News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by bambax on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:21AM (#29458833)
The problem is not the content of the video, crypto or not. The problem is not that YT moderates aggressively (it doesn't do enough IMHO) or even how it moderates.

The problem is that there is no serious appeals process, and no third party oversight of moderation decisions. This is true for all the big platforms.

How do we fix that, IDK, but probably at the government level.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by SpelingBeeChamp on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:55AM (#29460421)
That is not true.

I produce content for YouTube full-time.

Just a few days ago a well-performing video ended up age-restricted. It was an edge case, and could have gone either way. I appealed, and included the best argument I could put together.

A few hours later I received this:

We have reviewed your appeal for the following content:

[the video title]

After taking another look, we can confirm that your content does not violate our Community Guidelines.

Thanks for your patience while we reviewed this appeal. Our goal is to make sure content doesn't violate our Community Guidelines so that YouTube can be a safe place for all - and sometimes we make mistakes trying to get it right. We're sorry for any frustration our mistake caused you, and we appreciate you letting us know.

~~~

I appeal YouTube's decisions all the time. Sometimes appeals go my way, other times they don't, but that doesn't mean there is no serious appeals process. As far as I know, almost every adverse decision can be appealed.

~~~

About your last comment, the existence of a problem doesn't mean that government stepping in would be better.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by makeitdouble on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:19AM (#29460742)
Both of you would be right at the same time.

You raised high enough to be full-time on Youtube, you have a full history of interactions with their moderators, a track record of videos that performed well, and get to be handle by real humans.

That doesn’t mean it’s the same experience for the vast majority of creators, especially those who upload a video once in a while and have no reputation in the system.

On any Google service I think both sides exist, and the difference is usually pretty stark, like night and day.

PS: on the gov. part, the issue is that Google is economically big enough that there is no counterpart to make them do what they don’t want to. People are turning to govs. because there is basically no other recourse in many situations.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by goldenkey on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:19AM (#29460740)
By being a content creator, you are a money maker for them. Even so, you probably got lucky. thunderf00t has gotten in trouble loads of times for doing nothing but outing bad science. Same with CoffeeZilla and a thousand other YouTubers. I myself got my channel delisted from recommendations entirely (a shadow ban essentially) for making a Covid precaution video about different types of NIOSH masks..
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by NoWayDude1 on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:28AM (#29460876)
Imagine you, as a full time content producer, have been banned from YouTube for good, just because. Your appeal ended up the same way as for OP "response within less than 15 minutes that they appeal has been rejected and that no further replies will be processed". Would you want the government involvement in this case?
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by SpelingBeeChamp on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:45PM (#29465445)
NoWayDude.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by yomly on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:20AM (#29460751)
I think the whole point is that OP appealed, got hard rejection and can't escalate or even compromise.

Now their unrelated YouTube Music account is locked

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by otrahuevada on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:28AM (#29459453)
Google famously sucks at customer service, mostly because they've figured that they'd have to pay a moderation team more money than whatever they'll lose from the few and far between problem cases there might be.

There is no fixing that without massive corporate reorganization, which won't be voluntary, and thus will take 10x the time with worse results. At this point this is just the Google way to do things, and making smaller fry follow this rules will probably only end up making Google bigger.

The one real way out there might be is making one-click self hosting viable again.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by cft on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:52AM (#29459706)
The problem is their monopoly power over video distribution on the internet: disgruntled users have nowhere else to go. All alternatives are stifled by the monopoly.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by acdha on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:17AM (#29459971)
People have tons of alternatives. The problem is that ad subsidies pay more than most viewers are willing to pay after generations of internet users have been conditioned to think of content as free.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ghaff on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:44AM (#29461099)
There's also:

1.) The discovery associated with YouTube and

2.) In addition to being convenient, you don't need to pay to host on YouTube. It would be pretty trivial for people to host their own content--much of which is never going to pay anything to speak of in ads. But then they'd have to pay for the hosting.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by acdha on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:57AM (#29461278)
#1 is definitely true — I was thinking of that mostly as an artifact of the cost point. There's a really strong ratchet effect: YouTube gets a ton of content because they not only provide hosting for free but also incentivize a ton of creators to direct traffic to YouTube since they get paid that way, which further encourages people to think of YouTube as where they go for video. Even places which self-host tend to report much higher numbers from YouTube than their own website, and that's a very hard thing to compete against.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by whimsicalism on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:19PM (#29462596)
Advertising is what pays for the hosting. Good luck with your ad-free, free video hosting service.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by gfaster on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:34AM (#29460169)
From what I understand what YouTube does is super super difficult to do at scale as well as they do, I do not envy their competitors. Given that, I don't believe ever hoping for an actual competitor to pop up is reasonable, instead we should start thinking about how we can ensure fairness, inclusivity, and democracy(?) on what exists.

I'm not sure what the best way to go about it is, but I know that advertiser and corporate pressure being the only thing that matters is not working (see: dislike count removal). I would not be surprised that if YouTube continues to be unable to regulate itself we'll see governments stepping in and regulating it for them.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by kaetemi on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:52AM (#29460379)
An Internet standard for video delivery and ISP edge caching might be a nice way out...

Unfortunately that all seems to be proprietary money making territory right now.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ComodoHacker on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:24AM (#29461672)
Can we have something like 'municipal fiber' for content? With help of IPFS perhaps?
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by acdha on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:50AM (#29462127)
There are two reasons why P2P has been generally less successful than a lot of us hoped around the turn of the century: the first is largely technical, namely the small number of people with plenty of uplink bandwidth, and something like municipal fiber would actually help a lot there. When people have 1,000/25 connections they have less capacity to share in general and with things like video chat and gaming being common, the amount of idle capacity consistently available is relatively limited.

The other is harder: some ISPs outright blocked or throttled P2P protocols entirely (much to the annoyance of, say, Linux users torrenting ISOs) and most others will have some mechanism to respond to copyright claims. The latter is really hard for a YouTube competitor if it allows anyone to upload content — if the network attempts to auto-mirror content, you are potentially at risk if someone uploads something illegal; if it doesn't, only the most popular public content will be well-replicated.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by yxwvut on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:26AM (#29461710)
The problem is an incumbency/network effect problem. Sure, the ad-supported model helped them get off the ground, but it's not what's keeping them #1. The larger your library, the greater your value to viewers, and, thereby, the greater your value to content creators, increasing your library, increasing your viewership, etc. Virtually every tech company out there has massive incumbent advantages. Unless you can offer a differentiated service (eg: Tik Tok vs Instagram), your business is DOA.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by pdimitar on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:31AM (#29460133)
Nobody has been "conditioned" to think anything. If they opted to make things free at the start of the internet era then it's now their problem to figure out how to pivot to actually paying their expenses and turn profit.

It's not the users' problem per se (unless they get aggressively pushed out but then they go to alternatives so that company still doesn't make profit out of them).

Elementary psychology -- one that's studied at 9th grade where I live -- could have told them that it's super hard giving people something for free and then taking it away. People don't react well to that and never have.

They only have themselves to blame.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by acdha on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:18AM (#29460723)
These are mutually contradictory:

> Nobody has been "conditioned" to think anything. … > Elementary psychology -- one that's studied at 9th grade where I live -- could have told them that it's super hard giving people something for free and then taking it away. People don't react well to that and never have.

That was in fact my point: since the mid-to-late 90s, Internet users have become accustomed to thinking that they pay for internet connectivity but that most of the content they view will be free either because it's been subsidized by investors or advertisers. There are exceptions but they generally tend to be either connected to the physical world or a handful of areas like commercial movies or gaming where the major rightsholders were largely successful at preventing people from getting used to free content.

That puts you in exactly the dynamic I described: very few people think that YouTube-level content is something they pay for but their expectations are set by the kind of resources that billions of ad profits can support.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by 14 on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:50AM (#29461181)
From what I read they made well over $19 billion in revenue in 2020. They are making plenty of money they can afford to put towards the problem. They just don’t want to take from their own bottom line.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by narrator on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:59AM (#29460471)
There's Rumble, Odysee, Bitchute, Peertube, etc. Just post it there.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by goldenkey on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:25AM (#29460832)
More Plates More Dates, a workout science YouTuber who sometimes talks about 'enhancement', recently got banned off of Bitchute. So it isn't a bastion either.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by notshift on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:40AM (#29461063)
Does he talk about that in one of his videos? I'm curious to hear more. It looks like there is still a bitchute page up with his brand and videos.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by goldenkey on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:33PM (#29469090)
It's possible he got reinstated. Yes, he talked about it briefly in his outro a few videos ago.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by eldaisfish on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:19AM (#29460735)
to be seen by whom?

I'm pretty tech savvy and have heard of none of these. Not a single one.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by throw10920 on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:30AM (#29461791)
I've heard of all of those - mostly through my friends.

However, as to your larger point - you're right, most people don't know about these.

I would argue that those who want to escape Google's grasp should be willing to encourage person-to-person sharing as an alternative to the recommendation algorithm. Sure, 99.99% of the population isn't browsing PeerTube, but I bet you that most of them would be willing to watch a video hosted there if it was suggested to them by their friends.

This might be a good idea in general. Think of how much better ecosystems we would have if people relied on their friends to make personalized recommendations to content on any platform, as opposed to engagement-optimizing automated algorithms that exclusively recommend content on a single platform.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ghaff on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:19PM (#29462587)
By and large, hosting isn’t the issue whether text, audio, images, or video. Yes, video is more intensive than the others but hosting taken by itself is a solved problem. While podcast directories are centralized the hosting is pretty distributed. Not so easy is finding things and the fact that some level of moderation is probably needed somewhere in the system. And you’ll have to pay.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by SkyMarshal on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:47AM (#29461139)
I’ve heard of Peertube, it was on HN recently. But none of the others.

Oddly unmentioned are Vimeo and Dailymotion, which have been around much longer and probably have larger user bases and network effects.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ghaff on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:54AM (#29461239)
Unless you have a following, probably no one will see it on YouTube either. I generally post on YouTube but, if I were concerned about being blocked, I'd probably just host on a VPS.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by thijser on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:29AM (#29458901)
I totally agree.

If they had had a message "this is a problem with your account, fix it or else within 3 days we suspend you", that wouldn't have been nice but not completely impossible like the current solution.

How is it not possible for Google to implement that? I understand they also have some very bad cases of spam to deal with, but if I take my account as an example, the 'bad' video was uploaded 4 months ago and has 133 views in total, how can the system not determine there's no harm in leaving it up for another 3 days (in which it probably will get 0 views)?

So sad that the big tech companies can't manage to change from the inside but need to be forced by regulation to do good for their customers.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by giansegato on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:44AM (#29459018)
It could be remunerated. Like: pay 100$ to have a human look at your case. You can appeal (and pay) up to 3 times. This would partially solve the scalability problem + provide partial disincentives for scammers and spammers. I would happily pay 100$ to recover my lost Google account. Of course this would in turn create the bad incentive of having Google not create good models. Ideally the law would require to cap prices somehow. Hard problem for sure.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by EvanAnderson on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:00AM (#29459183)
Why is it my problem that a fair moderation process must be cost-effective for Google, et. al.?

Edit: Google's profit margins aren't my problem. If they want to be such a big, all-encompassing force in the "digital lives" of individuals they need to be held to account with fair policies for dealing with Customers. If that creates an untenable business for them they can either innovate in a manner that results in a fair deal for users and lower expense to themselves or they can suck it up and take the hit on their margin.

I don't use Google's various services beyond search, personally, but it's clear that some regulation is needed. Non-technical individuals don't understand the ramifications of relying so heavily on a platform that can be pulled out from under them with no notice and no recourse. Heck, even technical people don't seem to grasp it.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ziml77 on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:07AM (#29459248)
Because the process requires people and people cost money. And without attaching a cost to it, there would be far more requests for manual review coming in than any team Google hires could handle.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by pixl97 on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:26AM (#29459424)
"There are too many safety considerations for us to effectively mitigate, it would be too expensive, so we should be allowed to ignore safety altogether" --average 19th century industrialists
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ziml77 on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:54AM (#29459727)
The context here is a proposal on how to make an appeals process viable instead just saying it's impossible.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by colinmhayes on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:41AM (#29460241)
Google can easily afford to hire a hundred thousand moderators. No number of requests is too many.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by mst on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:35AM (#29460171)
If you legislate a non-cost-effective model you're making it substantially harder for possible future competitors.

If we're assuming that "youtube as a permanent monopoly" is inevitable then, sure, fair enough, but I think if you're making that assumption it's worth making it explicitly.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by JohnWhigham on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:07AM (#29459251)
Because they're a business, and that's how businesses are run?
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by junon on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:31AM (#29459476)
So ignoring your customers after they've paid you money is something we should just throw into the bin of "that's just business, folks"?
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by JohnWhigham on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:53AM (#29459715)
As cliche as it sounds, YouTube creators are not the customer, the advertisers are.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by AshleyGrant on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:10AM (#29459892)
I've been paying for YouTube Premium for years. I pay for YouTube TV. I pay for Google Photos. I pay for Google Apps for Business.

In all, I pay Google north of $1,000 every year.

Whether Google likes it or not, I AM their customer.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by golemotron on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:46AM (#29460303)
If you don't like them, it's time to look for a comparable competitor. If there aren't any then this is an object lesson on why there are pending anti-trust suits.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by junon on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:31AM (#29460924)
> If there aren't any then this is an object lesson on why there are pending anti-trust suits

I don't think anyone here is arguing with that - it's a pretty widely accepted fact that Youtube has a hegemony (see: near-monopoly) in the space.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by junon on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:00AM (#29459801)
If you accept money from people (such as the OP, who is a Youtube Music subscriber, a paid service), they are 100% your customer.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by jtbayly on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:25AM (#29460054)
Because otherwise in the worst case Youtube can't remain free, which is arguably a good thing.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by EvanAnderson on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:43AM (#29460255)
I don't take it as a foregone conclusion that centralized free video hosting services are a good thing.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ipaddr on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:42AM (#29460254)
How is a paid youtube a good thing? What do you win? Less tracking no..

If you want a paid video provider many exist.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by throwaway82931 on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:04AM (#29459211)
That's one option. Another would be that you need to pay for your service on a monthly basis.

Some way that for a user to have faith in the appeals process and purchase peace of mind. Just knowing that a backstop is there would help a great deal.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by dorfsmay on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:33AM (#29459505)
OP mentioned that they are a paid YouTube member, so they do pay monthly for the service.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by throwaway82931 on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:56PM (#29463172)
Yes, you're right. I guess I couldn't let go of the idea that an an appeals process should be scalable for paying customers. I still believe that.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by steve_g on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:31AM (#29459474)
He says he's a subscriber to YouTube music. So he is paying.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by JohnKacz on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:08AM (#29459260)
I'd add if you win the appeal you get your money back. That solves a few more of the problems I think.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by alpaca128 on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:17AM (#29459338)
All that does is create a "get free $100" button for Google.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by kortex on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:51AM (#29459694)
That's a good idea but I can also see it backfiring. "Oops your account got locked by our algo, better cough up some dough so we can take a look at it..."
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by politician on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:50AM (#29460341)
You already pay taxes for access to the courts.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by grammarnazzzi on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:13AM (#29460643)
This creates a system that encourages bribery.

Historically, such systems are legislated against and are often made illegal.

Example: Suppose you are a cashier working in retail. If at the end of your shift your drawer is short for whatever reason, you cannot make up the difference out-of-pocket. Your managager would be commiting a crime by accepting your money.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by hvis on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:10AM (#29459896)
Without any solid guarantees (e.g. laws), you're just out $300 and back where you started.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by _fat_santa on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:12AM (#29460632)
We don't need the government to step in, we need another video streaming company to come in and really compete with Youtube. The problem is that right now, Youtube has no direct competitors. Sure there is Vimeo and Rumble, but both aren't big enough to really threaten Youtube's bottom line.

The Rumble SPAC deal is interesting because it seems they may be the first company to have the capital to compete with Youtube. I have a strong feeling that once an actual competitor emerges, Youtube will tamp down on their censorship. They censor all day long now because they know creators don't have another option. Once that other option arises, the only thing that censorship will do for Youtube is loosing customers.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by meeech on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:16AM (#29460692)
"We don't need the government to step in, we need another video streaming company to come in and really compete with Youtube. The problem is that right now, Youtube has no direct competitors"

This is incredibly naive. All that would happen is both services would use similar automated systems for moderation - it is cheaper for them. They would have no incentive to provide good support.

We need regulations that require access to human judgement for digital services. When millions of people use a service, even a 1% error rate in moderation / account disabling has a real impact on a lot of peoples lives.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by joshsyn on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:34AM (#29460961)
An easy way to provide good support would be for youtube to charge the content up-loaders for a small fee. That would be a source of revenue for them to provide support in return for monetary value. Else there is simply no incentive. Introducing regulations for every digital human interaction is a waste of taxpayers money and incredibly naive way of thinking.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by genidoi on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:50AM (#29459680)
There can’t be any semblance of an appeals process whilst the law treats social media platforms like privately owned property that you have the privilege of being a guest too.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by wayoutthere on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:41AM (#29459579)
Quite frankly, now that YouTube has built its media ecosystem, they have an incentive to marginalize the long tail. The big channels (or rather, their distribution companies) have dedicated account managers who can clear this kind of stuff up. Big channels are easier to manage from a platform perspective since there’s someone you can call to clear up any issues (who you already have a contractual relationship with), so you don’t need to trust an unaccountable algorithm.

If you’re not a YouTube partner? You’re collateral damage that is baked into the design and considered acceptable by YouTube. Your value as an independent content creator is very low to them. The effort required to moderate independent creators is significantly higher than it is to moderate managed partners on a per-view basis. It’s a lot of work for small dollar amounts.

This is a pretty common situation we’ve seen play out over the last century. When a new media paradigm is established, there’s a land rush. But once the initial land rush is over, the industry regulates itself and consolidates for efficiency. The new media landscape eventually becomes the very thing they displaced. Ever wonder why YouTube has as many ads as broadcast TV these days?

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ivegotnoaccount on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:05AM (#29461410)
Honest question, do you actually get as many ads on YouTube as on TV ? With the former, I am used to 2 10-seconds to 1-minutes ads every 10-15 minutes and that are usually skippable (~16% in the worst case). On TV, at least in France, there are at least as many ads, but they can't be skipped.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by wayoutthere on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:25PM (#29462681)
Yes it’s gotten pretty egregious. I generally get 30 seconds of non-skippable ads every 5 mins or so. I haven’t watched broadcast TV in probably 10 years so maybe I’m not remembering how bad it is, but I have a hard time watching YouTube with how frequent (and poorly targeted) the ads are.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ivegotnoaccount on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:11PM (#29466353)
Wow, if it gets to this level, I can understand. If you don't mind, what country do you live in ? I am kinda curious of if it is related to location.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by depingus on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:43AM (#29460262)
This all could have been avoided if the same algo that detected the scammy title had been applied during the posting process. A warning from YT saying, "Hey this sounds scammy, we're not posting it" was all that was needed.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by Hard_Space on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:58AM (#29461298)
> that there is no serious appeals process, and no third party oversight of moderation decisions

Yes there is, see [0] - also posted by me in another reply in this thread, where I mention that my own YouTube account was suspended identically to OP earlier this year, but was restored 3-4 hours after filling out the form. The decision may or may not have been AI-driven, but I'm pretty sure there was a human in the loop behind the solution.

Don't mistake me for a Google fanboy - I had my primary Gmail account locked last week for daring to use a VPN, so I'm currently looking at de-Googling myself a bit. But to be fair, I was able to fix both issues within a few hours.

[0] https://support.google.com/accounts/contact/suspended?p=yout...

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by LegitShady on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:28PM (#29462722)
>had my primary Gmail account locked last week for daring to use a VPN,

yikes I check my gmail behind a VPN semi regularly. Now I'm worried.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by Hard_Space on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:22PM (#29469033)
I forgot, to be honest, that I had two other Gmail logins running on my headless tower at the other end of the room, so requests were coming from my country and from the US simultaneously.

Since I wasn't trying to evade geoblocking, I now use a VPN that's set to my own city AND I shut down the applications on the headless machine. But that still leaves my phone sucking in mails on a non-VPN connection, and that's not so easy to fix, because I'm damned if I'll switch it off every time I need a VPN, or trouble myself to use a VPN on that too.

So, yeah, in general I'm worried too. Personally I think we'll look back on VPN use in five years the way that early 20thC cocaine addicts fondly remember when you could just buy the stuff over the counter without a scrip in pharmacies. Sorry to see China setting the pace on this one.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by s17n on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:36AM (#29461879)
People talk about creating an appeals process like it's something Google could just snap their fingers and do, like the commenter in this thread who suggested they should just "hire 100000 moderators". The problem is, scaling a human system like this is extremely difficult and human appeals are notoriously weak against social engineering attacks. It's far from clear that a manual review process capable of handling billions of users and reliably producing the correct outcome is even possible at any kind of plausible cost.

Think about how much a court case in the US costs - orders of magnitude more than a company could possibly afford to spend on moderation. Does everybody really think it's possible to design a process that's orders of magnitude cheaper without also being orders of magnitude less accurate?

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by shkkmo on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:57AM (#29462259)
>It's far from clear that a manual review process capable of handling billions of users and reliably producing the correct outcome is even possible at any kind of plausible cost.

I would hope that the reason that scaling is hard is because violators would spam the system. If there really are so many legitimate users losing access, then this is a huge problem that we need to hold companies legally accountable for.

What we need is a system that disincentives large companies from having too many false positives while disncentiving bad actors from using the appeals process.

> Think about how much a court case in the US costs - orders of magnitude more than a company could possibly afford to spend on moderation.

You shouldn't need a full court case, it seems like a small claims court type approach would be sufficient.

One answer is a solution is used in many places already is to allow the judge to assign court costs to one party or the depending on the facts of the case.

> Does everybody really think it's possible to design a process that's orders of magnitude cheaper without also being orders of magnitude less accurate?

I absolutely think it is feasible to build a system that doesn't cost too much vs. the level of supplementary accuracy it would provide. I also don't see how we have a choice. In this era where we own nothing and everything is a service, we absolutely need to be able to have accountability for the companies that provide those services. We can't just allow them to cut the services off at their whim with no legal recourse.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by nybble41 on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:54PM (#29463139)
> … this is a huge problem that we need to hold companies legally accountable for.

Legally accountable for what? They do not owe anyone free access to their service. If you're a paying subscriber then they do owe at least their choice of a refund or continued service until the end of the current subscription period—unless they can demonstrate that you were the one that broke the contract—but they are have no obligation to let you renew, any more than you are obligated to continue subscribing.

Google doesn't have a monopoly on much beyond their own brand and reputation. All the services they offer, including video hosting, can be found elsewhere. If you want to build your income stream on their brand ("Oh, but no one will be able to find me if I host my videos on PeerTube!") you do it on their terms.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by shkkmo on Monday December 06, 2021 @04:51PM (#29466179)
> Legally accountable for what?

The legally accountable for providing a product that doesn't cause undue harm to the population.

> They do not owe anyone free access

I pay for services from Google, so does the entire customer base of the play store. The user in the published article was a paying YouTube music customer.

> but they are have no obligation to let you renew,

I would disagree. When companies are allowed to become large enough that they have a significant effect on the ability for alternatives to compete in the marketplace, they assume an obligation to provide access to that marketplace to everyone. I absolutely do not buy that large service providers have the right to deny service to someone simply because they don't like them.

Additionally, when you form a business relationship, even when that relationship consists of exchanging your product for their data, there is am entirely reasonable expectation that the relationship won't be severed without cause. This is an expectation that enables commerce and it is to the benefit of a nation to enable those expectations where possible.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by nybble41 on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:21PM (#29466469)
> When companies are allowed to become large enough that they have a significant effect on the ability for alternatives to compete in the marketplace, they assume an obligation to provide access to that marketplace to everyone.

I would disagree. "Past performance is no guarantee of future results." There is no obligation to keep doing things the same way they've "always" been done. Every interaction is decided on a case-by-case basis. One does not forfeit freedom of (dis)association through mere inertia; one retains the right to make exceptions or to change one's mind.

> Additionally, when you form a business relationship, even when that relationship consists of exchanging your product for their data, there is am entirely reasonable expectation that the relationship won't be severed without cause.

I might be willing to buy that, to a point. The usual rule is that the expectations need to have a reasonable basis in the contract and any liability is limited to the direct impact of having those reasonable expectations disappointed. However, even paid services routinely disappear on short notice, for various reasons. Assuming that a paid service will be maintained well after the current subscription term elapses is not reasonable. Neither is assuming long-term access to a free service.

> … it is to the benefit of a nation to enable those expectations where possible.

Then "the nation" can very well lead the way by offering its own services (on a voluntary, non-tax-supported basis, naturally) and not by, in effect, nationalizing a private service by imposing its own terms.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by shkkmo on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @08:20AM (#29472155)
> One does not forfeit freedom of (dis)association through mere inertia; one retains the right to make exceptions or to change one's mind.

We are not talking about a person, we are talking about a corporation. While there is certainly a value to freedom of disassociation for large corporations, I see no reason that freedom is not bounded by the right to have access to services that are available to the general public. We don't allow service to be terminated to people of a protected class, we don't allow service to be terminated explicitly to interference with your ability to compete.

> nationalizing a private service by imposing its own terms.

Regulating a business is not the same thing as nationalizing it. Trying to conflate such terms is not debating in good faith. Please try to think outside of your black and white partisan rhetoric and participate in a real discussion.

There is value, to Google, in those expectations being possible. Those expectations encourage people to do business with Google and trust Google with their data. Similar to the value of a stable currency or an incorrupt judicial system, these are expectations that enable the flow of commerce to the benefit of all. Creating a government run AppStore or YouTube fails to accomplish those goals and does nothing to enable commerce.

There is value in free enterprise and not restricting people's ability to find new ways to solve problems. That does not mean that large corporations have the right to treat people disposably. If we don't let ourselves get trapped in ideologically rigid thought we can find a way to balance these needs and rights in a fair way.

I would also note that these large companies don't actually want to terminate service to the users who would win on appeal. It is just that these companies don't want to pay to process appeals for spammers and fraudsters. Creating a system of fair and properly incentivized account adjudication could improve things for everyone.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by temp8964 on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:27AM (#29460081)
I don't believe "This is true for all the big platforms."

I saw lots of stories here about Google, but I don't remember see one about how Microsoft blocks user account. Did I miss?

Anyway. Couple years ago, I received several email notifications from Microsoft about someone tried to reset my account password. I got a little bit concerned and eventually sent a feedback to Microsoft asking what I need to do. Surprise! I got a answering call from Microsoft by a real human!

Because of all the bad stories about Google blocks user accounts, I moved all my stuff to Microsoft products and my own NAS.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by ipaddr on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:47AM (#29460317)
Hotmail has plenty of stories.

Paid email has many great providers like fastmail..

Microsoft doesn't offer a video platform so it doesn't really apply.

Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by temp8964 on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:41PM (#29463796)
Really? I searched Hotmail here and couldn't find story like this (banning users).
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by rodolphoarruda on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:05AM (#29460546)
We may fix this by decentralizing the original source of the content and making the social end, the account used to post/share that content, ephemerous. How can we still build reputation in this model? Making sure the original source is visible and accessible. It all boils down to reputation management, which needs to be re-engineered.
Re:YouTube suspended my account for posting DeFi hackathon v... by politician on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:48AM (#29460324)
Corporate appeals processes are watered down arbitration processes which are a loophole to allow a larger company to force a subordinate to give up their rights to the government’s courts.

Sue them in small claims court for the value of your music library.