News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by jakelazaroff on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:12AM (#29441745)
> no one is forced to use aws or Amazon

Sure they are. I’d probably have to stop using the Internet entirely to avoid using a service powered by AWS.

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by mmdoda on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:22AM (#29441810)
The point is you as a business don't have to use aws, there are alternatives out there.

For consumers it is irrelevant because they aren't buying "aws" directly.

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by Synaesthesia on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:24AM (#29441832)
You don't have to live in your house, you are free to live outside.

You don't have to have a job, you are free to starve.

You don't have to live in your country, you are free to go.

You see, freedom is not absolute, there are power relations involved.

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by spurgu on Saturday December 04, 2021 @12:01PM (#29442152)
You can work for a bit, save up for a sailboat, live on it, fish for food, travel from country to country.
Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by savant_penguin on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:46AM (#29442010)
This is a false comparison

Because freedom is not absolute it does not mean I'd want to give whatever freedom I have away

Under socialism you do not get do pick jobs at will. And you better show everyone how happy you are at the job assigned to you.

"You don't have to live in your country, you are free to go."

Many have died for this freedom alone. And you don't have to go to North Korea to know this. Right in the heart of (now) western Europe people were shot dead for running away through the Berlin wall.

How come people risk death to run away from the utopia? They must be counter-revolutionaries better murder whatever family they left behind

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by grumpyprole on Saturday December 04, 2021 @12:06PM (#29442201)
> Under socialism you do not get do pick jobs at will. And you better show everyone how happy you are at the job assigned to you.

Socialism might mean you have more choice of work, because there is greater social mobility and access to education. Perhaps also you might work for a "cooperative" firm, where every employee is a part owner and gets to vote on issues and a take on the profits.

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by Synaesthesia on Saturday December 04, 2021 @01:22PM (#29442967)
Yeah because those are dictatorships which have no meaningful socialism. I measure it in terms of worker power, not how authoritarian the state is or what it calls itself.
Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by jakelazaroff on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:34AM (#29441920)
It’s not irrelevant to me, the consumer, because there is a causal relationship between my use of a service and AWS making money.
Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by laserbeam on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:29AM (#29441868)
Hang on a minute, while what you are saying is true, the article is not trying to convince you that socialism is good. It's trying to convince you that bitcoin does not solve socialist goals. i.e. Bitcoin is still a capitalist tool even if it often uses narratives like "it breaks up central banks".

I agree with your perspective on socialism, and that yes, the is messy. It's just not the point here. It's simply what the other camp thinks of bitcoin. (assuming the writing is truthful and all that jazz)

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by sozforex on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:42AM (#29441981)
> Anything that is not socialist is called ultra right.

Could it be that you have misunderstood this? He was talking specifically about ultra-right / far-right like "National Front"/"National Rally" in France and Vox in Spain. That economic crises benefit parties like that (And you can see that parties like that are/were on the rise in popularity after 2008 crisis in Europe).

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by trs8080 on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:37AM (#29441937)
you should take a look at the venn diagram of failed socialist states and right-wing coups planned and/or supported by the United States.

here's a starting point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...

Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by grumpyprole on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:58AM (#29442137)
I could equally well claim that capitalism is evil and destroying lives (and the planet). But such a view would be just as one-sided as yours. The Nordic model, especially Finland, gives a good example of how socialist ideas can work. Socialism is about collective ownership, not authoritarian regimes.
Re:Why Bitcoin is not a socialist’s ally (2020) by spurgu on Saturday December 04, 2021 @12:05PM (#29442190)
Just to clarify, socialism is about government ownership. Communism is about ownership of the people. As I see it no society has ever reached communism. Those that have gone full socialist have failed. There seems to be a fair amount of success in halfway there "socialist-capitalist" (essential services socialist, regulated capitalism for the rest) countries like Finland.