News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by msandford on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:20PM (#29512555)
Core inflation excludes food and energy. So as long as you're dead, you only experience core inflation! Everyone else who is alive is exposed to core inflation and also the one that takes food and fuel into account. Perhaps that's why people don't "buy" the numbers. Because the numbers aren't representative of the reality that alive human beings experience.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by deltree7 on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:35PM (#29512800)
Core Inflation is needed so that they can apply the right monetary policy. If you want your 'personal' inflation, they have data for that too.

Fed releases all kinds of data (unemployment and monetary) and is pretty transparent.

It is disingenuous of you (and contributing to the erosion of institutional trust of Federal institution) by falsely accusing them.

Federal agencies aren't perfect, but at least educated people in HN should take the responsibility of giving constructive criticism based on facts rather than being brainwashed by random YouTuber/Blogger who is generally clueless about economics

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by d4mi3n on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:45PM (#29512954)
Still waking up and it's possible I misread GP, but their comments didn't seem disingenuous on my reading. It's healthy to be skeptical of something that varies that much from one's personal experience. Your reply about data available for personal inflation was exactly the kind of information they needed to verify if the underlying data matches their personal experience.

I understand the sensitivity to folks spouting "fake news", but let's not discourage critical thinking in a time where there is precious little to go around.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by RC_ITR on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:49PM (#29513030)
It's NOT healthy to assume you're the 'average' when you are not.

Almost no one on HN is reflective of the 'average' American and that lack of understanding is part of the reason the poor suffer so much in policy decisioning.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by d4mi3n on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:03PM (#29513231)
I don't know enough to comment on "healthiness" of assumptions about ones' self and where they fit into analysis like in the OP's link. My commentary is purely on how we communicate with each other in a time where divisiveness, misinformation, and polarization are common and pervasive.

It's hard, but if we want to have productive discussions we need to treat each other with empathy and talk to the best possible interpretation of each other's arguments. This assumes people are coming to a dialog in good faith, but everything needs to start with a little trust somewhere. Trolls are also not too hard to spot.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by mcguire on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:02PM (#29514025)
For example...

The median salary for software developers in 2019 in the US was $107,000, with 50% between $82,000 and $136,000. The mean salary in California was $134,000 and the mean in San Francisco was $145,000. (https://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/software-develope...)

The median household income in the US in 2019 was $69,560 with a 90% confidence interval of <$1000. The "median earnings of all workers aged 15 and over with earnings" in 2019 was $42,065. (FWIW, the median household income for black people in 2020 was $46,000, and for Asian people was $95,000.) The median household income of those with no college education was $47,000, some college was $64,000, and at least a bachelors degree was $107,000. (https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2021/demo/p60-27...)

(The median household income in California in 2019 was $78,000.)

The median salary for software developers individually in 2019 therefore puts them in the highest 40% of households. (In 2019, 1/5th of households made less than $28,000, 2/5 made less than $54,000, 3/5 made less than $86,000, and 4/5 made less than $143,000. 95% made less than $270,000.)

For many of the people frequenting HN, this is your mileage in the act of varying.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by deeviant on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:17PM (#29514964)
If you want productive discussions that you need to enter them in a good faith.

Building an argument based on personal anecdotes and applying it to national policy not good faith. Science literally exists to limit subjective bias and to separate actual trends in reality from notions in your head, subjective experience basically worthless for understanding large-scale trends.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday December 10, 2021 @06:55PM (#29516952)
It's always alarming to me to see how many people on HN don't acknowledge the bubble they're in.

If you're a well-paid engineer, and nearly everyone you interact with is a well-paid engineer, you're going to think everyone lives like you.

And I wonder how many of them grew up poor. And I mean, poor as in "half my meals as a kid were rice and beans", not "One time my dad didn't get the bonus he was expecting, so we had to fly coach rather than First Class when we to France during Christmas".

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by RC_ITR on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:48PM (#29555608)
Questioning the BLS data without being able to explain how the data is collected and analyzed is not a way to fight misinformation, it's a way to encourage it.

If OP had made some more detailed arguments, like 'the methods for imputing homeowners rent seem biased' or 'it seems disingenuous to keep a static weighting during COVID, despite the major observed shift away from services and to goods' then I would love to engage on that.

But randomly saying 'this EXTREMELY transparent dataset seems fishy' is just encouraging people to 'do their own research' on things they have no expertise in.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by sdsaga12 on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:25PM (#29513529)
"In 1996, five economists, known as the Boskin Commission, were tasked with saving the government $1 trillion. They observed that if the CPI were lowered by 1.1 percent, then a $1 trillion could indeed be saved over the coming decade. So what did they do? They proposed a way to alter the formula that would lower the CPI by exactly that amount!

This raises a question: Is economics being used as science or as after-the-fact justification, much like economic statistics were manipulated in the Soviet Union? More importantly, is anyone paying attention? Are we willing to give government agents a free hand to keep changing this all-important formula whenever it suits their political needs, simply because they think we won’t get the math?"

This was written by Edward Frenkel, a math professor at UC Berkeley who was born in the USSR in 1968 and so, we can assume, had some familiarity with statistical games played by regimes trying to hold onto power.

I invite you consider that you might extend too much faith toward federal institutions that have presided over a ceaseless rise in inequality and erosion of rights in recent decades.

https://slate.com/technology/2013/02/should-algebra-be-in-cu...

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by ChrisLomont on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:14PM (#29514169)
>This was written by Edward Frenkel

And he is not an economist, yet he is a well known econ crank.

Here's an actual economist [1], looking at the evidence one decade past the Boskin report - concludes the same thing.

And, the really cool thing about inflation over that length of time, is you can check it for yourself (which I have showing people why ShadowStats is complete nonsense).

Get some old ads from the start of the period (say 1996, the year of the Boskin Report), and look at prices. Put them in excel. Do the same for now. Compute a reasonable basket.

And here is the really neat part - see if the BLS reported CPI over that period matches reality, or if adding 1.1% annually matches reality.

I will spoil the result - BLS is correct.

From the CPI calculator, Jan 1996 to Jan 2021, inflation is a 1.69 multiplier, for an annual rate of 2.12%. Add back the supposed 1.1%, take the 3.22% over the same 25 years, get a 2.21 multiplier, quite a difference.

And, for the record, there are lots of other places tracing inflation, like the Billion Prices Project, that reach the same conclusions. If the govt lied about it, there would be awesome arbitrage opportunity (and like all such things, people have even investigated that - no such lies - papers on Arxiv).

[1] https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w12311/w123...

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by SpelingBeeChamp on Friday December 10, 2021 @10:32PM (#29518161)
What awesome arbitrage opportunity would exist if the government was understating inflation?
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by ChrisLomont on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:12AM (#29520338)
Google any inflation linked asset, from bonds, ETFs, swaps, all sorts of derivatives. If you know inflation is consistently wrong, all such things are mispriced. Then it's simple to hedge against non inflation versions of the same, or buy derivatives constructed against them, to extract the risk free difference.

If you dig around you'll find finance papers measuring such things, demonstrating no one has found any such exploitable gaps. Plenty of groups try.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by sdsaga12 on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:25PM (#29516196)
Thanks for the thoughtful reply. Will take a look
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by praxulus on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:19PM (#29514251)
>In 1996, five economists, known as the Boskin Commission, were tasked with saving the government $1 trillion. They observed that if the CPI were lowered by 1.1 percent, then a $1 trillion could indeed be saved over the coming decade. So what did they do? They proposed a way to alter the formula that would lower the CPI by exactly that amount!

I know this is a direct quote from a Slate article, but it's a blatant lie. The commission was officially the "Advisory Commission to Study the Consumer Price Index", i.e. it's founding purpose was to evaluate the accuracy of the CPI, not an open-ended mission to save the government money.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by serverholic on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:00PM (#29513988)
This is why cryptocurrency was invented. Satoshi even signed a statement about government bailouts in the first bitcoin transaction.

The truth is that the game is rigged. Like entropy, government power always increases over a long enough timeframe. Anytime the spotlight is shined on government they manipulate the game or blame corporations. Then they introduce regulation to "protect" citizens but these regulations add up to just keeping big business entrenched.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by stjohnswarts on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:08PM (#29515472)
Satoshi doesn't get any credit for stating what people have been stating literally for decades before "he" came along. Let's not give him credit for anything other than the bitcoin algorithm.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by serverholic on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:26PM (#29515643)
I think you misread my statement. The first bitcoin block literally had a political statement embedded into it. That's all I'm pointing out.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by bko on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#29513015)
> It is disingenuous of you (and contributing to the erosion of institutional trust of Federal institution) by falsely accusing them.

There are trillions of dollars tied to these inflation numbers. Many social services are tied to these values. So if an agency could get reported inflation down just a few basis points based on their subjective decisions on what to include and what to substitute, that could save the government billions.

That's not saying that they are necessarily doing that, but its wise to be suspicious when there are such large stakes

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by cheriot on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:01PM (#29513200)
That suspicion should motivate people to educate themselves before pushing conspiracies. Public debate needs a core set of facts to reason about the world so politicizing BLS numbers is... really bad.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by bko on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:14PM (#29514182)
That suspicion should motivate people to think about the incentives they're setting for government agencies and try to create clear objective measures that cannot be gamed.

> Public debate needs a core set of facts to reason about the world so politicizing BLS numbers is... really bad

When it becomes tied to trillions and the agencies are selected by politicians then its by definition political.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by cheriot on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:59PM (#29516526)
> create clear objective measures that cannot be gamed

There is no perfect world where nothing can be gamed. We have a respected institution in the BLS and setting an impossible bar only promotes misinformation by discrediting what's credible.

> the agencies are selected by politicians

This is why there are specific roles for political appointees and others for career civil servants.

In this specific case, we're talking about the usual noise of someone not understanding the point of core inflation, not knowing that there are other measures of inflation, and jumping to a conclusion that the numbers must be bogus. Regardless of what you think about inflation numbers, the reasoning was bad.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by orhmeh09 on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#29513009)
None of us posting here has any responsibility to upholding the trust of federal institutions, which have already been eroded far more than one could do on HN by both parties to hold power.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by heurisko on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:10PM (#29513325)
> Core Inflation is needed so that they can apply the right monetary policy. If you want your 'personal' inflation, they have data for that too.

Why does applying the right monetary policy depend on excluding inflation in food and energy?

Edit: answered by dragontamer

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by deltree7 on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:03PM (#29514029)
There are two kinds of inflation

1) Increase in prices because of increase in money supply

2) Increase in prices because of supply shocks (weather, strikes, supply chain, disruption) or unusual spiky demand.

Core CPI is an attempt to measure (1) to ensure the money supply, which the fed controls is at balance (with their other mandate of full employment).

It's a hard problem because there are lot of nuances and still we want to measure the same thing for a fair MoM or YoY comparison.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by SilasX on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:05PM (#29514050)
Really? They don't want to track the inflation that results from the new money just being buried in stocks and real estate for safekeeping? Isn't that an indicator they're printing too much?
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by stjohnswarts on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:05PM (#29515450)
All I know is my favorite Taco Bell meal is up 20% year-over-year
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by dragontamer on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:22PM (#29512577)
Core inflation is a different measure because food and gasoline prices vary so much.

Its not about withholding information. Its about aggregating the important bits together.

With a 60% rise in gasoline prices in the past year, it makes sense why you'd want to track gasoline separately from everything else.

-------

If you want to just track "everything", then quote "CPI", not "core CPI" (a different number entirely).

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by jdavis703 on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:28PM (#29512686)
I don’t drive, I’m mostly on a plant-based diet, and I’ve been on 100% renewable energy for years. I’m very much alive, and also am willing to believe we’re not close to double digit inflation based on my costs.

And I live in one of those high-priced metros, so I actually experienced a rent cut since everyone fled to Miami and Austin (thereby increasing prices there).

Obviously your experience may be different, but remember econometrics tracks the entire economy, not just your budget.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by newbamboo on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:02PM (#29513220)
“ experienced a rent cut since everyone fled to Miami and Austin ”

Obviously not in a California metro where the state decided to subsidize rents to compensate for preventing evictions resulting in a windfall for landlords and massive rent increases throughout the state.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by dpe82 on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:15PM (#29513386)
I experienced a significant rent reduction in San Francisco this year.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by klipklop on Friday December 10, 2021 @06:45PM (#29516893)
Check the rent for the places that SF'ers fled to. Your rent went down because a bunch of affluent people left and opened up a bunch of units.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by dpe82 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:29PM (#29523517)
Right; the point is that rent did not universally increase.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by vntok on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:36PM (#29512814)
> I’m mostly on a plant-based diet, and I’ve been on 100% renewable energy for years

Do you believe that your way of living is representative of the average American's?

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by seoaeu on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:51PM (#29513057)
That's the thing, there is no one "average" American that this inflation number applies to! It aggregates over all of them, including the ones living on plant-based diets and using 100% renewable energy
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by iso1631 on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:35PM (#29513666)
The average american has 1 breast and 1 testicle. The term "Average American" tend to be used by people claiming to talk on behalf of them, without actually doing so (given that the "Average American" is as different from the "Average American" as everyone else)
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by dgfitz on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:55PM (#29513927)
If we’re being pedantic, less than one breast and less than one testicle. As well as less then 2 arms and less than 2 legs.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by stephencanon on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:53PM (#29513080)
It's exactly as representative as any other American's is. That's the nature of an average--everyone's contribution factors equally.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by martingoodson on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:20PM (#29513457)
The consumer price index does include food and energy. It's in the main table of the post we are discussing. It's not clear why you are not 'buying' them.

  Food......................    .4    .8    .7    .4    .9    .9    .7      6.1

  Energy....................    .0   1.5   1.6   2.0   1.3   4.8   3.5     33.3
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by ravenstine on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:33PM (#29512761)
Ding ding ding!

What we need is tools that help individuals plug in their budget and track how inflation affects them. These overall inflation figures are pretty much useless because they have to exclude information in order to not be too highly amplified in either direction. Creating a budget of how much I typically spend on food, gas, utilities, and such and being able to backtest that budget would be really helpful, and perhaps that data could be used to crowdsource inflation figures that are more representative of what the average person is actually experiencing.

Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by lottin on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:04PM (#29516008)
Inflation is not the same thing as cost of living. Inflation measures changes in the price level, while cost of living is the expenditure that is needed to sustain a particular standard of living.
Re:Inflation rises to 6.8% year over year by bee_rider on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:34PM (#29512779)
Which is crazy -- you could track my food intake and lack of energy expenditure to easily derive my core inflation.