Recently moved back from Germany after five years there, homeopathy depressingly common and accepted there, even by many medical professionals.
We still have homeopathic pills and "treatments" which are being paid by the health insurance. Something which goes back to some politicians wife who believed in it and was able to influence the political process. The huge Steiner tradition in here is catastrophic. We just recently had COVID running wild in a Waldorf school. Turns out, faked vaccination certificates were very popular...
It's quite embarrassing and it's actually the first time the side effects of this madness come up in public discourse.
Just in this thread alone, we can find people saying:
1. Vaccines would let us wipe out COVID (wrong).
2. Even harsher lockdowns would let us wipe out COVID (wrong).
3. Vaccines stop people transmitting it (wrong).
4. Vaccinated people don't end up in ICU with COVID (wrong).
5. Sweden had unusually bad outcomes (wrong).
6. That it's "very normal" for people to take yearly flu shots (wrong, only ~35% uptake amongst at risk patients in 2019).
And that's not even a full list. There's not only a large set of factually incorrect beliefs amongst vaccine mandate fanatics (and that's the only word for you guys now), but also a generalized incorrect belief that it's the other side who are badly informed.
Vaccines don't stop being from transmitting, but it reduces the length of infection by about 2 days, it drastically reduces the likelihood of infection, which drastically reduces the transmission rate, and recent studies have shown that it does also reduce the likelihood of transmission directly.
Vaccinated people with breakthrough cases may end up in the ICU, but the rate of hospitalization, admittance to the ICU, and cases of death are considerably lower than those who haven't been vaccinated.
Using the extreme example, and pointing out that each argument is wrong, rather than extreme, while not discussing the facts is just another form of misinformation.
The reasonable choice is to disallow all fanatics, but the world is too polarized on this topic. The center cannot hold.
Regardless, whilst these claims are "extreme" in the sense of being phrased in absolutes, they aren't "extreme" in the sense of being rarely believed, are they? Not only do they crop up all over this thread but in the very article the thread is about, Angelas Merkel, not exactly famous for being the Queen of Extreme, says "The fourth wave must be broken and this has not yet been achieved" which is simply another way of saying (3) and strongly alluding to (1) and (2).
Also:
"it drastically reduces the likelihood of infection, which drastically reduces the transmission rate, and recent studies have shown that it does also reduce the likelihood of transmission directly"
Let's break this down:
1. Infection rates. Health agencies claim it reduces the likelihood of infection, and at first it genuinely seems to, but the only one that is willing to show the actual raw data before they wildly alter it using statistical techniques, is the UK HSA. Their data shows that by now the rate amongst vaccinated people is actually a lot higher than among the unvaccinated for some large age groups! This sounds like it should be impossible, but it turns out to have been observed in pre-COVID times with other vaccines.
They have been reduced to claiming that comparing case rates between vaccinated and unvaccinated people isn't a valid way to determine if the vaccine works, due to vague behavioural differences that they speculate must exist but have no proof for.
2. Rate of transmission. Not for the first time, we find that epidemiological studies aren't worth much. Can you cite yours, so we can see when it was written? Because once again UK data contradicts it (or it does now at least):
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7...
"In the UK it was described that secondary attack rates among household contacts exposed to fully vaccinated index cases was similar to household contacts exposed to unvaccinated index cases (25% for vaccinated vs 23% for unvaccinated)."
No real difference in transmission at all. Actually slightly higher for vaccinated people but let's assume that's not really significant.
On the other side we have anti-vaxxers here too. Who's more harmful?
While most of those points you made here are just overblown generalisations (and probably not even stated in this fashion), none of them are completely wrong. On the anti-vaxxer side we have claims which are not only completely wrong, people literally die because they or others around them believe in them. So again: what's your point?
Seriously - how?
Let's start by agreeing that hospital overload is definitely a bad thing.
Vaccination should help reduce the load, but has anything else been done? Hasn't staff in hospitals decreased over the course of the pandemic? Aren't we funneling tons of money to pharma instead of Frontline workers? What about setting up field hospitals? What about altering the priority access to emergency health care of the unvaccinated?
Hospital overload has been a liminal crisis for the past 2 years, but has yet to materialize as a real issue.
Have we just been getting lucky? narrowly avoiding disaster each wave?
Because this is almost starting to look like a boogeyman that pops up on a regular basis that reminds us that we need to live in fear.
People can go and get a jab. This is easy. Can be done in minutes. No harm done.
You can't build a hospital like that or get personal cloned from some pool of educated personal. Even if we'd have started 2 years ago. Wtf do you want with a field hospital? Those people don't need bandages...what are you talking about??
I know this smokescreen it just came up all over the anti-vaxxer scene. It's a hilarious attempt to cloud their own responsibility and divert the anger away from them. It won't work because it's so cheap and stupid. Especially coming from people who refuse to accept the easiest and fastest solution.
And NO, hospital overload is the only valid point. By spreading and keeping the pandemic running you also ruin peoples lifes economically. People who depend on crowds coming to their store for example or doing sports with them. Than there is long COVID...
Man...this topic is not new. All those ways this is harmful has been presented in the media over the last years. How can you still be so ignoran December 2021????
Field hospitals were proposed early on in 2020, they even sent the medical ship to NY up the Hudson. Its not my idea and it's not a new idea. If you're not aware of that, then I'm sorry for assuming the extent of your awareness.
We don't have to clone anyone. We can do 2 very easy things: 1. Rehire the unvaccinated that were let go. 2. Pay our front line workers more.
Everyone should support this. It's an easy win.
As someone who's unvaccinated and had covid, I honestly don't know what long covid is or why we should be afraid of it anymore than the long term effects of the vaccine.
Though if you fell for one boogeyman, it makes sense that you'd fall for another.
Covid is out of the box, economic damage is inevitable. How much is up to us. If you look at Florida, Sweden, or even the Amish, it's clear lockdowns do more economic harm than covid does.
Last but not least, I'll say it again.
Hospital collapse has been a liminal crisis for 2 years.
We have more vaccinated than ever before yet were still somehow on the brink of collapse. Nothing has been done about it except to scape goat the unvaccinated. People are going to be unvaccinated. The vaccine is going to wear off. Try doing something about it instead of dehumanizing people you disagree with.
Enough is enough.
So this ship was manned by robots or where is the connection to what I wrote?
> We don't have to clone anyone. We can do 2 very easy things: 1. Rehire the unvaccinated that were let go. 2. Pay our front line workers more.
Why would you hire somebody who is unable to do the most basic stuff to protect their patients (get vaccinated). Those people are obviously not suited for their job and I'm happy they are gone. There should be a list so those people never ever end up in a responsible job like that or at least need to get some MPU before they attempt it.
@2 you still won't magically conjure them out of nothing just because you pay them. You need to learn that stuff. It takes time.
> As someone who's unvaccinated and had covid, I honestly don't know what long covid is or why we should be afraid of it anymore than the long term effects of the vaccine.
I can't imagine how somebody can write such a thing December 2021 and still expect to be taken seriously.
You've made up your mind. You have complete confidence and conviction in the vaccine.
That's fine. I respect your right to choose based on your own risk tolerance.
So of course you and other fanatics won't take these points seriously, you think the alt premise is completely illegitimate.
It's a fool errand to try to change the mind of someone who's certain they can't be wrong, so I'm not going to try.
What I am trying to do is explain that after 2 years of worrying trends, events, and numerous unknowns.. it's reasonable to believe we're not getting the full story about the vaccine.
But you know what, I hope I'm wrong. Let's chat again in 5 years, and then we'll know for certain.
Just because YOU didn't have it, doesn't mean nobody else didn't.
I've seen zero convincing evidence of "long covid".
Mostly I see it defined as vague psychological effects .. hard to imagine any universal confounding factors that might result in everyone having a poorer psyche in general in recent history.
The effects last a few weeks on average, 3 months in rare cases. While its odd an ominous for the effects to last that long, there's no reason to believe it will last for years.
And while there are some real permanent effects, like loss of smell + taste, these are extremely rare. Like vaccine induced myocarditis rare, maybe even more so.
Meanwhile, "all cause of death" rates are on the rise, despite ATH vaccination rates. Is that definitely because of "long covid", and definitely not because of the vaccine? That doesn't make sense to me.
Sad.
The handling of those people in the media and the way their opinions are presented equally with scientific facts result in this reluctance politicians displayed in this crisis. Now we all have to suffer because of it. I hope we finally mandatory vaccinations...it's overdue.