I think what's important is that I actually had to check because I have no idea what a working used laptop goes for..and if you told me some go for $60, I wouldn't be surprised.
Given that the laptop was "messed up" and needed to be "fixed", even more so. Who "fixed" it btw? Not her, probably.
I've had stuff of mine stolen often enough (bikes, mostly) that I don't really care whether the law would say I should have known or not, but morally, I just think it's disgusting to profit off theft of other people's property and I think it's just the right thing to do, to consider the possibility.
That said, even though I'm of the opinion the women was definitely in the wrong and should have known better, the police also definitely crossed the line the way they handled those photographs.
And - wouldn't you think that _those_ offers would be shady? I mean.. There's a reason why people check eBay after their gadgets were stolen...
As for shady, no, the depreciation of electronics never surprises me. Plus, the article said the laptop needed repairs.
I'm not saying she didn't know it was stolen. I'm saying that the price, alone, is a 0% indicator in my books.
The Absolute recovery officer sent the explicit photos along with location information for the stolen laptop to the Springfield Police Department.
How sure? Perhaps she has a scat fetish that her boyfriend doesn't share. Yes it's subjective but not necessarily a chosen response; most people find the image of a mutilated corpse or a festering wound to be disgusting for example.
'One of the prudish detectives wasn’t a fan of the photos, calling them “disgusting.”'
That's all we have to go on. A single word remark reported by the plaintiff. It's pretty much impossible to make any bearing as to the professionalism or otherwise of the "detective" (it says earlier in the same para that it was "officers" operating under a warrant, which would almost certainly not be detectives for recovering a stolen laptop, YMMV the piece looks unfinished and unedited to me).
However, FWIW, saying something is disgusting isn't casting a moral judgement on it. If you show me a festering sore I might remark "urgh, that's disgusting" but I don't find sores to be immoral. I'm pretty sure he or she wasn't presenting or even attempting to present a legal judgement with what was most likely an off-the-cuff remark. Unprofessional, perhaps mildly.
For all we know the remark was disgust at a teacher having apparently knowingly handled stolen goods taken from another school and encouraged a pupil into delinquency by helping them profit from crime and that the plaintiff misinterpreted. Yes it would probably still be mildly unprofessional to comment.
Aside, aren't school laptops marked to show their owner; this would have made it near impossible to not know that the goods were stolen.
One of the prudish detectives wasn’t a fan of the photos, calling them “disgusting.”
Anyway, their job isn't to be the moral police. Also, telling her she was stupid isn't very professional.
Sigh