It shouldn't be recorded in the first place.
That being said, I will never get a Ring doorbell or something similar. I also believe that the tech companies should not be allowed to hoard data about people’s private or public lives at all.
If yes, why them, and not tech firms?
We had abusive neighbours who damaged our belongings before so we essentially had to install a CCTV system. They were coax cameras hooked up to a DVR with no internet functionality (and that data had to be overridden regularly due to the size of the disk).
At the end of the day, if you're under threat of damage to your things, I would recommend a CCTV system. You won't see me recommending Amazon's offerings (or any other "cloud" solution rolls eyes), though.
Any yes, I have been victim of vandalism multiple times. Doesn't mean I want to be surveilled forever. There is no absolute security.
Unless I'm mistaken the UK hasn't drifted off and become and independent island chain separate from Europe
Sometimes people make mistakes, sometimes outright errors. Sometimes people use language to push ideas they like, such as "the EU is Europe" and thus not being a part of the EU is somehow an offence against nature. I'm not sure why these mistakes, errors, and mendacities should go unchallenged and uncorrected.
Every use of "Europe" in that article could be replaced with "EU" and it would be the better for it.
The problem is the there’s no specific term for the people living in either the US or the EU, so we “wrongly” use Americans and European.
Note: I say this as both a US|EU citizen.
Some would argue that's exactly what happened but your point is valid, EU != 'Europe the continent'. The problem is that such imprecise usage is rampant.
I wouldn't say people are "essentially powerless", especially in the EU with GDPR. I can't speak for other parts of the world of course (CCPA is the only thing remotely similar to GDPR that I'm aware of in America).
Question: Wouldn't it be reasonable to have a law that recordings of public areas for the sake of investigation of serious crime be immediately encrypted such that they could only be decrypted by a court order? (Such a law might be enforced by random inspections and huge fines.)
But banning devices from automatically posting everything to the manufacturer's computers without any user intervention is easy, and quite probably enough for the near future.
How about a secret-sharing scheme that requires keys from a certain number of judges?
Now id yo could restrict the police's use of databases to send hate mail to anyone left of the clan (as in Bernie Sanders, not as in left over), that would be a worthy endeavor. But if I have a choice, I'll take a law with teeth and a prosecutor who cares over technology.
The problem is that it is impossible to use public spaces without being recorded -- which is uncomfortable in itself -- and that various people who do not need to have access to the recordings -- which is extra uncomfortable. There is also the unnecessarily large potential for abuse. The default should be that noone has access, and, as far as I can see, it could be.
While I do share your concern, the current rule of thumb - at least in the USA - is that privacy is not expected in public spaces. I can see that since, by definition, that's what makes public public.
I understand that this might not be the law, but I'm interested in if it should be.
But the counter argument would be "Harassed by a doorbell, how so?" and "I have a right to protect my property and my family. My camera allows this to happen."
Unless the legal definition of "in public" changes, the surveillance will continue.
If you take a photo in town square and I'm in the background no worries, that's fine. If you follow me around taking photos of me in town square then that's harassment - not fine.
If your Nest doorbell watches me walk past your house that's also fine. However if your entire street has Nest then has Amazon identified me as having walked down your entire street? If so, that should also be harassment.
The issue isn't that the photo or video was taken, it's the correlation that happens after the fact.
I'm NOT a fan of Teslas sentry mode.
It is? Since how long; when was that law changed?
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/domestic-cctv-usi...
For example
"you should make sure that the information recorded is used only for the purpose for which your system was installed (for example it will not be appropriate to share any recordings on social media sites)"
This is of course routinely ignored and unenforced
I think if you're in public, you should assume you're going to be recorded. I don't think it should be this way, but it is.
I think the inflection point between surveillance and home security is "cloud." The footage should not be accessible to third parties without a warrant, and it should be under the individual's control. Questions of life, limb, and liberty should not be offloaded to unelected, self-interested, profit seeking corporations like Amazon and Google.
So install it for the purpose of sharing on social media. Problem solved!
(I'm only half joking)
People are allowed to take photos and videos on a public area, but aren't allowed to leave a recording device there.
[1] The US is hardly alone in this - they just happen to be the point here.
You typically have to ask for a permit to surveillance any public space and the difficulty of getting one often ranges from hard to illegal.
Alas US cultural hegemony pushes strongly the the rest of the world, especially the western anglosphere
Things like ring doorbells on the other hand should be cracked down - the number of times I see people in the UK posting pictures of public areas on facebook is shocking, but if they're just sat there, being deleted unless pulled for a proper reason, that's fine too.
What really does concern me is when things like image recognition come into the picture. A corporation can't montior me by paying someone to sift through CCTV pictures. They can montior me by using automation to process everything though.
This is a good thing, how successful it is remains to be seen.