News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:45AM (#29522194)
Every answer in this thread is wrong except for "hire an attorney and work with them to figure out what the best option for you is." Do not follow any "free legal advice" from HN -- and I'm speaking as an actual licensed attorney.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by prepend on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:07PM (#29522407)
I don’t question your motives in this instance, but I always pay extra attention when someone’s advice is to hire them or someone like them.

Obviously, “hire a lawyer,” is sometimes right. But if I hired a lawyer every time I was told to, I would be out hundreds of hours of billing fees. Anecdotally, I’ve never fucked anything up royally. That doesn’t mean that I made the right decision, but is something I strive for.

Spending $300-1000 on a consult every time I might need one is like taking an antibiotic every time I might have encountered a bacteria. It’s important to qualify and spend money when I actually need to rather than every time.

It’s like those people who say “don’t criticize my book until you read it” (since that usually means that it makes them some money to have me buy their book). If I had to read every book to figure out if I should like it or not, that’s impossible. I need to develop effective evaluations and filters to prevent me from wasting my time and money.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by user3939382 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:11PM (#29522437)
> Spending $300-1000 on a consult every time I might need one

Actually I’ve been surprised to find that many times even high priced attorneys are usually willing to spend 20-30 minutes+ giving you some general advice before even retaining them. I’ve gotten very valuable advice this way several times at no cost.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by uberman on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:26PM (#29522581)
This is my personal experience as well.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by devoutsalsa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:40PM (#29522694)
They need to due a little due diligence before taking you in as a client, such as assessing if your needs fall within their expertise and whether you will be a potentially profitable client. If you work as hard as you can to summarize your case to respect their time, as opposed to rambling like an incoherent crazy person, you can often get a free pointer on how to handle the case & maybe a referral to someone who is better prepared to assist you.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by y4mi on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:09PM (#29522927)
> Anecdotally, I’ve never fucked anything up royally.

You're not necessarily wrong, but that's definitely a survivalship bias. You only need to lose once for a game over, so everyone still playing underestimates the stakes at play, as there is close to no interaction to people that have lost.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by prepend on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:51PM (#29524597)
I agree. And it balances out the survivorship bias of “I always get a lawyer.”

I’m not sure of a good way to balance out and correct for my bias other than just trying to think critically for when I need and don’t need a lawyer.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:19PM (#29524785)
Which type of error do you feel more comfortable making?

One type of error is paying a lawyer when you didn't need one, in which case, you're out $X.

The other type of error is not paying a lawyer when you did need one, in which case, you're out $Y.

In my experience, the values here are frequently $Y >>> $X.

In the end, the choice is yours; you rolls your dice and takes your chances.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by nicbou on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:17PM (#29522493)
In my experience, a lawyer will also nudge you towards whichever course involves keeping a lawyer involved. They'll never tell you "if I were in your shoes, I wouldn't keep going".
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by devoutsalsa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:53PM (#29522804)
A bad lawyer will never help you get to the point, because a bad lawyer needs to milk you as they have little to no referral business.

I got a semi-serious traffic ticket in Colorado in 2014, but I lived in California. I forgot about the ticket, and remembered a couple years later. I wanted to clear up the situation, but navigating the court system from a different state was challenging. I decided hiring an attorney local to the area would be easier than traveling to Colorado.

I called maybe 6 to 8 attorneys, and they fell into three categories: too expensive, too inexperienced, or just right.

Too expensive sounded like “we’ll need a $2000 retainer to even look at your case.”

Too inexperienced sounded like “I just graduated from law school, and I’ll give you a super good rate for the experience of working on your case.”

Just right sounded like “I know the district attorney who is overseeing your case. Their name is $NAME, and here’s exactly how I’m going to handle your case… <time passes> …I might be able to handle this for $500, but it could cost maybe double that if it’s more work than expected.”

I got the matter resolved for between 1X and 2X the minimum estimate, and was happy with the results.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by winterplace on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:30PM (#29523063)
What did you use to look them up?
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:29PM (#29522602)
> In my experience, a lawyer will also nudge you towards whichever course involves keeping a lawyer involved.

Both of the times my wife and I have consulted an attorney, they provided an overview of the relevant legal and practical context, a description of options of how to approach it and what they could do as part of that and the fee structure involved, and a description of why hiring them would probably not be cost-effective for the issue at hand.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:24PM (#29522562)
I'm sorry you had such an experience. Ethical lawyers will give you the best advice they can, which often includes "you are going to end up paying me way more than what's at stake here." (This literally just happened to me as a client over a land-sale-deposit dispute.) Or, "This is a turkey of a case and you should roll over. You owe me nothing."
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by datavirtue on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:45PM (#29522739)
I have gotten that advice from lawyers. I just kept hitting up new lawyers until I found one that saw things my way. Resulted in a windfall for me.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by torstenvl on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:54PM (#29522812)
Glad it worked out for you, but it's a bad idea to extrapolate that to broader advice. Maybe you got lucky. Maybe it wasn't luck and you have some kind of gift for assessing case trajectory. But in either case, most people aren't going to be able to predict a case outcome better than experienced attorneys.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by mistrial9 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:07PM (#29522905)
two out of three common auto mechanics were caught here giving false estimates and cheating to some extent on common operations.. how many people can discern minor errors with law?
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by nrook on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:22PM (#29522538)
My experience differs. I once had a legal dispute in which I was asked to sign away some additional rights in order to receive some money that I was owed anyway. My lawyer said, essentially, "you are in the right, but you aren't planning on using those rights anyway, so just sign the paper and get this over with."

There are scrupulous and unscrupulous lawyers, much as in any profession.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:56PM (#29522820)
> My lawyer said, essentially, "you are in the right, but you aren't planning on using those rights anyway, so just sign the paper and get this over with."

There are situations where this is very good legal advice. Collecting things you are owed from people who don't want to give them up takes time and money (and involves risk), and even when it nominally works the systems intended to make you whole for the additional costs don't always, and especially often don't value time (both delay and the consumption of your personal time) as much as you do.

A lawyer's job isn't just to advise you on what the law says you are entitled to, but more critically to do so on the course of action that will best achieve your interests given the pragmatics of the legal system.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by wayoutthere on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:42PM (#29522710)
They will, because they don’t want to pursue legal action where there’s little chance of them getting paid. It’s worth giving you a half-hour of their time for free to figure out if 1) there’s enough money involved, 2) the defendant can pay up in the event of a win or 3) you can pay up if you don’t win. Nothing worse than working 100 hours and not being able to collect because the defendant is “judgment-proof” (aka flat broke).

Have a home issue where the builder owes me $100k in an open-and-shut case… but there are a dozen other people in the same situation, his company has folded and he’s under indictment for fraud in an unrelated case. My lawyer advised me to just move on with my life as any chance of collecting is near-zero.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by kingcharles on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:23PM (#29523017)
99% of the lawyers I've met are scum, and I've met hundreds.

One lawyer I hired to defend me in a contractual pay dispute said to me on the first meeting with both sides "Do not let this get to court. If this goes to court the only people that will win are me and the other lawyer. We'll both get to take an extra vacation this year." So, 1% of lawyers are not scum.

Luckily it didn't need to go to court. I walked into the meeting, let the other side play hardball, "We're not going to pay you any of the money we owe you, go fuck yourself." and then showed them in the contract they had signed where it says they don't own any of the copyright to any of the work I developed for them. They left the room and came back several minutes later with a cheque.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by winterplace on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:33PM (#29523085)
Which one was it and how did you find that person?
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by kingcharles on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:01PM (#29524671)
I can't remember his name, this was circa 2004 in the UK (so technically a "solicitor" not a lawyer). I found him on a referral from an acquaintance.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by pxx on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:47PM (#29522760)
Since your comment is categorical, I'd like to chime in with a counterexample. I've gone in for a consult and gotten "you've already pretty much done everything I would. I can charge you $2000 for the rest but you probably wouldn't want to do this seeing that you already have done all of the work."
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ChrisLomont on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:42PM (#29523164)
I've consulted lawyers perhaps a dozen times in life, and not once have they attempted to make me use them. Most actually help me in the 30 or so minutes free to find a better solution. A few times I had to go all in and hire them: I won a copyright infringement suit, stopping someone from selling knockoffs of things I sell, I needed some to represent me in states half way across the country to get a trust drawn in that state rejiggered, I won a case against a landlord. Each of those times I needed one to screw it up by not hiring a lawyer could have cost me significant money. And in each case, by hiring one when I was in in the right, the lawyers delivered. And only the copyright suit was expensive to pay lawyers for - the rest would amount to a few months rent to obtain significantly more in return.

This is also the experience of a few friends I consult each time I weight "do I need a lawyer". So my experience is 100% the opposite of yours.

How many times have you used a lawyer for something and had your example happen? How many times have they not done what you claim? Care to share examples?

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by maccard on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:47PM (#29522752)
Ive had three legal advice experiences - two with work and one personal. The employer ones were both straightforward about whether or not we should do something, and they did not encourage us to keep returning to them on the issue, and the personal one the guy gave me a 30 minute phone call, advised me that if I wanted to formally pursue the matter I would need to engage his services at £200/hour, however his unofficial legal advice was to just proceed and not bother.

As another anecdote, my experience with developers is that developers will repeatedly tell you that the software isn't complete and requires extra attention to keep it running and to maintain it, and that it needs extra time for refactoring, despite it functioning correctly right now...

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by scrose on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:16PM (#29522967)
> my experience with developers is that developers will repeatedly tell you that the software isn't complete and requires extra attention to keep it running and to maintain it

Is that not true in most cases? A running system will eventually become vulnerable to attacks, and/or services it relies on may be deprecated. The last thing you want is to be in a situation where your software is easily exploitable, but your dependencies are so far behind that a fix becomes a multi-month or year long project.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by maccard on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:47AM (#29528822)
Yes, and im sure it's equally as true for lawyers too!
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ISL on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:45PM (#29522740)
It is essential to ask around for recommendations -- there are some great lawyers out there. When you need a good one, you may find yourself suddenly-surprised and grateful to be paying their (substantial) hourly rate.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:10PM (#29522434)
I have no skin in this game. I just have experience.

The outcome here could be that OP loses their domain name. If they just want to give it up, they don't have to hire an attorney. Easy answer.

But if they do want to keep the domain name, when paid opposing counsel comes knocking at the door, they need to lawyer up, plain and simple.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by cyral on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:37PM (#29522672)
Even if they want to give it up, the agreement will likely have representations and warranties (see part about any known/future claims) which OP should not just sign without an attorney reading it over. The agreement will surely be written in a way that is very favorable to the other party.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by gitfan86 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:32PM (#29522629)
It isn't that simple. The burden of proof and the cost of filing suit is entirely on the people who own the .net domain. You can't lose a domain based off of a threatening email.

I have received threaten letters before and have responded with "I dispute these claims. Please do not contact me again in any manner" and I never heard from them again.

I don't know enough about the company sending the threatening letter here, so I can't say if that would work or not here, but it is very possible you don't need a lawyer.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:35PM (#29522658)
> You can't lose a domain based off of a threatening email.

Indeed, but if you take no action at all, the opposing counsel does take action, and you don't contest the action, then the default outcome could be a forced transfer of the domain.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by gitfan86 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:48PM (#29522773)
So you agree that he doesn't need a lawyer at this junction. But if a lawsuit is filled, he will need to respond and request that the case be dismissed. Using a lawyer for that step isn't a bad idea.

They are going to have a hard time finding a case that set a precedent that you can take over another company's website because you registered a similar company 5 years later. Lookup nissan.com

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:54PM (#29522806)
This is not legal advice, but I don't recommend waiting until a suit is filed. Hiring counsel early and figuring out how to respond to the initial notice can be important: it might keep the courts out of the dispute altogether (especially if the other side is on very weak grounds) and might increase the settlement amount (if any) should OP choose to settle and transfer the domain.

There's more to this issue than just the naked law and legal procedure. Context matters, and experienced lawyers help you navigate situations. They're called "counsel" for a reason. :-)

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by gitfan86 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:47PM (#29523220)
But at what cost? 200/hour to navigate a situation that is easily winnable? Also if the other party knows that he has a lawyer they can use that to run up legal fees, making a settlement seem like the cheaper option.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:02PM (#29523322)
You are assuming "easily winnable" without knowledge of all the facts and the law. The whole reason to hire an attorney is to get an informed opinion about where you stand in the first place.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by gitfan86 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:13PM (#29523408)
You are assuming that one cannot access facts and the law without paying a lawyer.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by mfrye0 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#29523131)
This. While I respect lawyers immensely, I think half the battle is deciding when to use a lawyer vs handling it yourself.

With that said, this guy definitely needs to consult with a lawyer.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by spockz on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:15PM (#29522957)
Usually you have something like insurance for this. In Dutch it is called “rechtsbijstand” for private persons and pretty affordable. These are not necessarily the best lawyers obviously but they are backed by huge law firms. Probably the same exists for businesses but way more expensive.

So it doesn’t need to be expensive to request the support of a lawyer.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by mosselman on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:27PM (#29523036)
"Rechtsbijstand" is dependent on certain conditions. Amongst which a minimum amount of financial damage.

The "juridisch loket" is an organisation that provides free legal advice and is financed by the Dutch government. This is probably a better option in most cases.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by JohnHaugeland on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:43PM (#29523180)
> Spending $300-1000 on a consult

bruh consults are free, you're getting worked

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by prepend on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:25PM (#29524829)
There are free consults, but then you aren’t their client. Paying for an hours time gets a more detailed consult and makes you a client that gives me more meaningful iformation and also some “work.”
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by laurent123456 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:34PM (#29522642)
I don't know what's so special about law that it can never been discussed in any forum. You can certainly ask about other people's previous experience, possible advice or recommendations. For example for certain legal issues there are government websites that can help, etc. Saying "hire an attorney", as if it was no big deal to directly spend thousands without first asking around, is a bit strange.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by moksly on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:08PM (#29522912)
The advice sort of extends to any profession doesn’t it? Sometimes you can get good advice from strangers on social media, most times you probably shouldn’t risk anything on it though.

It’s sort of like Google programming isn’t it? I’m sure you’ll get it to work, but you hopefully wouldn’t do it if you were building medical software that could end up killing people. That’s when you pay the experts.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by zbuf on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:46PM (#29522749)
It also incorrectly assumes the purpose of a forum (this and many others) is to simply find the answer to the person's question.

For as long as people enjoy reading, writing and discussing, the only important thing is that readers can distinguish between "legal advice" and something some random person said on the internet.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by kingcharles on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:26PM (#29523034)
I've litigated dozens of cases on my own. Law isn't that complicated, especially for the smart people on here. You can often do a better job on your own simply because you have waaay more time to spend on the issue than a lawyer would. Plus you have skin in the game which makes you motivated in a way your lawyer will never be.

The flip side to that is that it is illegal in most states to give legal advice to someone unless you are a lawyer. You can give legal information, but not advice.

[Illinois once tried to prosecute me for the crime, so I have some experience]

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by rfrey on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:01PM (#29522870)
Person who charges $600/hour: "your only correct action is to hire a person who charges $600/hour."

Sorry for the snarkiness, but I'm continuously gobsmacked by how oblivious people, especially attorneys, can be to the fact that the Game of Justice as it is played in these parts is simply not accessible to the vast majority of people, who can only try to find another way to work around the system even if it's probably doomed to failure.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by harryvederci on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:09PM (#29522421)
You can add a layer in between: there are countries with a governmental institution[0] where you can go to for basic legal advice. They may point you to an attorney if needed, but for basic things they can give you advice themselves.

[0] Dutch example: "Het Juridisch Loket"

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by hedora on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:16PM (#29522485)
In the US, you can call your local bar association. They’ll generally find an appropriate lawyer, and charge a small amount for the initial consult/matchmaking.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ArtTimeInvestor on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:17PM (#29522495)
Bullshit.

Knowing your rights, reading the law and discussing it is a perfectly fine thing to do for everybody.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:38PM (#29522681)
> Knowing your rights, reading the law and discussing it is a perfectly fine thing to do for everybody.

Sure. I am a former law student (in mid career when I did that), worked in legislative office, spent a large part of my career as a government program analyst that did lots of legal/compliance analysis, and spend huge amounts of reading and discussing the law, legal rights, etc.

But when people have an immediate concrete legal problem with substantial property or other interests at stake, whatever other discussion of my understanding of the involved law involved might be interesting, the only correct advice in ~99.997% [0] of circumstances from anyone who is not a lawyer, or even just not the person involved’s lawyer on the matter, is to get someone who is your lawyer (at least for the length of a consultation) review and advise.

[0] there are situations where the practical context is such that the law and legal advice are irrelevant, though they are quite exceptional.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by jevoten on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:25PM (#29523487)
You act like getting informed on the law is somehow contrary to hiring a lawyer, which is especially bizarre, since most of the advice was phrased as "in my experience X is likely to happen, but you should consult with a lawyer".

Is it wrong to try to be informed of the law (when ignorance is rarely an excuse)? To find out what rights a trademark or a domain name confer? Or to list precedent and examples, such as nissan.com? We should just stick our heads in the sand, resign ourselves to total ignorance and helplessness, and let the lawyers do all the thinking?

Lets make this specific. Look at this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29522196

Are you saying every part of that comment, except for "This is probably not DIY territory; consult a lawyer knowledgable about trademark law to help you determine how to respond." is wrong?

For example, is the following statement wrong in the U.S.?

> Just like patents have a concept of "prior art," trademarks have a concept of "first use in commerce."

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by jksmith on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:02PM (#29522873)
Agree, just got a TM, and the journey was full of grey areas and few to zero xor solutions. For all the lawyer haters, the game is already rigged, so don't hate the player.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:24PM (#29522568)
> Every answer in this thread is wrong except for "hire an attorney and work with them to figure out what the best option for you is." Do not follow any "free legal advice" from HN -- and I'm speaking as an actual licensed attorney.

Speaking as a former law student that left because I got back into technology, and who is a fairly educated layman on the law but not someone with any financial interest in how people approach legal services, this.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ransom1538 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:35PM (#29522651)
Do not respond to the letter. Do not engage. Do not alter your website. Do not hire a lawyer. The fastest way to enter into a legal battle is to hire an attorney and start engaging.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by dtech on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:38PM (#29522682)
Seems like an excellent way to lose your domain in a default judgement
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by Ancapistani on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:08PM (#29522914)
A default judgement requires that a case be filed. In the US, that means they have to serve you notice of the case.

Obviously they have the OP's address, so if they fail to serve him the judgement should be easy enough to set aside.

I'd do absolutely nothing in this circumstance until and unless they actually initiate a legal proceeding. If they did sue for the domain, depending on the value of brand I probably lawyer up, and perhaps seriously consider counter-suing them for both their domain and the use of the business name itself.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ransom1538 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:47PM (#29522761)
"Strictly speaking, a cease and desist letter is not legally binding because the recipient can choose to ignore it. However, it is a valid legal document that establishes a precedent of a plaintiff's grievance. Usually, the letter sets a time limit for the recipient to comply with the request to desist from the offending action — or deliver an appropriate response if they believe the letter was sent in error."

Take the letter. Delete it. Engaging is the fastest way to lose the domain. Their Lawyers want you to engage and start making written statements. Don't.

"Seems like an excellent way to lose your domain in a default judgement"

Lol. Don't ignore legal paperwork or court dates, which this isn't.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:21PM (#29522995)
This is not legal advice, but I don't recommend waiting until a suit is filed. Hiring counsel early and figuring out how to respond to the initial notice can be important: it might keep the courts out of the dispute altogether (especially if the other side is on very weak grounds) and might increase the settlement amount (if any) should OP choose to settle and transfer the domain.

There's more to this issue than just the naked law and legal procedure. Context matters, and experienced lawyers help you navigate situations. They're called "counsel" for a reason. :-)

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ransom1538 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:28PM (#29523511)
Reminds me of my favorite lawyer youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgWHrkDX35o
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by dt3ft on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:09PM (#29522922)
Of course an attorney would tell you to hire an attorney.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by chiefalchemist on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:00PM (#29522857)
Can't up vote this enough.

1) This is an ex co-worker . I believe she's well versed in such things. I get nothing for this mention.

https://kinneyfirm.com/

2) That said, one of the keys to trademark is being in the same industry, such that the public might get confused.

Apple Computer striking a deal with Apple Records, once the former started to sell music, is a good example. Prior to that, there was no (legal or market) overlap of the two.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by daveevad on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:22PM (#29523008)
One thing I noticed during the Get Back Beatles Documentary recently released, is that Apple Records was a subsidiary of Apple Corps. The Beatles' Apple had much bolder ambitions than I had realized. In the film, they discussed movies and performances under the Apple umbrella.

John Lennon himself described it as: "we've got this thing called 'Apple' which is going to be records, films, and electronics – which all tie up."

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by mlyle on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:42PM (#29523170)
> 2) That said, one of the keys to trademark is being in the same industry, such that the public might get confused.

Note that this is generally true for trademark law, but there are things like the ICANN/WIPO UDRP that can be used to expropriate domain names that have somewhat of a different standard.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by rvba on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:34PM (#29522647)
People tell to hire a lawyer, yet at same time hundreds of programmers copy snippets of code they dont understand, or use libraries unaudited by anyone
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by throwaway2048 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:59PM (#29522847)
That says more about the profession of "Programmer" vs "Lawyer" than it does about some imagined hypocrisy.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by ISL on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:48PM (#29522764)
Sometimes doing so yields an RCE, dealing substantial damage to both a company and its counterparties.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by oauea on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:49AM (#29522232)
> and I'm speaking as an actual licensed attorney.

and so the racket continues

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by jacoblambda on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:12PM (#29522454)
This is the equivalent of a doctor saying "if you think you have cancer, don't blindly listen to the internet and consult a doctor and I say that as a licensed medical professional".

This isn't someone trying to rope someone into a racket for their own gain, it's "Our laws and legal system are a clusterfuck that varies wildly from region to region. Get a free (or at least cheap) consult instead of taking a risk trying to navigate this yourself".

There is no situation in which it is worthwhile to take the risk to try and navigate that clusterfuck yourself. Spend the 50USD or so and the hour of your time it'll cost at most to get a consult and go from there. At best you can get something out of this whole interaction but at worst if you don't consult a lawyer you can end up without the domain, without any money from selling the domain, and saddled with legal fees defending a lawsuit against you.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by will4274 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:42PM (#29522709)
Except that it isn't cancer. It's a headache. And sure, WebMD will tell you to call a doctor in case your headache is a blood clot. But most people just take aspirin.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by codingdave on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:54AM (#29522283)
Exactly. Licensed attorney's typically avoid any commentary at all that could be construed as advice, to avoid creating a relationship. So if someone is sticking their neck out, it is hard to imagine there isn't an ulterior motive in telling everyone to lawyer up when they get a letter.

Not that their advice is wrong - you should consult a lawyer over internet advice. But the "everyone else is wrong, listen to me" flavor is a bit heavy-handed.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:05PM (#29522386)
I'm being heavy-handed here because 20 years ago, before I was a lawyer, I was sued, failed to hire counsel in time, and unnecessarily lost my shirt as a result. I don't want the same thing to happen to OP.

Legal questions come up on HN from time to time and the usual response is a bunch of wannabe lawyers incorrecting one another, and if OP follows any of their advice, Bad Things could result. I spoke up early this time in what was perhaps a foolish attempt to short-circuit this.

No competent attorney is going to give legal advice here -- money aside -- because they would be violating their professional ethics code by doing so. Giving legal advice requires knowing facts at a very detailed level (the degree to which is rarely found in the post), knowing the laws in the jurisdiction(s), and having relationships and experience. Not to mention attorney-client confidentiality, and other reasons.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by sdoering on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:19PM (#29522983)
Thanks for being a voice of reason.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:05PM (#29522895)
Whether or not you, or anyone else, believes, and / or can demonstrate, the current state of society and legal systems is a racket, doesn’t magic away the problem of a potential default judgement.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by zoe4883 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:01PM (#29522347)
This sort of looks like template document. An actual attorney would send paper letter, not an email.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:06PM (#29522393)
False. C&D letters are sent via email all the time.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by hedora on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:22PM (#29522546)
This is a great reason to ensure your mail client doesn’t auto-download embedded images, send read receipts, etc.

No reason to tip your hand until a lawyer tells you to. For instance, the last time I dealt with a lawyer, they had me send responses directly, in hopes the other side would underestimate our position. It worked, fwiw.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by reaperducer on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:26PM (#29522582)
False. C&D letters are sent via email all the time.

Millions of Americans don't have e-mail. They're just on social media. What then?

That's why important things are always sent by mail. Very important things by certified mail.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:29PM (#29522604)
That's irrelevant for this issue. Domain holders have to provide working email addresses as a condition of registration, and are reminded annually to keep their addresses up to date.

If an email address can't be found, the correspondence can be delivered through other means if necessary (mail, process server, etc.). But generally, there has no longer been a need to waste paper and postage to deliver notices since email became practically ubiquitous.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by m3047 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:49PM (#29523674)
IANAL but I am an internet plumber. Happy to provide expert witness that e.g. Hover, owned by Tucows, has a toggle for whois in their domain admin dashboard but it does nothing: I cannot turn whois on even if I want to.

Having, or publishing, an email address does not mean I care to, choose to, or will in fact receive email sent by you; or that I will display or treat it in the fashion you desire.

Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by zrobotics on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:07PM (#29522902)
They may not check their email, but how is anyone on social media without email? I'm not aware of a single social site that doesn't require an email address to create an account.
Re:Ask HN: Own .com for 7 years, a new company trademarked m... by otterley on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:14PM (#29522954)
I believe all of them allow the use of a mobile phone number as an alternative.