Re:Is Web3 anything?
by pengwing on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:32AM
(#29507027)
The irony of course being that you would have to fully trust the programmer who reviews your contract.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Even if you trust the programmer, and even if he is competent he might still miss a very complex edge case ... and since there is no court / jury to take a human decision, you can be totally screwed.
Even worse (better?) no sane programmer is going to sign a real-world contract guaranteeing the code is bug-free, and if you trust the wrong programmer to work on your complex blockchain program they might put in a sufficiently complex exploitable code path, and be first in line to (anonymously) exploit it.
Hmm, we already trust programmers enough to design our cryptography (hash functions and such)
With millions of dollars being stolen from various smart contracts every other week... No, I don't trust those programmers.
Designing hash/crypto functions is a very different story than implementing contracts. You would need to know basically 0 of the math that would be needed to implement a hash function.
Re:Is Web3 anything?
by soulofmischief on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:36AM
(#29508110)
Would you trust them if programmers you did trust trusted them? A developer web of trust? An example of this would be followers/stars/forks on GitHub.
Maybe there is room for a distributed service which specifically enables this trust you're looking for?
Now you have to trust the lawyer that created your contract, as well as the court that might enforce it.
You don't have to trust a single developer if you pay multiple independent reviewers though. If you paid a bonus for finding problems you could even incentivize their honesty.