From the perspective of people who don't like aspects of Rust, it's a yucky goo.
This is _not_ like with C. Few people are enamored with C, but - the language itself is relatively simple (Duff's device notwithstanding...), so in my analogy it's like water. You may not adore it, but you can see through it, and you'll be ok with gulping it down to quench your thirst.
I beg to differ. This is exactly how I feel about C. C is the language that's confusing as hell to read for anything other than really simple use cases AND makes it super easy for me to shoot myself in the foot.
This is also possible for C. Most commonly around Undefined Behaviour. C only does what you expect it to do if you know the C spec inside out. Rust can have confusing behaviour too, but it is generally much better in this regard than C or C++.
You may find it easier to reason about C than Rust, but that's only because you know C better. I find it much easier to reason about Rust.
Know thy standard and thy compiler optmizations, least you be surprised by the outcome.
if you don't use pointers, yeah. but like you can't built anything useful without pointers.
It's a question of whether unguarded pointers (and a lack of language features that keep pointer math from devolving into an unreadable mess) are good to have in areas where pointer errors can result in critical bugs. We started discouraging goto statements not because developers didn't understand them, but because they did understand them, and they understood that the tools you use influence the type of code you write. And Rust doesn't even really get rid of pointers, it just adds rules around them.
We all accept some degree of abstraction/safety tradeoff, otherwise we'd program in lower-level languages than C that are even simpler and even easier to understand. C does introduce a lot of complexity over more primitive assembly languages. And Rust introduces a lot of complexity over C.
Different people pick different points where they think the tradeoffs are optimized. But we have a pretty large amount of data suggesting that even <quote>good</quote> programmers in industry make pointer errors in C. So it's pretty obviously not lack of understanding that's causing these issues, it's that unrestricted memory access and pointer math is inherently error-prone. Whether it's SO error-prone that's it's worth introducing a much more complicated, rigid language into the kernel is left as an exercise for the reader. There is a downside to introducing more complexity here, all abstractions have downsides.
But it's real dismissive to say that if everyone understood C pointers then their code wouldn't ever devolve into an unreadable mess. I just don't think that's an opinion that can be backed up by any real evidence, pretty much every org struggles to some extent with writing secure C code. And we have a lot of experience in the field of software engineering that should have taught us by now that sometimes unreadable code is the result of language affordances and patterns.
My wild guess is that most "simple" pointer errors (use-after-free, double-free, unintentionally using unitialized memory, ...) happens at interfaces where there isn't perfect comunication about what component is responsible for keeping track of each task.
> "Most bugs are a result of the execution state not being exactly what you think it is."
There is an aspect of language design that is about making it hard to be surprised by things. And I vaguely suspect that a lot of pointer errors fall into this category; people assume something is being freed, they assume that a subroutine is cleaning up after itself or that it's not manipulating something, or that it doesn't need to call some setup method before it's run. These are boundary errors between interfaces where allowing users to (inadvertently) mask what is happening can lead to logic that feels very convoluted and hard to follow, and can also lead to simple errors around just forgetting to do stuff.
I wouldn't call that Carmack quote a mantra, I'm not saying it explains all programming (or that all architectural restrictions are good), it's just a lens that I keep coming back to when I think about language design and architecture; there's a real tradeoff in removing flexibility, but there is also a huge amount of value in systems/patterns that make it very hard to bury relevant information. And if a language can auto-surface some of those problems, that can lead to cleaner code.
The time scales with the compiled unit size. If you're compiling drivers/modules, they're going to be fairly small and not much slower than C.
one of the biggest hurdles for me was the DTB declarative language. that was the most stupid idea ever to invent that and i lost 100s of hours trying to get my DTB files right for my hardware. so you can understand i don’t want more hipster shit to deal with.
Also at this point, Rust isn't "hipster shit". You're just not familiar with it, and that's fine. But it's in wide use now and proven to solve major classes of recurring issues.
Yes. Rust helps with that because as a language it simplifies avoiding huge classes of vulnerabilities.
Rust simplifies it for the developers by moving part of the mental model of the developer into the compiler.
Of course you need to know what you are doing still, but pretending humans don't make mistakes even when they know what they are doing is ignoring reality.
And those drivers can continue to be written in C. Rust is merely an option.
Sometimes I feel like C's compiler is almost adversarial, going out of its way to find small mistakes in my code and have them blow in my face at runtime instead of notifying me. I understand why it works that way of course, but usually when my Rust code compiles, it works. I can't say as much for my C code, despite nearly 20 years of practice.
I do share some of your frustrations with the DTB thing, I'm not a fan of it either, although something like that was needed and I'm sure any alternative would have its haters.
No matter your skill level, that won't stop you from committing memory-safety mistakes that may lurk for years until they suddenly result in a catastrophic failure. Evidence for that is abundant.
I'm sure it gets better as you memorize the millions of different types, but what benefit do you get from all this pain?
I also think it's just a boy's club at this point. Big pipe dreams of rewriting all the C++ and C code is all we here about. It's not going to happen. The language is too f*k*g hard to learn so no one will. It's like trying to make everything in Haskell, c'mon, get real.
Someone had to say it...
I don't think I've experienced this in any language, even ones with the most expressive type systems. More typing is better, as far as I have experienced, and as far as I have heard from people who take it up in their projects.
The compiler will tell you exactly what goes wrong if you pass the wrong type. If you mean that type inference was confusing, it's the same as `auto` in C++. Except the Rust compiler does an enormous amount of handholding with errors, often showing you exactly how to correct your code.
Probably mostly because of that.
Not that the other points are necessarily easy to follow since they're not well explained. If knowledge of why some type was hard to know or had to be googled (or for example noting what one of those types is) was presented, then people might have been able to respond to those points.
Instead it reads as "it's hard, I used it and it's hard, and I had to do some stuff I didn't like, and so my impression is it's just a bunch of people faffing off and it's too hard to take seriously", which isn't really useful for a discussion, and additionally is dismissive. Every one of the criticisms presented could be said about C without any change because no actual concrete details are provided.
It's not like Rust is perfect, there are many valid criticisms of it that have real examples and make useful points. Those comments probably deserve your defense more than this one.
The main drawback of Rust here I think is the longer compile times (I dread to imagine how long a fully Rustified kernel would take to build) and a generally more complex, but also more expressive language.
More generally I trust the kernel maintainers not to succumb to the hype and overdo it. People who still exchange patchsets over mailing lists are probably unlikely to be blinded by shiny things.