flexibility and inherent buffering capability and the fact that lots of the connections/links are loose/weak/interchangeable. (Supplier of fuel xy can be chosen relatively spontaneously, completely unlike some cable which invariably connects two fixed geographic locations.)

An intercontinental electrical grid is in comparison dramatically less flexible. I'd call it grossly negligent to even attempt to implement a world spanning grid exceeding lets say 15 % of total power transmission.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by p_l on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:27PM (#29523982)
Germany pays neighbours to stop their own wind farms to sell power from their own, because they can't ship the energy from wind-rich north southwards due to lack of necessary interconnects. It's not that simple.

And the overbuilding necessary is usually more in range of 10x assuming favourable storage conditions (which aren't necessarily available).

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:38AM (#29529503)
When I look at "Germany, 2011 weather data, 2030 cost assumptions" in https://model.energy/ I get an optimized solution (for synthetic baseload production) that has PV and wind curtailment at 4.6% and 12.3%, respectively. This solution includes batteries and hydrogen; generally when hydrogen is included curtailment is limited (because you can make hydrogen when the sources would have been curtailed, up to some point of sufficiently rare curtailment that the extra electrolysers don't make sense.)
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by p_l on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:32AM (#29529909)
This holds as long as hydrogen storage can be kept quite low (assuming no improvements in nuclear) i.e. you have plentiful underground caverns. Helps that the data they have on caverns is actually for germany.

Mind you, the model misses things like "Bavaria is NIMBYing all necessary transit work" etc. which is why you have weird situation of Germany paying Netherlands to curtail wind farms while buying nuclear from France, because they have to route around NIMBYs.

Only slightly related - I'd love if the cost comparisons in general discourse stopped avoiding the issue of intermittency (that's how you always get such low prices on wind and solar) and used costs that include capacity factor and dispatchability (which https://model.energy/ does). Having funding (and purchasing priority) decided on dispatchable green sources (whether hydro, wind/solar/battery/hydrogen mixes, or nuclear) would probably help a lot in stabilisation of grid and long term decarbonisation, even if it would reduce some frankly pathological incentives for renewable build out (pathological because of linked carbon-producing plant build out to stabilise the setup, while simultaneously using cheap peak production prices to push out stable setups)

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:51AM (#29530554)
That site may overestimate the cost of dealing with intermittency, since it doesn't include dispatchable demand. For example, if hydrogen is to be used in steelmaking or ammonia synthesis, that demand can also be added when renewables would otherwise be curtailed, and the hydrogen stored for later use.

The site's model also does not include pumped hydro, or intermediate term thermal storage.

All these extra options can only help reduce the cost of integrating renewables, and make renewables more competitive vs. nuclear.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ephbit on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @03:20PM (#29556997)
> ... dispatchable demand. For example, if hydrogen is to be used in steelmaking or ammonia synthesis, that demand can also be added when renewables would otherwise be curtailed, and the hydrogen stored for later use.

Isn't the problem that electrolyzers mostly have to run 24/7 because they would otherwise not be profitable? Then all these processes that rely on hydrogen wouldn't actually belong to the dispatchable demand category.

Dispatchable demand could be found in heat pumps (in combination with buffer tanks) for heating homes. (As long as there's sufficient grid capacity)

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:17PM (#29568830)
When the idea was to turn relatively expensive electricity into hydrogen to replace gasoline, then it made sense to make the electrolyzers as efficient as practical, even if that made them more expensive.

But using curtailed intermittent power is different: here, the electricity is cheap, and capital cost of the electrolyzer becomes more important than efficiency. Under these different design tradeoffs, one might use a different technology (alkaline electrolyzers without platinium group catalysts, say, rather than PEM cells with expensive Nafion membranes and platinum.)

I have seen claims that alkaline electrolyzers are available for < $200/kW in China.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by p_l on Sunday December 12, 2021 @11:07AM (#29530729)
Pumped hydro has the problem of "we pretty much can't build more".

As for curtailment-reducing tricks, that's a good argument but IMO not changing the base calculus much - the model is about replacing the base demand power sources, so that we can push the extra into peak. Bigger problem is that scaling down demand is problematic for dealing with underproduction, and also simply missing on power (Thus my preference for billing for dispatchable power generation, then extra peak could be funneled easier into bonus things like green hydrogen for non-storage etc.)

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:12PM (#29531360)
> Pumped hydro has the problem of "we pretty much can't build more".

On-river pumped hydro is not easily expanded. But there is enormous potential for off-river pumped hydro.

http://re100.eng.anu.edu.au/global/

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by p_l on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:47PM (#29532331)
Consider the large missing areas on the map. For example, Poland and Germany has 0 sites (Poland pretty much built all hydro it could without causing more environment damage)
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Sunday December 12, 2021 @02:15PM (#29532606)
That's certainly true, but it's also certainly true that "we can't build anymore" is by no means universally true. Great swathes of the world have far more PHES potential than they need.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by kleene_op on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:51PM (#29524599)
1 MWh roughly costs 150$ for nuclear, about 50$ for wind/solar. You're telling me that the magical solution to all our energy problem using solar and wind energy only would be to overbuild THREE times solar and wind infrastructures, for a cost of 3*50=150$/MWh, which is essentially the same as if we were to use nuclear instead.

PLUS 3 hours battery scattered everywhere in the country (to be renewed every few years).

PLUS a full continental electricity grid (basically admitting that not every country can be sovereign of their own energy).

Was this post supposed to make solar and wind look good?

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by bryanlarsen on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:20PM (#29525661)
Where are you getting those numbers? This project is $40/MWh, and includes 4 hours of batteries! https://www.energy-storage.news/developer-8minute-says-more-...

Solar power is now less than $10/MWh in Spain and Arizona: https://qz.com/1995355/the-era-of-subsidies-for-wind-and-sol...

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by Gwypaas on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:05PM (#29524697)
$50 is a very high number and location specific. You get off-shore wind power in the UK for that, with off-shore being more expensive than on-shore.

$13.5 for solar in Abu Dhabi could be set as the current lower limit in optimal conditions.

https://rethinkresearch.biz/articles/uae-solar-deal-brings-l...

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:56PM (#29524229)
Medium term the best solution is massive rollout of renewables, with some storage, and gas to fill in the gaps. This will more rapidly reduce grid CO2 emissions, and for much lower cost, than a nuclear rollout.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by actually_a_dog on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:59PM (#29523754)
Sure, in the medium term, nuclear probably is the best solution. But, nuclear is not going to save us from 1.5°C (nothing can, in fact)[0], and it isn't going to do anything for us for 20-30 years. That's how long it takes to build a nuclear plant in the US.

We can't let nuclear distract us from the goal, which is preventing more serious warming.

---

[0]: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/aug/09/humans-have-...

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by orangecat on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:29PM (#29523997)
it isn't going to do anything for us for 20-30 years. That's how long it takes to build a nuclear plant in the US.

First, the time it takes to build a nuclear plant is not an unalterable law of nature. Second, when people were saying that we should build more plants 20 years ago, a common objection was that it would be useless because it would take 20 years and by then everything would be powered by clean renewables. I'm similarly unconvinced that wind and solar will provide everything we need by 2040.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by KennyBlanken on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:06PM (#29524312)
> I'm similarly unconvinced that wind and solar will provide everything we need by 2040.

Have you actually looked at the numbers for renewable energy installations, or is this just based on personal incredulity?

While the nuclear industry has been shouting about how we need nuclear, the US has installed about 20GW worth of renewable generation in one year. That is equivalent to about ten nuclear power plants (in the US, most plants are 1-2GW; a few are 3-3.5.)

40% of our installed capacity over the last 2 years has been renewable energy sources, and both wind and solar installed capacity is growing at a nearly logarithmic scale. The only thing cheaper than wind is solar, and both are continuing to get cheaper.

Those figures, by the way, are for utility/grid scale projects and do not include residential systems.

Utilities already consider this a solved problem and have now shifted focus to storage technology.

There is a strong online PR effort by the nuclear industry because they are desperate to stay in business I'm not exaggerating when I say that the blog of a guy who runs such a PR consulting firm has been featured more than once here on HN.

The nuclear waste problem is solvable but has not yet been solved in the US. Nuclear power plants are decade-scale projects and even once they sync up to the grid, it takes them another decade just to offset the carbon impact of their construction.

Nuclear power plants have very high OPEX and very deep/complex/exacting supply chains when we're seeing lots of supply chain issues due to climate change.

Reactor vessels require very high grade metal and specialized firms, and those firms have years if not decades long waiting lists. We can't just snap our fingers and create more reactor vessel manufacturers.

No wind farm or solar farm has caused a catastrophe of any sort, much less one that renders thousands of square miles of land uninhabitable for a century.

Wind and solar do not generate material that is extremely lethal and weaponizable.

The list goes on and on.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by kleene_op on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:00PM (#29524661)
>and both wind and solar installed capacity is growing at a nearly logarithmic scale.

Boy, that sure sounds promising

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by radu_floricica on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:29PM (#29523988)
I'm ok with 1.5C. I'm ok with significant climate change long term. I haven't read anything yet that caused me to think it's a particularly large problem. Like anything else there will be winners and losers - some places will be better, some worse. More people will die of heatstroke, a lot less of cold. It may well end up being a net benefit.

Should we avoid particularly large climate changes? Well, yes, mostly for Chesterton's Fence reasons. But I'm far from panic.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by monodeldiablo on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:41PM (#29524529)
> I haven't read anything yet that caused me to think it's a particularly large problem.

Then you haven't read much.

I suggest looking into the North Atlantic current, ENSO, ocean acidification, and long term forecasts of glacier formation, drought, fire, flooding, tropical storms, heat waves, and other extreme weather phenomena. Just skimming through the first few pages of the -- extremely conservative -- IPCC report should upend your current notion that global warming "may well end up being a net benefit".

Global warming does not simply mean the world uniformly heats up a degree. It means more energy is injected into the atmosphere, adding additional chaos and instability to an already chaotic and unpredictable system. This will mean more extreme weather, steep reduction in fish stocks and agricultural productivity that will shock the food system, and mass migrations of people unlucky enough to be born in those regions most badly affected.

To believe that global warming -- literally a global problem -- isn't "a particularly large problem" is akin to saying covid is "a bit of a cold". That statement spectacularly underestimates the scope and scale of the threat, and ignores the chorus of experts who have spent the last half-century being depressingly accurate (or even conservative) in all their forecasts.

You are "ok with 1.5C" because you don't understand what it means.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by sjwalter on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:57AM (#29527499)
> This will mean more ...

One thing particularly strange about climate change alarmists is that they are just so damn sure of all these horrible outcomes that are absolutely sure to happen.

You're forecasting, dude. You don't have a crystal ball. Yet your statements, and those of all the alarmists, are those of the totally cocksure.

I live near Glacier National Park. In the early 2000s, some climate change model predicted the glaciers would be gone by 2020. All the entrance signs were modified to state this to every single visitor: Enjoy 'em while they last, friends, but climate change will render these glaciers puddles by just 2020!

Well, come 2020, the glaciers are still right there. A bit smaller. But also nowhere near gone.

Failed predictions and shrill screeching forecasting failures stack up over and over from all the alarmists and yet still they, as you do here, fail to have any humility, any sense that, hey, maybe you don't know it's the end of the world for sure.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by monodeldiablo on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:52PM (#29534949)
> One thing particularly strange about climate change alarmists is that they are just so damn sure of all these horrible outcomes that are absolutely sure to happen.

It's a shame you didn't quote more of my first sentence there. Let me help: "This will mean more extreme weather..."

Guess what 2021 featured? A 1000 year heat wave in the oh-so-temperate Pacific Northwest, at temperatures previously considered physically impossible in that region. And a few months prior? Record-setting cold wiped out the grid in Houston and plunged a big chunk of Texas into survival mode.

If you're looking for an all-at-once calamity to herald the coming of Climate Doom, you're gonna have to watch the movies. Because what all the science clearly indicates is a gradual, inexorable increase in extreme phenomena.

> You're forecasting, dude. You don't have a crystal ball. Yet your statements, and those of all the alarmists, are those of the totally cocksure.

I mean, we're having an informal discussion on the internet, where scientific jargon and careful discussion of error bars gets in the way of clear communication. But I can still be pretty damn confident of those predictions because climate change isn't some far-off future possibility. It's unfolding all around us, as we speak. The increase in extreme weather? It's been going on for 50 years.

Rising temperatures? Droughts? Floods? Fires? They're all on the upswing and have been for long enough that it's impossible at this point to attribute them all to some statistical anomaly.

Let's put it another way. If you catch me playing with matches on the couch and exclaim, "You'll burn the house down!", I probably have some cause to accuse you of being overly dramatic. If, on the other hand, the house is already on fire, my protestations that "You can't be so cocksure it'll be uncomfortable to live in the house" sound pretty ridiculous.

> I live near Glacier National Park.

Cool. That's an anecdote. Not data. Do you have any actual data to support your stance that climate scientists -- climatologists, meteorologists, geologists, etc -- the world over are "alarmists"?

> Failed predictions and shrill screeching forecasting failures stack up over and over from all the alarmists and yet still they, as you do here, fail to have any humility, any sense that, hey, maybe you don't know it's the end of the world for sure.

Straw man. Nobody's claiming it'll be the end of the world. The planet will be just fine. Humans will simply find it a more inhospitable place in which to live. Which is what I said. And all those "shrill screeching forecasting failures" from the last 30 years have, on average, been too conservative, forecasting slower warming.

You just haven't noticed because you don't want to believe it might be true. I understand the emotional reaction. It's the same thing that compels people to refuse to believe that covid exists or vaccines work. Doesn't mean it's a logical or accurate stance, though.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by radu_floricica on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:45PM (#29527226)
I did read the IPCC report a while back, or at least the summary. It's surprisingly common sense, given how it's described. Change is coming, some of it bad, a minority pretty bad.

There are quite a lot "pretty bad" things out there.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by monodeldiablo on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:32PM (#29534819)
Cool!

Now consider that almost every previous cycle of the IPCC report has missed its forecasted marks because it was too conservative.

The IPCC report is the toned down, let's-not-rock-the-boat version of the scientific community's view regarding the unfolding climate disaster. It is an optimistic set of forecasts, with loads of hedging.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by LightG on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:22PM (#29524406)
Luckily there are democracies who are fianlly not ok with 1.5c and significant climate change long term.

Time will tell who wins out.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by ch4s3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:00PM (#29524258)
The guardian isn’t a reputable source on this. We could adjust regulation in the US, pre-approve a handful of small to medium reactor designs and probably have a lot of them built in under 10 years.

The historical lag time comes from the period of rapid technological improvement and regulatory change where projects had to be redesigned multiple times mid project.

If you think grid scale solar and wind are just as susceptible to bad regulation, NIMBYs, graft, and bureaucratic nonsense then you may not be paying attention. Note the lack of offshore wind in the US.

Existing nuclear power tech could displace natural gas and coal without the need for storage or much land. We also wouldn’t need to overhaul the grid.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by actually_a_dog on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:37PM (#29526609)
Not a reputable source on what? Your comment has nothing to do with what the Guardian article I linked says.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by p_l on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:23PM (#29523950)
Building extra LNG plants is going to help us even less, and that's what it currently takes to keep grid operational with renewables, so...
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by actually_a_dog on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:25PM (#29523968)
Who said anything about LNG? Why the straw man? I said nuclear won't save us, full stop. Please do not put words in my mouth.
Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by p_l on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:31PM (#29524018)
Well, the "it's not going to do anything right now so let's forget about it, maybe there will be magic battery tech in that time" is also a straw man. Meanwhile the best we have from renewable grids, even in huge interconnected systems that ostensibly should be able to shift renewable power around is... LNG build up to cover for instability of renewables, and reduced pressure on shutdown (or even extensions) to coal power plants.

Also, USA might take 30 years, but then USA is infamous for having trouble building any infrastructure these days. Global warming and energy scarcity is a global problem.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by actually_a_dog on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:33PM (#29524029)
> Well, the "it's not going to do anything right now so let's forget about it, maybe there will be magic battery tech in that time" is also a straw man.

Yes, and I also didn't say that. Again, do not put words in my mouth. I'm getting really tired of your disingenuous, bad faith non-arguments.

Re:The debate about nuclear power and climate change by pfdietz on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:03PM (#29524282)
Natural gas isn't stored as LNG in the US; it's stored as compressed gas in underground caverns. Many millions of tonnes of natural gas are stored in these caverns; they buffer the transmission system against seasonal changes in gas demand.

We could store hydrogen in those caverns instead.