News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by lmm on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:31AM (#29507022)
But is there any case where you'd actually trust a pile of blockchains more than an existing trust mechanism (whether that's neighbourliness, contract law, or something else)? If you're not a programmer, getting a programmer to review your smart contract probably costs more than getting a lawyer to review your regular contract. If you are a programmer, you probably know better than to rely on some code being bug-free.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by pengwing on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:32AM (#29507027)
The irony of course being that you would have to fully trust the programmer who reviews your contract.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by js4ever on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:28AM (#29507359)
Even if you trust the programmer, and even if he is competent he might still miss a very complex edge case ... and since there is no court / jury to take a human decision, you can be totally screwed.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by biztos on Friday December 10, 2021 @09:57AM (#29510591)
Even worse (better?) no sane programmer is going to sign a real-world contract guaranteeing the code is bug-free, and if you trust the wrong programmer to work on your complex blockchain program they might put in a sufficiently complex exploitable code path, and be first in line to (anonymously) exploit it.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by ahussain on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:37AM (#29507405)
Hmm, we already trust programmers enough to design our cryptography (hash functions and such)
Re:Is Web3 anything? by laserbeam on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:44AM (#29507453)
With millions of dollars being stolen from various smart contracts every other week... No, I don't trust those programmers.

Designing hash/crypto functions is a very different story than implementing contracts. You would need to know basically 0 of the math that would be needed to implement a hash function.

Re:Is Web3 anything? by soulofmischief on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:36AM (#29508110)
Would you trust them if programmers you did trust trusted them? A developer web of trust? An example of this would be followers/stars/forks on GitHub.

Maybe there is room for a distributed service which specifically enables this trust you're looking for?

Re:Is Web3 anything? by tomp on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:30PM (#29514389)
Now you have to trust the lawyer that created your contract, as well as the court that might enforce it.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by onion2k on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:26AM (#29507351)
You don't have to trust a single developer if you pay multiple independent reviewers though. If you paid a bonus for finding problems you could even incentivize their honesty.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by Jyaif on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:42AM (#29508154)
Note that if the bonus is less than what the reviewers would gain from using the exploit, then they are not fully incentivised to be honest.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by gorgoiler on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:19AM (#29507653)
This idea of a legal bug is interesting.

It feels like The United States unofficial 0th amendment is the enshrined concept of getting off on a technicality. It comes with the territory with a written constitution.

OJ, sexual relations with that woman, Capone’s unpaid parking tickets, hanging chads… or anything heard by the Supreme Circus.

A huge part of the legal system, or at least the part that goes to trial, is exploiting the equivalent of bugs in the legal code.

Re:Is Web3 anything? by tmoravec on Friday December 10, 2021 @06:36AM (#29508707)
Another way to think of "legal bugs" is corruption.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by objectivetruth on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:12PM (#29513347)
Respectfully disagree -- these examples are mostly how the system is supposed to work to protect the rights of the individual.

OJ was found not guilty by a jury of his peers who felt there was reasonable doubt to his guilt. Sure, to the vast majority of us, he obviously did it and skated, but I'd guess there are 100 or 1000 non-publicized cases of an innocent person getting railroaded for every OJ.

Clinton paid a massive political price for his weasel language and related evasions, and some people think that price included Gore's loss of the Presidency in 2000.

Capone was brought down for unpaid taxes, not parking tickets, and that was as a result of a federal task force brought about following years of incredible gangland violence in Chicago.

I wouldn't call these bugs.

Re:Is Web3 anything? by mattwilsonn888 on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:02AM (#29507557)
Have you ever heard of a better use case for clamped down functional languages? The only issue with crypto right now is how infantile it is - that's what most critiques boil down to (especially on this site). Any long term speculator is happy to see it, so long as they see the same problems the forever skeptics see but with a dash of optimism rather than arrogance.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by classified on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:34AM (#29508092)
Ah, the solution to all of mankind's problems is so simple, really. (Where have we heard that one before?) Technology can solve all problems in human society, just be optimistic! Also, you'll get rich quick.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by nathias on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:36AM (#29507401)
In the case of smart-contracts you at least have the possibility of knowing, with existing trust mechanisms this is impossible.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by lmm on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:55AM (#29507514)
You can't ever be 100% certain - even if you analysed the smart contract completely correctly, there's always the possibility of an ethereum-style hard fork to change what your contract means. So you have to ask how confident you can actually be in whichever style of contract in practice.
Re:Is Web3 anything? by nathias on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:58AM (#29508224)
sure, nothing is perfect, but its a considerable improvement