News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by ColinWright on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:03AM (#29341429)
You say "There's a formula with a triangle ..." without telling me where. That's not real helpful, and you're making me do the work to find out what you're talking about. If you want assistance to get started, you need to be more explicit.

However, I have done that work, so I've looked, and in the second column of page 210 there's a "formula with a triangle":

t_c = 5 \middot 10^{-5} \sqrt( V / Dt )

... where the "D" I've used is where the triangle appears in the formula.

But that can't be it, because just two lines above it we have:

"For a pulse of width Dt, the critical time ..."

So that's stating that "Dt" is the width of the pulse, and should be thought of as a single term.

So maybe that's the wrong formula, or maybe it was just a bad example. So trying to be more helpful, the "triangle" is a Greek capital delta and means different things in different places. However, it is often used to mean "a small change in".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%94T

FWIW ... at a glance I can't see where that result is derived, it appears simply to be stated without explanation. I might be wrong, I've not read the rest of the paper.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by NamTaf on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:22AM (#29341558)
I feel you're coming at this without appreciating your body of prior knowledge. Intended or not, your statment "But that can't be it, because just two lines above it we have..." assumes a whole lot of knowledge.

You and I both know that it reads as one term, but for someone unfamiliar with calculus but exposed to algebra they are drilled to understand separate graphemes as separate items, because the algebraic 'multiply' is so often implied, e.g. 3x = 3 * x as two individual 'things'.

I think there's merit in explaining the concept of delta representing change, because it's not obvious. For example, when I was taught the concept in school, my teacher explicitly started with doing a finite change with numbers, then representing it in terms of 'x' and 'y', then merged them into the delta symbol. That's a substantial intuitive stepping stone and I think it's pretty reasonable that someone may not find this immediately apparent.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by ColinWright on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:33AM (#29341637)
I agree completely that I'm coming at this with a lot of background knowledge, but if I'm reading in an unfamiliar field and I see a symbol I don't recognise, I look in the surrounding text to see if the symbol appears nearby. As I say, "Δt" appears immediately above ... that's a clue. As you say, it's drilled in at school that everything is represented by a single glyph, and if these are juxtaposed then it means multiplication, and that is another thing to unlearn.

But I think the problem isn't the specifics of the "Δ", it's the meta-problem of believing that symbols have a "one true meaning" instead of being defined by the scope.

I agree that explaining the delta notation would be helpful, but that's like giving someone a fish, or making them a fire. They are fed for one day, or warm for one night, it's the underlying misconceptions that need addressing so they can learn to fish and be fed, or set on fire and be warm, for the remainder of their life.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by NamTaf on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:47AM (#29341759)
I absolutely agree with your comments regarding teaching the underlying approach to digesting a paper. You definitely raise good points, especially the 'one true meaning' comment. I should state that I'm not discounting the value of your point, especially given this clarification, however I guess that when I reflect on my experience in my time learning this, the time I best learnt was via initial expalnation, then worked example, then customary warning of corner-cases and here-be-dragons.

e: I also think, on reflection, that a signfigicant part of your ability to grok a new paper per your comments is your comfort in approaching these concepts due to your familiarity. Think of learning a new language - once you have a feel for it, you're likely more comfortable exploring new concepts within it, however when you're faced with it from the start you probably feel very lost and apprehensive.

I feel that understanding calculus is a fairly fundamental step in the 'language of maths', teaching that symbols don't necessarily represent numbers but can represent concepts (e.g. delta being change). This isn't something you encounter until then, but once you do you begin to understand the characters associated iwth integrals, matricies, etc. in a way that you may not have previously with algebra alone.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by ColinWright on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:57AM (#29341866)
Agreed ... I think we're pulling in the same direction ...
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by erichocean on Thursday November 25, 2021 @02:53PM (#29344432)
> a symbol

That's literally the whole problem: he sees two symbols.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by Someone on Thursday November 25, 2021 @12:58PM (#29343425)
> with calculus but exposed to algebra they are drilled to understand separate graphemes as separate items

But most will already be familiar with the family of goniometric functions such as sin and cos, there’s log and possibly exp and sqrt. There’s min and max; advanced math has inf and sup.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by tomerv on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:10AM (#29341484)
I think that this is indeed the formula in GP's question. And indeed sometimes math notation is obtuse like that. It looks like 2 terms, but the triangle goes together with the t as a single term. At other times it might be called "dt" and despite looking like a multiplication of 2 variables (d and t, or triangle and t in this case) it's just a single variable with a named made of 2 characters.

The important thing here is that "For a pulse of width Dt" is the definition of this variable, but this can be easily missed if you're not used to this naming convention.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by kergonath on Thursday November 25, 2021 @11:27AM (#29342625)
That’s because “Δ” means “a change of” or “an interval of”. So, Δt is “an interval of time”. It is like a compound word, really. It conveys more information than giving it an arbitrary, single-letter name.

This convention is used in a whole bunch of scientific fields, like quantum mechanics, chemistry, biology, mechanics, thermodynamics, etc.

It’s also very useful in how it relates to derivatives, which is a crucial concept in just about any kind of science you could care to mention.

So yes, there is a learning curve, but we write things this way for good reasons, most of the time.

Multiplication should be represented by a (thin) space in good typography, to avoid this sort of things. Not doing it is sloppy and invites misreading. Same with omitting parenthesis around a function’s argument most of the time (e.g. sin 2πθ instead of sin(2 π θ) ).

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by enriquto on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:17AM (#29341533)
> it's just a single variable with a named made of 2 characters.

I have this same problem with programming, when I have to deal with code written by non-mathematicians. They tend to use all these stupid variables with more than one letter and that confuses the heck out of me.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by rullopat on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:13AM (#29341500)
Sorry I didn't mean to make you work for me, but it's a PDF and I didn't know how to explain better the position (maybe I should have told you the first formula on page X).

For you it was a D, for me it was a triangle and I didn't get the meaning of that Dt. Maybe it's just a too advanced paper for my knowledge.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by ColinWright on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:55AM (#29341843)
BTW ... you say:

> Maybe it's just a too advanced paper for my knowledge.

Maybe it is for now ... the point being that if you start at the beginning, chip away at it, search for terms on the 'net, read multiple times, try to work through it, and then ask people when you're really stuck, that's one way of making progress.

You can, instead, enroll in an on-line course, or night-school, and learn all this stuff from the ground up, but it will almost certainly take longer. Your knowledge would be better grounded and more secure, but learning how to read, investigate, search, work, then ask, is a far greater skill that "taking a course".

Others have answered your specific question about the delta symbol, but there are deeper processes/problems/questions here:

* Not all concepts or values or represented by a single glyph, sometimes there are multi-glyph "symbols", such as "Δt" in your example.

* When you see a symbol you don't recognise, read the surrounding text. The symbol will almost always be referenced or described.

* The notation isn't universal. Often it's an aid to your memory, to write in a succinct form the thing that has been described elsewhere.

* In these senses, it's very much a language more akin to natural languages than computer languages. The formulas are things used to express a meaning, not things to be executed.

* Specific questions about specific notation can be answered more directly, but to really get along with mathematical notation you need to "read like math" and not "read like a novel".

* None of this is correct, all of it is intended to give you a sense of how to make progress.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by ColinWright on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:20AM (#29341549)
I'm just saying "D" because I can't immediately type the symbol here and it was easier just to use that. Not least, I didn't know if that was the formula you meant.

But as I say, immediately above the formula it says:

"For a pulse of width ∆t, the critical time ..."

So that really is saying exactly what that cluster of symbols means. There will be things like this everywhere as you read stuff. Things are rarely completely undefined, but you are expected to be reading along.

And you need to work. I just typed this into DDG:

"What does ∆t mean?"

The very first hit is this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_%28letter%29

That gives you a lot of context for what the symbol means, and this is the sort of thing you'll need to do. You need to stop, look at the thing you don't understand, read around in the nearby text, then type a question (or two, or three) into a search engine.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by gspr on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:49AM (#29341786)
I'll use this as an example for the point I'm trying to make in my comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29341727

Please don't take this the wrong way. It is not meant to be demeaning, and it is not meant to be gatekeeping (quite the contrary!). But: If you do not know what a derivative is, then learning that that symbol means derivative (assuming that it does, I have not actually looked at what you link to) will help you next to nothing. OK, you'll have something to google, but if you don't already have some idea what that is, there is no way you will get through the paper that way.

I hope you take this as motivation to take the time to properly learn the fundamentals of mathematics (such as for example calculus for the topic of derivatives).

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by wrycoder on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:53AM (#29341817)
The triangle, or “delta”, is used to indicate a tiny change in the following variable.

Let’s say you go on a journey, and the distance you’ve travelled so far is “x” and the time so far is “t”.

Then your average velocity since the beginning is x / t .

But, if you want to know your current velocity, that would be delta x divided by delta t .

The delta is usually used in a “limiting” sense - you can get a more accurate measurement of your velocity by measuring the change in x during a tiny time interval. The tinier the interval, the more accurate the estimate of current velocity.

What I’m talking about here is the first steps in learning differential calculus. You could look for that at kahnacademy.com. You might also benefit by looking at their “precalculus” courses.

Just keep plugging away at it, the concepts take awhile to seep in. Attaining mathematical maturity takes years.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by simiones on Thursday November 25, 2021 @11:55AM (#29342867)
I would say that delta is typically used to mean difference of any magnitude (i.e. Δt could mean 2 hours).
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday November 25, 2021 @12:24PM (#29343151)
Yes, small changes usually use lowercase delta, e.g. δt. Not to be confused with the derivative symbol dt, nor with the partial derivative symbol ∂t !

Before I continued my maths learning after highschool (ie before UK A-levels) I learnt the Greek alphabet to make it easier to understand maths notations as I could 'voice' (internally) all the funny glyphs adopted from Greek.

At uni I learnt how to properly write an ampersand (for logic classes) and how to write Aleph and Beth (for pure maths, particularly transcendental numbers).

Some professors have a fondness for the more confusing Greek letters (lowercase xi, lowercase eta) ... is it n or eta, epsilon or xi, ...

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by wrycoder on Thursday November 25, 2021 @04:48PM (#29345287)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_sum usually uses ∆. See also the explanation of ∆ at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative#Explanations .

That's the sense in which I'm using ∆, which is common, at least in the US.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by Jensson on Thursday November 25, 2021 @05:00PM (#29345374)
But this is a physics paper, that isn't how you use uppercase delta in physics. It is just a range. In physics however you do a ton of approximations all the time in ways mathematicians hate (you don't care about errors smaller than you can measure), so uppercase delta is often approximated with derivatives etc, but it isn't a derivative. Math in physics is way more practical and uses very different techniques than math in math, often because physicists invented the math first and mathematicians later went and formalized it.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation? by wrycoder on Thursday November 25, 2021 @04:49PM (#29345299)
True. To continue my example, the average velocity in the last hour would be taken with a ∆t of 60 minutes.