Just because there's an entire consulting industry behind convincing you that to build the perfect team you must have "complementary personality types", does not mean it's true.
Not like the IT industry has the luxury of choice based on such a lot of the time either.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26288772
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers%E2%80%93Briggs_Type_Indi...
It's a horoscope for smart people, with slightly more utility.
Well, I guess there's the issue. You think there's very little value in it. I think there's much more than you do, though I agree it's certainly a subjective measure. I say that any of the 3 archetypes that you might "test out" as would give a potential manager some measure of useful context in predicting how you will respond/react to various situations and people, despite criticism of the accuracy of the system.
You can be data-driven or sentiment-driven, but not both.
You can favor disciplined structure, or you can favor creative chaos, but not both.
You can favor generalists, or specialists, but not both.
You can favor ambition or humility, but not both.
But companies will gladly tell you they have room for diverse personalities, and only after being there a number of weeks, months, or sometimes years, will the untruth of that scenario hit you.
I might have lost few opportunities because of this but that was my choice.
See this article for a summary of the criticisms: https://www.vox.com/2014/7/15/5881947/myers-briggs-personali...
And there are a LOT of people that are awful at introspection.
People rely on these things to make hiring decisions. I personally know people who hire based on reported personality that closely matches their own. I’ve seen people making biased opinions after being coached on these tests.
“No scientific backing, Makes people rely on confirmation bias” should be plastered all over these things, just the way we label cigarettes with photos of smoking consequences.
Also even if people answer honestly the science behind it is very shaky and when applied to real world situations it seems about as useful as astrology.
('Scandanavians are the best employees' perhaps, based on this thread..! But that aside.)
Hiring is hard. People are complicated. Trying to reduce them a couple of letters or a number is hogwash.
I guess thats one of those local idiosyncrasies
Unless you've ever independently (non-circularly) corroborated your 'idea of how smart someone is', my guess is that it just serves as a proxy for qualities like academic education (which != intelligence), social class, similarity to yourself, &c.
For the record, hiring is hard, no company seems to have got it right. Think IQ tests probably says more than someone being forced to nervously scribble down bubble sort on blackboard or estimating how many water melons there are in pakistan. None of these obviously says anything compared to working with someone for a week.
edit: People are different, if it was as simple as evaluating a conversation it wouldn't be a very hard problem.
The problem is that these tests do not sell themselves as "just one data point", and even if they did, you'd have to do so many other things to compensate for the shortcomings of standardized IQ tests, they're really not worth doing in the first place.
IMO the best way to assess fit is to ask someone to handle a hypothetical, or to ask for previous experiences fitting a problem or situation.
(And I would refuse to pick a candidate based on one number. No good can come of this.)
I definitely do NOT want tests of ANY kind to be the norm, but if I'm forced to find a "fit", then I try to take myself out of the picture and balance the team instead. I respectfully reject the idea that this is similar to "measuring skulls" (a comment in the thread).
Thanks for pointing that out. Hopefully I made myself clearer now.
> Sometimes they talk so much about fit fit fit, but they don't even bother with a personality or IQ test (which as a former hiring manager, I find very valuable because it allows you to balance the team, not because you see how high/low people score).
Just for reference, if an employer ever asks me to perform an IQ test I'm definitely walking away.