I guess I would just throw a few names out there and let you build from there. Disclaimer: I haven't worked with them enough to say they are truly exceptional, but at least they're not from the first category and actually have decent roles:
* La Fosse Associates
* Opus Recruitment Solutions
* Austin Fraser
* Gathered and Found (never heard of this one but got recommended it by someone just now)
Connect with a few people from each, have a few calls and go from there.
*While I have met some downright bad recruiters in my time, I have also met some really great ones, so if anyone wants a connection to one LMK!
That said, I feel that recruiters work harder the farther along you are in your career. They make more as a percentage and they realized that experienced candidates likely have a larger network and will send them more referrals. It's a sales business, they're not stupid.