News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by jmole on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:17PM (#29463488)
of all the things to bounce off the moon, why a consumer IoT protocol?

Alien 1: The humans are talking again. Alien 2: What did they say? Alien 1: The front door is locked.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by mcpherrinm on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:23PM (#29463548)
Amateur radio operators routinely do earth-moon-earth radio communication using specifically designed protocols. So using LoRa here is surely the point: to show what it can do — not that it can be done at all.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by bigiain on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:41PM (#29467786)
The spread spectrum "chirps" that LoRa uses are really effective in allowing you to grab tiny signals from unreasonably large noise floors.

You can see the really obvious signal in the waterfall chart here: https://revspace.nl/DecodingLora

It's way way easier to grab those chirps out of the noise than FSK FM modulated signals or worse AM anything.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by jjoonathan on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:21PM (#29463535)
Because it doubles the range of the PR stunt.

If they had driven the chip with a raspberry pi (or, more importantly, said so enough times to land the keyword in the article), they could have quadrupled the range of the PR stunt.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by tinus_hn on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:27AM (#29470557)
They could use virtual reality nanotechnology in the blockchain!
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by gh02t on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:01PM (#29464087)
LoRa isn't really a consumer protocol, more of an industrial one. It's mostly intended for widely distributed sensor networks.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by d21d3q on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:23AM (#29469563)
Actually LoRa is not a protocol but physical layer, way of modulating RF. LoRaWAN is probably that consumer protocol which you refer to. There is also Symphony Link protocol (proprietary).

And I wouldn't use LoRaWAN protocol in industrial application, because you have limited way of ACKing every message (more like UDP for sending sensor data rather than TCP), no option for OTA, and Symphony Link claims to have it, so that I would call it more industrial.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by gh02t on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @09:09AM (#29472591)
Correct, I was hand waving over the distinction but I suppose it's important. LoRa itself is the radio layer. I still think of it as something targeting industrial use cases, though there have been some neat hobbyist projects using it.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by OJFord on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:36AM (#29470610)
So UDP isn't industry-ready yet either then?
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by intpx on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:55PM (#29464737)
Wasn't it designed for sending sensor data from oil wells spread out over vast swaths of land or something? I've always though of it as shortwave/vhf for packets
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by zoom6628 on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:26PM (#29467659)
Started out being used for satellite communication between satellites. It's point to point nature and multiple frequency legs itself to sensor networks over extended distance or in dense areas like cities.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by intpx on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:03PM (#29464841)
Maybe i'm thinking zigbee?
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by gh02t on Monday December 06, 2021 @04:20PM (#29465875)
Zigbee has always (or at least, for a long time) targeted a mixture of consumer and industrial applications and is focused on relatively short range mesh networks. It does have a lot of consumer uses now, it's one of the big protocols used for home automation. Not sure of the exact history of LoRa, but widely distributed oil well sensors would definitely fit the intended use of LoRa. Agriculture is another good use case.

Low power sensors infrequently reporting (mostly one-way) small amounts of data back to a base station over really long distances is what it was originally designed for, though people have done other stuff with it. Zigbee is all about the meshing AFAIU.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by thedougd on Monday December 06, 2021 @04:39PM (#29466069)
Zigbee has a serial bus mode that's identical to RS-485 in practice. There were/are so many industrial applications of RS-485 that they could instantly convert to wireless mesh with a zigbee daughter board or chipset. 'Pro' versions had ~1.5 mile range between nodes.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by Rebelgecko on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:06PM (#29464148)
I think Amazon Sidewalk (included w/ every Alexa now) is built on top of LoRa
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by blacksmith_tb on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:00PM (#29464809)
It looks like they added LoRa to the most recent Ring Bridge[1], but most older Sidewalk devices do their connecting over wifi. Seems likely other new ones will do both.

1: https://fccid.io/2AEUPBHARB001/RF-Exposure-Info/RF-Exposure-...

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by walrus01 on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:32PM (#29464448)
lora is used for more than just consumer iot control - it's one of the most effective ways to bridge a serial connection across a very low bandwidth/RF difficult or weak link.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by ineedasername on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:26PM (#29464381)
Alien 3: We need to find this Alexa person
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by axegon_ on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:43PM (#29463825)
I think this is a pretty good thing, certainly promising: IoT protocols are by definition accessible to the general public which gives a lot of potential for future developments. Surely not with LoRa in particular, given the microscopical size of the payloads but the fact that it is possible is really promising. Just a decade ago, this would have been unthinkable for any hobbyist. Hell, even the prices of sdr's a decade ago were off the charts and today a semi-decent one to get you started costs a few bucks.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by Breefield on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:22PM (#29463540)
Just a guess: given that LoRa operates on line of sight, when trying to update a gateways with sensor status (e.g. GPS position of tracked item) the operator won't be able to get realtime reports if the gateway isn't positioned at a high enough altitude relative to the sensor.

You can mitigate this by having many gateway/collectors at high points on buildings/hills, but bouncing signals off the moon seems like an interesting alternative for connectivity in low coverage locations...

Perhaps this is clear to you I'm just trying to think it through out loud.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by teraflop on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:28PM (#29463625)
This is a cool stunt, but it's not at all practical for IoT communications. For one thing, it requires a big dish and a huge amount of transmission power to get a barely-distinguishable reflected signal.

The other big issue is that it doesn't scale, because there's no directionality: the reflected signal will be scattered off the moon and received everywhere on the hemisphere of earth where the moon is above the horizon. So every single device that tried to use this strategy would have to contend for the same chunk of bandwidth.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by oolonthegreat on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:42PM (#29463812)
it would be interesting to see where else it could've been picked up. like a scatter dispersion map
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by detaro on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:24PM (#29463568)
Moonbounce isn't practical for any real application nowadays. It's a fun experiment and a PR stunt.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by Breefield on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:26PM (#29463592)
Why isn't it practical? Background noise makes it unreliable?
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by detaro on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:35PM (#29463710)
The fact they used a 35m radio telescope as the receiver station here, and transmission powers way over legal limits for normal LoRa-like applications is a pretty good hint. You lose a crazy amount of signal with moonbounce, the effort is always easier to put into different methods instead. AFAIK it's only non-experimental use predates human-made satellites (US military, as a further channel to reach far-away war ships even if terrestrial propagation conditions are bad). If you can't use satellites, and can't have a receiver station within a few thousand miles of your transmitter, then it maybe is sort-of an option, but that's not really a situation you have anymore.

Amateur radio operators still do it, and with purpose-made codecs and really slow speeds it's not that out of reach (i.e. at least for those you don't need a radio telescope dish), but that's just because it's an interesting challenge.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by vvoid on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:02PM (#29464832)
Background noise - that's one way to put it! The path loss is around 250 dB, so a practical amateur moonbounce station makes use of a very powerful RF amplifier feeding an array of yagi antennas, all mounted on an altitude/azimuth rotator - in other words, it's a radio telescope, and the receiving side hopefully has something similar. You can do a google image search for "moonbounce," the setups are kind of amazing. A lot of investment mostly to exchange morse and specialized low-bandwidth digital modes.

The upshot is that you can communicate with any station that can also see the moon - somebody on the other side of the planet, 12,000km away. Plus there is the unique experience of hearing your own transmission echo, two seconds after you cease.

This kind of setup is well within reach for a commercial enterprise but will never be practical for IoT owing to the laws of physics. On the other hand, there is SNOTEL, a system that bounces snowpack telemetry off of the ionized trails left by meteors...

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by virtue3 on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:32PM (#29463671)
Because the moon is 238,900 mi away. Nor does it stay locked in position. Nor is it perfectly reflective (albeit quite a high albedo) nor a perfect sphere.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by bigiain on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:48PM (#29467825)
This comment has made me need to go listen to Albedo 0.39 again:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygcBT87K6BY

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by op00to on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:40PM (#29463781)
Path loss.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by snovv_crash on Monday December 06, 2021 @04:06PM (#29465719)
LoRa doesn't have to be LOS, it depends on the carrier frequency you use. 900MHz LoRa is used for building penetration of control signals for racing drones, for example, with the open source ExpressLRS system.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by bigiain on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:45PM (#29467809)
I have a bunch of (low powered, runs for 24+_hrs on a single 18650 cell) 433MHz Lora/Meshtastic nodes - I can get 10km or so range with simple 1/4 wave dipoles indoors in urban environments. Hills kill it a bot, but I've got one shot that gets 3.3km non line of sight with a hill between the nodes.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by walrus01 on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:33PM (#29464467)
> given that LoRa operates on line of sight

not exactly, no, one of the most common uses for LoRA is in the US 915 MHz band where it can function in a very much non line of sight environment.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by noman-land on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:52PM (#29463974)
I think it would be extremely neat to have a fully citizen run global p2p infrastructure that is nearly free, resilient to electrical and internet outages, and able to reach remote and distant places.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by grkvlt on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:13PM (#29477604)
So, something like AX.25 [0][1] on the amateur radio VHF and UHF bands, which is free (once you have an appropriate license) and there is widespread citizen maintained and managed infrastructure, such as repeaters. [2]

0. http://www.ax25.net/

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AX.25

2. https://ukrepeater.net/

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by progre on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:27AM (#29469319)
That would be neat! But before anyone thinks they can build a citizen p2p version of internet this way: LoRa can do bits per minute. Think old time telegraph throghput.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by genewitch on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:39PM (#29464534)
Winlink basically does this. I'm unsure if there's software for other OS, but winlink is email-ish that is p2p on the backend, and can also be used point to point. And don't tell anyone I said this, but if you have a real hardware modem for winlink you can get 3KB/second. It works on any frequency you can tune to.

Also APRS, even though it seems like Google has a huge interest in it, is also a p2p communication network, running on 144mhz and 10mhz.

Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by __MatrixMan__ on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:32PM (#29464460)
I'd crowdfund the maintenance of LoRa repeaters on nearby mountaintops. I'd also do the hiking to maintain them, sounds like as good a premise for adventure as any.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by URSpider94 on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:29PM (#29465197)
Check out https://helium.com - it's a blockchain-based LoRA network, where the blockchain is used to reward uptime and certainty of location of the base stations. Transmissions can be received from 10 miles or more away, if the receiver is located high enough.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by giantg2 on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:21PM (#29463532)
A consumer protocol, but also way over consumer power level (350W). No wonder it's the furthest LoRa message sent. Let's bump it up to 1kW and break the record again...
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by fortran77 on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:06PM (#29466317)
That was the Effective Radiated Power. The actual transmitter was outputting consumer output levels.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by giantg2 on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:51PM (#29466763)
I thought most FCC rules are based on effective power and that this wouldn't be legal for terrestrial/consumer use?
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by s800 on Monday December 06, 2021 @06:42PM (#29467292)
Correct.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by numlock86 on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:35PM (#29463702)
1kW? Are you crazy??? Let's see 25mW, which is the maximum you are allowed to use in Germany for 868 MHz ...
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by stavros on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:36PM (#29466619)
To be fair, it can do a few km at 25 mW, which is fairly good for consumer range.
Re:Bouncing a LoRa message off the moon by imoverclocked on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:03PM (#29464113)
I agree, if we are doing this, go big. 1MW would be far more exciting and the experiment definitely wouldn't go unnoticed.